Talk:Gordon Strachan/Comments

I was wavering between B and start but thought that the amount of detail just about swung it into B.

Strengths:

Written in a neutral, non-POV manner.
The article's statistics, both through the managerial stats table and the infobox, are good.
Content since his move into management is quite detailed and informative.
Managerial style section is well referenced and informative.
A link to wikiquote.
Some external links and a lot of wiki-links through templates etc.

Weaknesses:

Not many references for an article of its size.
Virtually nothing about his time with Dundee, eg when was his senior debut.
Not much detail on his time with Aberdeen, short of a list of what he won.
Virtually nothing about his Pilton upbringing, early life, supporting Hibs and why he didn't sign for them.
Could do with a picture or two.
Several more external links would be good, possibly something referenced from his autobiography.
An Honours section might improve the article.

All IMO, of course. Caledonian Place 18:16, 3 April 2007 (UTC)