Government simulation game

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

A government simulation or political simulation is a type of game that attempts to simulate the government and politics of all or part of a nation. These games may include geopolitical situations (involving the formation and execution of foreign policy), the creation of domestic political policies, or the simulation of political campaigns. They differ from the genre of classical wargames due to their discouragement or abstraction of military or action elements. [1]

Contents

[edit] Background

A screenshot from the 2005 computer adapation of Diplomacy, first created as a board game in 1954
A screenshot from the 2005 computer adapation of Diplomacy, first created as a board game in 1954

Before the emergence of personal computers and their ability to quickly process large amounts of statistical data, games based on geopolitics and elections had already existed for years. One of the earliest such games was The Game of Politics, created by Oswald Lord in 1935[2] which remained in print until 1960. In 1954, the board game Diplomacy was created, which differs from other wargames in that it features a "negotiation" phase during which players reach agreements with other players, and then execute military moves simultaneously.[3] National politics has remained a vital area of board gaming, with products such as the 1986 board game Die Macher featuring elections in Germany[4], and "Wreck the Nation" which satirizes the politics of the United States under the Bush administration.[5]

After enjoying years as a play-by-mail game, Diplomacy was one of the first games to move to take advantage of e-mail, and continues to be a popular email game as of 2007.[6]

[edit] Computer Gaming

A screenshot from the Atari ST version of Balance of Power
A screenshot from the Atari ST version of Balance of Power

As computers became more sophisticated, games in this genre moved beyond e-mail to more complex simulations. One of the earliest titles in this genre was Balance of Power, designed by Chris Crawford and published in 1985. This game features conflict at the height of the Cold War, using political and policy decisions to shape outcomes rather than warfare. [7][8] In Balance of Power, any armed conflict between the player and the opponent superpower results in a nuclear war, which is considered a loss condition.

Other Cold War era games included Conflict: Middle East Political Simulator created by Virgin Interactive, and Spectrum Holobyte's Crisis in the Kremlin. "Conflict" simulated a hypothetical situation in 1997 in which the player assumed the role of the Israeli Prime Minister and was obligated to employ various diplomatic and covert directives to defeat its rival nations. Surrounded by hostile nations, the player was restrained by a very limited military force and was thereby encouraged to employ peaceful means to remain in power until he acquired more advanced weapons systems and power.[9]

In Crisis in the Kremlin, the user could play as any of the three Soviet politicians Mikhail Gorbachev representing the reform party, Yegor Ligachev, the leader of the hard line party and Boris Yeltsin who was the prevalent figure of the nationalist party. The player could use the simulation to test certain strategies to lead the failing Soviet Union into a new era of prosperity or force its dissolution and integration into the new world order. This game introduced the concept of budget management, citizen and faction satisfaction as well as multiple economic values and political spectrum.[10][11]

Early political simulation games were intended more for education than entertainment. In 1987, "On the Campaign Trail" was developed as a tool at Kent State University's political campaign management program, and engaged students in decision-making regarding the campaigns for United States Senate elections between 1970 and 1986.[12] Subsequently, a commercial market developed for packaged games involving elections and campaigns.

A screenshot from Stardock's Political Machine game
A screenshot from Stardock's Political Machine game

The 1993 game Power Politics focused on domestic United States political campaigns (but not the running of the country upon election). In 1998, this was adapted to the Doonesbury Election Game, designed by Randy Chase and published by Mindscape, in which players conducted a campaign with the assistance of a pool of advisors selected from characters in the Doonesbury comic strip.[13] A successor product entitled Power Politics III is currently in development by Kellogg Creek Software.[14] In 2004, Stardock published Political Machine, in which the player steers a candidate through a 41-week election cycle for United States President, developing policies and tailoring talk show appearances and speech content. The game is heavily tied to modern polling methods, using real-time feedback for how campaign strategy impacts polling numbers. [15]

Some games in the genre involve enacting policies and budget decisions to sway voters. One such game is Democracy, published in 2005 by Positech Games. In Democracy, players make decisions during each turn regarding which policies to support. As turns progress, the player views how their favorability rating changes amongst certain types of voters. Candidates make promises before each election, and failure to follow-through can result in lower support during the player's reelection campaign.[16]

There are also forum-based roleplaying games of government simulation[1] and nation simulation[2].

[edit] Related Games

A mature city from SimCity 4
A mature city from SimCity 4

While most games in this genre are turn-based strategy games, some games have incorporated the core theme of politics in other formats. A Mind Forever Voyaging, published by Infocom in 1985, was an interactive fiction game in which the player controlled a sentient computer capable of experimenting with potential future scenarios based on varying public policy decisions. Newsweek said of the game, "It isn't '1984,' but in some ways it is even scarier."[17]

Another game that departs from the typical features of the genre, but relies heavily upon the management of public budgets and policies within a non-violent framework is the Sim City series of games, published by Maxis. Sim City features a real-time environment in which the player can create zones for city development, build roads, power and water utilities, and watch as their city develops based on their decisions. The game was originally published in 1989 and as of 2003 was in its fourth major release.[18]

[edit] Training and Education

Beyond entertainment, these games have practical applications in training and education of government personell. Training simulations have been created for subjects such as managing law enforcement policies (such as racial profiling), the simulation of a military officer's career, and hospital responses to emergency situations.[19]

[edit] Popular Culture

The 1983 film WarGames features a fictional government simulation program called "global thermonuclear war," which was originally intended by its creators as a simulation of the events leading up to a Cold War era atomic war. Like Balance of Power, an ending that resulted in nuclear war was considered a loss.

[edit] References

  1. ^ Tom Leupold (2004-08-12). Spot On: Games get political. Gamespot. Retrieved on January 7, 2007.
  2. ^ Time Magazine, Feb. 03, 1936, "Monopoly & Politics," http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,755767-1,00.html
  3. ^ Allan B. Calhamer, Europa Express #10, "The Roots of Diplomacy," http://www.diplom.org/Zine/S1998R/Calhamer/invention.html
  4. ^ Erik Arneson, "Playing Politics," http://boardgames.about.com/library/weekly/aa061399.htm
  5. ^ BuzzFlash Reviews, http://www.buzzflash.com/store/reviews/274
  6. ^ Jim Burgess, "Play-by-Mail Diplomacy vs Play-by-Email Diplomacy," http://www.diplomacy-archive.com/resources/postal/pbm-vs-pbem.htm
  7. ^ Chris Crawford (2003), Chris Crawford on Game Design, ISBN 0131460994
  8. ^ Robert Mandel, The Journal of Conflict Resolution, Vol. 31, No. 2 (Jun., 1987), "An Evaluation of the 'Balance of Power' Simulation," pp. 333-345, http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0022-0027(198706)31%3A2%3C333%3AAEOT%22O%3E2.0.CO%3B2-5
  9. ^ Zzap! Issue 70, February 1991, p.48, "Conflict: the Middle East Political Simulator," http://amigareviews.classicgaming.gamespy.com/conflict.htm
  10. ^ Home of the Underdogs - Entry: Crisis in the Kremlin. Retrieved on January 7, 2007.
  11. ^ Social Science Computer Review, Vol. 12, No. 3, 447-448 (1994), "Software Reviews: Crisis in the Kremlin"
  12. ^ Nadine S. Koch, "Winning Is Not the Only Thing 'On the Campaign Trail': An Evaluation of a Micro-Computer Campaign Simulation," PS: Political Science and Politics, Vol. 24, No. 4 (Dec., 1991), pp. 694-698, http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=1049-0965%28199112%2924%3A4%3C694%3AWINTOT%3E2.0.CO%3B2-4&size=LARGE
  13. ^ IGN: The Doonesbury Election Game, http://pc.ign.com/objects/659/659635.html
  14. ^ Kellogg Creek Software, http://www.powerpolitics.us/about.htm
  15. ^ Jason Silverman (2004), "Wired News: Campaign Game Mimics Real Life," http://www.wired.com/news/games/0,2101,64625,00.html
  16. ^ James Allen, Out of Eight PC Game Reviews, Democracy Review, http://jaguarusf.blogspot.com/2005/12/democracy-review.html.
  17. ^ MobyGames, A Mind Forever Voyaging, http://www.mobygames.com/game/a-mind-forever-voyaging/adblurbs
  18. ^ IGN, Sim City 4 Review, http://pc.ign.com/articles/382/382583p1.html
  19. ^ The Examiner, "Simulation games help prepare government, unite local businesses," http://www.examiner.com/a-493527~Simulation_games_help_prepare_government__unite_local_businesses.html

[edit] See also