Talk:Gripping hand

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I used this the other day without even thinking about it and got quizzical looks from my coworkers! :-) -- WhiteDragon 06:03, 9 Apr 2004 (UTC)

I use it all the time - I think in threes and fives, so it comes quite naturally - and make a point of linking to this article whenever I do it online. - Korivak 20:07, August 4, 2005 (UTC)

I am not a "particularly devoted fan of Niven and Pournelle" but I use this all the time. Whoever I am.

I don't know if this article gives the best explanation; one of the characters in the book describes it as an illustration of 'Aristotelian logic'. My understanding was it was a nice way of expressing the dialectic form of reasoning: 'on the one hand' = the thesis: 'on the other hand' = antithesis: 'on the gripping hand' = synthesis: we can't actually say this, as symetrical beings, though the phrase 'on the other hand' sort of implies it,so its nice to have a way of doing so. On the other hand,it doesn't help that some of the examples in the book aren't clear, and fit the description in the article. The gripping hand is, does anybody think the article should be amended to reflect this?

I always thought the "gripping hand" was meant to underline an important consideration with the decision to be made, such as the two options may be irrelevant and potentially harmful in the light of some other circumstance 128.113.148.163 13:29, 2 February 2007 (UTC)