Talk:Larry the Cable Guy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Larry the Cable Guy article.
This is not a forum for general discussion about the article's subject.

Article policies
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography. For more information, visit the project page.
??? This article has not yet received a rating on the Project's quality scale. Please rate the article and then leave a short summary here to explain the ratings and/or to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article. [FAQ]

Contents

[edit] Criticism

I visited the page a few months ago, then the "criticism" section was removed. Some angry censors that don't want their baby to be criticized ? Arronax50 01:55, 4 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Humor

I think it should be noted that this guy is not funny. He has tricked everyone into thinking that he is a funny person.

No; that would violate neutral point of view. Not everyone thinks he isn't funny anyway. --Idont Havaname (Talk) 01:34, 19 October 2006 (UTC)

[edit] The Fake Accent

Should it be noted that his southern accent is fake? He grew up in Nebraska, which is a mid-western state. He moved to West Palm Beach, South FL as a teenager, but people don't even have Southern accents there either; a good percentage are uprooted New Yorkers, and some from Jersey and Connecticut, and maybe a few have a twinge of a Floridian accent, but that's nothing like Larry the Cable Guy's accent. He even says in interviews that he willingly "turns on" the accent. 64.12.116.195 05:43, 13 October 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Larry the Cable Guy a "Character", not Person?

Is Larry the Cable Guy just a character that this Daniel person portrays in some real-life situations, like Bob Einstein's Super Dave Osborne, or Sacha Baron Cohen's Borat & Ali G?

And if so, shouldn't this be noted within the page and have the creation of seperate Danny & Larry pages?

RESPONSE REQUESTED

This article even has an entire section devoted Larry's "Fictional Family," which is not the real-life family of Daniel, and within some paragraphs it mentions that Larry the Cable Guy's life is entirely fictional. Wouldn't all this info contribute further reason to call "Larry the Cable Guy" a fictional character whom Daniel Whitney portrays in real-life?

Since Larry the Cable Guy is a fictional character Larry's family is his real family because Larry himself is fictional.--Kevin mills 18:34, 3 March 2007 (UTC)User;Kevin mills

[edit] Feud with David Cross

His feud with fellow comedian/actor David Cross seems notable enough to add, it's also on David's page, and in Larry's book.

[edit] Out of context?

Saw this passage:

Whitney's act has been criticized for having racist and homophobic elements. In his book GIT-R-DONE, he begins a passage about the Abu Ghraib prison scandal: "Let me ask some of these commie rag head carpet flying wicker basket on the head balancing scumbags something!"

I think Larry the Cable Guy is really really unfunny etc but this is just unfair. The quote actually continues, "Why do you hate us?", making the previous sentence a parody of people who use those words. If you want to find an example of him being racist that's great because he's definitely criticized for that, but that quote is out of context.

[edit] Fix Up the Vandalism

There are a number of places in which fans seem to have had their fun. Giving birth to the Antichrist? Mentions of towns in his bibliography? As usual, whether or not the comedian himself is a dunce, his fans sure represent themselves poorly.

It says he lived on a pig farm in Nebraska and was diagnosed in 7th grade as being severely retarded. I don't know about the pig farm (though I find it strange his dad would go from being a pig farmer to being a principal at a private school), but being severely retarded would mean he would probably be incapable of speech. Now I know what you're thinking, he hardly can speak, but it is speech nonetheless.

I've removed the reference to mental retardation. Unless mental retardation is confirmed in a very reliable source, saying in the article that he is mentally retarded is a form of Wikipedia:Vandalism. Comments that people have been adding along with saying he is retarded have violated neutral point of view, as well. --Idont Havaname (Talk) 16:58, 23 October 2006 (UTC)
And I re-removed it after it was put back again. We have to be especially vigilant with vandalism of this nature when it comes to articles on living people, as it could potentially land Wikipedia in some trouble if it's not attended to, like with that article on .. uh, the news guy, I forget off the top of my head. But anyway. Without a source, there's no way that can stay. Errick 04:41, 25 October 2006 (UTC)


[edit] Flea Markets?

I seriously doubt that anyone could have majored in "flea markets" in college. Julyo 21:05, 26 February 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Attention

Please follow the page format when adding to this discussion page. Avengerx 00:42, 15 January 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Git-R-Done

What is the origin of the Git-R-Done Catchphrase? Why is it funny? "Git-R-Done" reroutes to this page, so it seems like there should be an explaination of the phrase. - Anonymous

The origin is more than likely from Get-Her-Done referring to Sexual Intercourse, but not definitly.

[edit] Greatest Comedian POV

I took out the comment about some people considering him one of the greatest comedians of all time. That's a bit NPOV, obviously. I added in something about the conflict between him and his critics, quoting David Cross and Larry/Dan's response to his critics. I think that's reasonable and noteworthy. - swhite

I dont care what you say Larry is no doubt the funniest comedian... -BenR

Have you gone insane? He is not funny but just an idiot.

[edit] Controversy

  • sigh* Now the section about his controversial views reads like a criticism of David Cross. Come on people, be neutral. I'm taking out part of the Cross commentary and just leaving the two competing sides without the additional critique from others.

The comment about how he can't be racist because most of his jokes are directed at his own race is pretty ignorant. He is well known for some pretty incendiary talk regarding Arabs. --Jeff Greco 21:54, 9 December 2005 (UTC)


[edit] LSSU Banished List

I believe the part about his catchphrase being on LSSU's banished words list should be shown on his page because it is relevant to the subject matter. It tells people that it's so popular that it's becoming overused. The banished words list is meant to be humorous and show how bad our society has gotten. OutRider2003 14:41, 9 January 2006 (UTC)

If the catchphrase were really overused in general, then that information would be appropriate for the page. I suspect the phrase isn't overused in general (since I've never heard it), but, either way, the information about LSSU in particular is completely irrelevant. (anon)

[edit] Nebraska

Why is his place of birth listed as NY, I was under the impression that it was Pawnee City Nebraska, or is this bad information? as referenced here http://www.comedycentral.com/comedians/browse/l/larry_the_cable_guy.jhtml

http://www.dead-frog.com/archives/2005/06/larry_the_cable.php

http://music.yahoo.com/ar-304341-bio--Larry-The-Cable-Guy?ev=25023071

the iceman 01:35, 24 January 2006 (UTC)

[edit] charges of racism

"Since most of Whitney's barbs are directed at Rednecks of his own race, charges of racism may be questionable. Whitney has made some off color jokes about Arabs, among other groups."

These two statements seem to be contradictory. I also don't think they really add anything to the article, since the sources are conveniently included, and I think it would be best to take them out. Simply let the reader check the sources if he wishes to investigate the charges further.

I'll do it now, unless someone has other ideas. Ur Wurst Enema 05:48, 30 January 2006 (UTC)

[edit] I went to School with Whitney

Here's some information that may help.

I attended The King's Academy in West Palm Beach Florida from 1978 until 1980. This is a private Christian School which encompassed Pre-kindergarten through 12th grade. It was and is pretty well known in the West Palm Beach area as an upscale school. Dann was a year behind me I believe.

Dan Whitney, known then as Danny Whitney, came in about the same time, apparently moving in from Nebraska. Dan's Father was brought in as the elementary school principal there and was there for either 1 or 2 years. I don't remember specifically.

Danny was a member of the Pep Band, where I think he played Trumpet. I was on the Basketball team and remember Danny at the games. He was a fairly popular kid and something of a class clown. I recall being good naturedly heckled on a few occassions by Danny.

I don't think he graduated from King's though my recollection could be faulty in that regard. He may have left when his Dad ceased his position there. In fairness, I think it's important to note Dan probably got free tuition due to his Dad teaching there and it should not be used to build up some of the info I see here, trying to portray him as a rich kid. Not accurate as far as I can see. We had a lot of red-neck types at King's Academy who lived in Loxahatchee, which is west of West Palm Beach and made up at the time of a successful tradesmen and the like.

Through my brothers who were behind me I know the following:

1. Dan went to college in Georgia to a baptist school. 2. He returned to West Palm Beach Fl (Maybe living in Sanford then but I'm not sure) and at some point working as a bellman at a Ramada Inn in West Palm Beach. 3. He was encouraged by friends to try out at the Comedy Club on Dixie Hwy. 4. He did well and began to be something of a regular. My brothers went to see his act as few times while he was there.

Beyond that, most of the rest of the information I know is already reflected here.

I've tried to contact Dan a few times and to see him following a show here in Washington DC where I now live. E-mail to his web-site get no response. Not surprising, as I'm sure a lot of people try to get in touch with him. I was an acquaintence, not necessarily a friend although, I liked Dan and I'm glad to see him doing well.

My name is Bart Breen. My e-mail is canuckster1127@earthlink.net.

[edit] King's Academy information etc

I restored the info on the early life regarding The King's Academy etc. I was an eyewitness. I knew Dan Whitney at this time in his life.

Please read Wikipedia's policy on Verifiability. You may have known him and all that information is probably true, but the Wikipedia needs information "published by reliable and reputable sources." If you know the claims to be true and have a first hand account of the claims, it shouldn't be too hard to find an informative source(magazine, paper, book, news report, etc.) that will back up these claims. That will give the article much more authority.--Mitaphane 11:12, 8 June 2006 (UTC)
"It shouldn't be too hard to find an informative source ... that will back up these claims." That's not necessarily true. The history of Daniel Whitney is mostly shrouded in mystery, as the only published information about him is about his fictional Larry the Cable Guy character. Given the speculative nature of Whitney's pre-Larry life, I believe it would be appropriate for eye-witness accounts to be offered on this page - not as verifiable fact, but perhaps only as speculation. Brash 15:56, 18 June 2006 (UTC)

I think Danny transfered to Berean Baptist School in West Palm Beach after Kings. Berean was even more fundamentalist than Kings Academy. I was looking at a 1982/83 yearbook and it shows Danny as a member of the senior class.

That's possible. I have Dan in my 1980 Kings Year Book. His Dad left Kings before he graduated and I don't think Danny actusally graduated from Kings. B. Breen

[edit] Video of Daniel pre-Larry

There is a discussion of the authenticity of this video at Snopes:

http://msgboard.snopes.com/message/ultimatebb.php?/ubb/get_topic/f/60/t/001310.html

[edit] Thomas the Tank Engine?

In his credits, Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends is listed. Is that correct? I've probably seen every Thomas related thing on earth a dozen times over, (A 4 year old Train Nut for a son will cause that...) and I'm fairly certain I've never seen him credited, and never heard anything similar to his voice (Either in his Larry Persona, or with the voice as a comedian before he took on that persona.)

Also, IMDB doesn't list it for him, or list him as a credit on the Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends Page.

If this cannot be verified, I'm really doubting the accuracy here.

[edit] Page moves...

Per Wikipedia:Naming conventions, we are supposed to use the name by which he is most well-known as the title of the article. I've moved the page back to Larry the Cable Guy. --Idont Havaname (Talk) 01:12, 19 July 2006 (UTC)

I disagree with this page move. Isn't it more encyclopedic to use the person's real name? Larry's a fictional character, we don't see William Shatner listed as Captain Kirk. If "Larry" really needs an entry, maybe the article should be split off into entries about the character and the actor. From Wikipedia:Naming conventions: "It is important to note that these are conventions, not rules written in stone. As Wikipedia grows and changes, some conventions that once made sense may become outdated, and there may be cases where a particular convention is "obviously" inappropriate." I believe this is such a case. Rob T Firefly 02:25, 20 July 2006 (UTC)
Larry the Cable Guy is credited as Larry the Cable Guy. William Shatner was credited as William Shatner, right? [1] Not Captain Kirk. On the first episode of Blue Collar TV, Larry the Cable Guy was credited in the end credits as Dan Whitney, although in the beginning of the show he was identified as Larry the Cable Guy; all subsequent episodes that I have seen have him credited only as Larry the Cable Guy. Also, comparing current Google News hits heavily favors "Larry the Cable Guy" (272) [2] over "Dan Whitney" (8) [3] or "Daniel Lawrence Whitney" (1) [4] Comparing regular Google searches gives similar numbers. "Larry the Cable Guy" gets over 2.4 million hits [5] compared with 638 for "Daniel Lawrence Whitney" [6] [7] and 43,200 for "Dan Whitney" [8]. So he's definitely going by Larry the Cable Guy. --Idont Havaname (Talk) 19:48, 20 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] git-r-done

I think the phrase git-r-done should be a seperate page altoghether even though larry does use it a lot(too much actually) he didnt invent it


shut the fuck up he made it famous basturd.

I agree it should be it's own page. What does it mean? Mathiastck 21:39, 15 September 2006 (UTC)

I was wondering that too, I've never heard of Larry, but I have heard/seen git R done alot, what the hell does it mean?

Dont talk like that you profane idiots, and it is spelled bastard. Git R Done is a catchphrase used by Larry the Cable Guy No one seems to truly know the origin or meaning.

I agree that there should be a seperate page for the phrase. Also, please limit your profanity and sign your comments with four ~s. JohnWardlow 17:17, 2 March 2007 (UTC)

If you mean me, that was before I joined --Kevin mills 01:12, 22 March 2007 (UTC)Kevin_millss

[edit] Blue collar status

-from main page-"Further criticism has been charged as his bona fidese as a Blue Collar comedian, since his success and merchandise has brought him great sums of money."


The blue collar status is not his financial status its the group he's with. Also the type of comedy its not high brow comedy its "blue collar comedy" None of the guys in Blue collar comedy are hard up for money. This statement should be removed. If inaccurate criticism is allowed you could have pages and pages of misconstrued and inaccurate rumors and verbiage. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 63.163.213.245 (talk) 02:40, 5 December 2006 (UTC).

[edit] Recent edits changing his origin

Specifically http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Larry_the_Cable_Guy&curid=1200093&diff=93395041&oldid=93055776 (I'm not sure how to make that a regular link), many dates were changed to nonsense, and several references to Nebraska were changed to a different city. Subsequent edits restored the dates but didn't change the cities. Are they still correct? Errick 05:12, 11 December 2006 (UTC)

There should be a controversy section on this page. This man is very offensive to many people, myself included because of his remarks about homosexuals and disabled people. These offenses should be noted. I tried to put an entry in for this, but I got accused of vandalizing the page (in case anyone is asking why I don't do it myself).

[edit] Gerbil Vandalism?

Is this edit vandalism? [9] Edit is from an IP with a long history of vandalism, and I can find no references to "A Gerbal named GERBONNUS who is covered in WARTS!!" anywhere else on the Internet. But I'd rather not remove this unless someone with more knowledge of Larry the Cable Guy can verify that this is not a legitimate edit. -Trunkalunk 00:09, 18 December 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Removed content from Family list

I removed this element from the list about his fictional family:

  • A Gerbal named GERBONNUS who is covered in WARTS!!

For this reason: 1. It is formatted badly, with words in all-caps. 2. It is unencyclopedic with the unmerited use of exclamation marks. 3. "Gerbil" is misspelled. 4. It is unsourced, and as such, I am not certain it is true.

If this has been removed in error, please repost this to the section:

Thank you! David 21:34, 18 December 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Censorship?

There are a few sections where certain words have been replaced by a series of pound signs (ex. "#####"). Is this something intentional or should we looking into reverting some of the text? Justin The Claw 08:42, 1 February 2007 (UTC)

Yeah, looks like those were part of an earlier bit of vandalism. Someone fixed part of it, but didn't fix that # signs. I fixed it just now. Errick 21:56, 1 February 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Clarify

The Controversy Section seems incomplete. It does talk about his bigot jokes, but what else about it? It just doesn't seem finished and clear. Thanks, 1312020Wikicop 22:24, 4 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Semi-Protection

We gotta semi-protect this page guys, almost every edit these days is either vandilism or a revert. --Ferdia O'Brien 23:40, 10 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Why all the hate

I know its a little off topic, but why all the hate towards the man, he's and honest hard working guy, if he wants to make fun of people, I say let him. Freedom of speech yo!