Talk:Harpers
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
harpers should go directly to the magazine. The magazine is widely known as simply "Harpers", and is more important than forgotten realms. Comments? Stbalbach 14:26, 1 May 2005 (UTC)
- Importance is graded by the individual. At any rate, the actual shortened name of the magazine - Harper's - already redirects there. Harpers would only be searched for by mistake. -Erolos 21:02, 2 May 2005 (UTC)
- i disagree - search for the term "Harpers" on any search engine, and the first four or five links will all be related to the magazine. in fact the first "Harpers" wikipedia link that shows up on google is the link to the "Harper's Magazine" page. i think that:
- "Harpers" should redirect to Harper's Magazine
- this page should be renamed Harpers (Forgotten Realms)
- finally the Harper's Magazine page should contain a line at the top stating "Harpers redirects here. For the Forgotten Realms Organization named Harpers, see Harpers (Forgotten Realms)
- though i'm open to other solutions. cheers! :) 192.223.226.6 16:08, 12 January 2007 (UTC)
- the page on Johann Sebastian Bach works this way as well 192.223.226.6 16:17, 12 January 2007 (UTC)
- i disagree - search for the term "Harpers" on any search engine, and the first four or five links will all be related to the magazine. in fact the first "Harpers" wikipedia link that shows up on google is the link to the "Harper's Magazine" page. i think that:
