Talk:Hydraulic empire
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article is part of Wikipedia:WikiProject Ancient Egypt, a collaborative effort to improve Wikipedia's coverage of Egyptological subjects. If you would like to participate, you can choose to edit the article attached to this page (see Wikipedia:Contributing FAQ for more information). | ||
| Start | This article has been rated as start-Class on the Project's quality scale. | ||
Contents |
[edit] Terminology
Is esper a word? I didn't see it in the dictionary. --Anon
- Neither did I. I've only ever seen it in sci-fi and Japanese contexts. --maru (talk) contribs 02:11, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Marx and hydraulic empires
I thought they were mentioned by Karl Marx. --Anon.
[edit] On the analysis section
- [i]Can this term apply to despotism of the developed world, with its monopoly on technology-development, the "water" of industrialized economies, in its relationship to the developing world? This concept is likely anathema to citizens of the developed world[/i]
The analogy is strained. If you look at technology development, you don't see a fixed size resource. Education, invention, and the application of technology all aren't limited in any fundamental way. Knowledge in particular can be replicated indefinitely. I grant it's possible for a group to control a critical aspect of technology just through their advanced knowledge, but that knowledge can be reinvented or stolen.
Perhaps a better consideration would be security and control. With the increasing power of technology, it is both harder to be secure from harm and harder to control people, society, etc.
- This sentence should be removed as an empty theoretical toss-away that betrays a developing world POV. Absent a specific argument to make for a western hydraulic despotism based on technology, it's little more than a backhanded rhetorical slap.
- To include it, specific reference should be made to someone else's argument, with the logic of the argument summarized in a way that doesn't present the article as supporting it. JJ 18:05, 20 January 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Water empire merged here
See Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Water empire. Johnleemk | Talk 05:39, 5 February 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Deleted this section
In The Constant Feud: Forest Versus Desert, the late Israeli author E. G. Ban used the "hydraulic empire" theory to explain the hostility between the Middle East and Western civilizations, starting with the Persian invasion of Greece, leading through the Punic Wars, the Jewish rebellions against Rome and eventually to the conflicts between the Islamic world and the Western world. In E. G. Ban's view, Middle Easterners hated the Western world because of a feeling of deprivation and envy resulting from the desertification of their own environment.
Deleted this because it's not relevant - how does the idea of envy on the part of "Middle Easterners" (a questionable term) resulting from the desertification of their own environment, relate to the concept of the hydraulic empire, as defined elsewhere in the piece?
As well as being irrelevant, it's a highly questionable thesis (I would say, "drivel"), and not substantiated or supported by third-party references - the work of a non-canonical author included seemingly arbitrarily; furthermore it links within the paragraph (not in the footnotes) to an external site, so I'm frankly suspicious of the motives behind its inclusion.
[edit] SF
I removed some parts from the "Examples in SF" section. It's simply too long compared to the rest of the article and while that concept is common in SF which may merit a section it shouldn't dominate the article.
- When brought to planetary level, hydraulic despotism exists in its purest form among the Fremen of Arrakis. Water among the Fremen is life and can be seen from the fact that Fremen recycle water from their dead's blood. A quote from the O.C. Bible in the novel states "From water does all life begin".
the society of the Fremen was tribal, not a hydraulic empire
- Destiny's Road by Larry Niven (1998) is another example: the seeds called "speckles" contain a nutrient missing in the colonized planet's biosphere. Deficiency of said nutrient results in dimnished mental capacity which may be permanent if prolonged or it occurs early during a child's development, and can also result in death.
- The Sten Chronicles series of books by Allan Cole and Chris Bunch (8 books): Anti-Matter Two is a safer, more controllable form of anti-matter, and only the Eternal Emperor knows the manufacturing process and is zealous in its sale and use.
- Also in the movie Total Recall the oxygen injected into the Martian colonies where humans live is controlled by a totalitarian government.
- In the film adaptation of Tank Girl, the tyrannical Water & Power company controls Earth's remaining fresh water.
A section with examples from movies/sf etc. on wikipedia opens Pandora's Box. The first two examples are elaborate and fitting and after that comes an overly long list of obscure and pointless examples put in in later edits. I don't doubt that there are hundreds of works that have something remotely resembling a hydraulic empire but we don't have to mention every single one because the section says "Examples" not "Exhaustive List". I left the (probably) most well-known example -Dune- and the example that seems to best fit the topic. 62.245.161.201 17:11, 6 January 2007 (UTC)
- No, Destiny's Road is definitely the better example as it's central to the plot. A World Out of Time is barely memorable, though I do agree that the Pak/TlO is totally off the mark. Other examples in Niven's bibliography are Smoke Ring and Building Harlequin's Moon --Belg4mit 06:57, 25 January 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Additions
Arguably, the Incas should be a see also, but probably not until that entry is updated. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Belg4mit (talk • contribs) 07:30, 25 January 2007 (UTC).
