From a Distance
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
| "From a Distance" | |
 Cover of the 1990 – 7" single by Bette Midler |
|
| Written by | Julie Gold |
|---|---|
| Published | 1987 |
| Language | English |
| Original artist | Nanci Griffith |
| Recorded by | Nanci Griffith
Others (selected): |
The song, "From a Distance" was written in 1985 by American singer-songwriter Julie Gold. Gold was working as a secretary at the time for HBO and writing songs in her free time. [1] Gold's friend, Christine Lavin introduced the song to Nanci Griffith who first recorded for her 1987 release, Lone Star State of Mind. It quickly became a favorite of Griffith's fans around the world. The song became an international commercial success after it was recorded in 1990 by Bette Midler for the album Some People's Lives, and went on to win a Grammy for Song of the Year in 1991.
Bette Midler re-recorded a christmas version for her 2006 Christmas Album, Cool Yule, with additional lyrics by Midler, Robbie Buchanan and Jay Landers. Additional recordings of the original have been performed by Gold, Griffith, Simon Nicol (of Fairport Convention) and many others. The song has also been sung by a number of childrens' school choirs.
Much of the song's popularity coincided with the first Persian Gulf War. It received a "Minute Man Award" from the United States Army for inspiring the troops and a "Seven Seals Award" from the Department of Defense.
The song also won a "3 Million Airs Award" from BMI.
Contents |
[edit] Interpretation
The song seems to be about how distance, both physical and emotional, can change perceptions, though perhaps not always for the better. It has a hopeful message about how God is watching us, suggesting that, even though there are wars, cruelty, calamity, and want, somehow, someway, we may yet have a little peace and love in this world.
Another interpretation is that the perception of love and peace only exists "from a distance" and that the reality is not being addressed. It suggests that God doesn't actually act on our problems, and is only an observer. From a distance "no one is in need," and "there are no hungry mouths to feed." "God is watching us from a distance." In other words, God is so far from human experience as to not be able to see, and thus respond, to hunger or need. Hardly a message of hope.
[edit] Charts
| Date | Recording artist | Country | Chart | Peak |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1990 | Bette Midler | US | Billboard Adult Contemporary | 1 |
| 1990 | Bette Midler | US | The Billboard Hot 100 | 2 |
| Oct 1990 | Cliff Richard | UK | UK Singles Chart | 11 |
| Dec 1990 | Bette Midler | US | ARC Weekly Top 40 | 1 |
| Jan 1991 | Bette Midler | Australia | ARIA Chart | 8 |
| June 1991 | Bette Midler | UK | UK Singles Chart | 6 |
The Bette Midler album, Some People's Lives also peaked at number 6 in the Billboard 200.
[edit] Put-downs and parodies
The Bette Midler recording of the song ranked at number 37 on VH1's list of the "50 Most Awesomely Bad Songs Ever." [2] and ranked at number 14 on Blender Magazine's list of "The 50 Worst Songs Ever". [3] Criticisms focus on the song's lyrical content and the production of Midler's version, suggesting the single offers "liberal homilies, stiff rhymes and more sound F/X than a Mel Gibson movie." [3] Blender's editors declare the "Worst Moment" to result from the use of the drum machine, stating, "If God exists, He probably hates drum machines." [3]
In 1992, singer-songwriter Jay Mankita wrote a parody, "From a Dog's Stance", which appeared in Sing Out! magazine and was later included on his recording, Dogs Are Watching Us. [4] Mankita adopts the viewpoint of the canine rather than the devine:
| From a dog's stance, we all have enough... |
| so why not give dogs more? |
| From a dog's stance, dogs can't comprehend... |
| what all these cats are for. |
| From a dog's stance, we are waitresses... |
| marching to the kitchen now. |
| Bringing bowls of food...Make that "people" food... |
| That's the stance of every dog. [4] |
The song has also been satirized by singer-songwriter Sue Trainor in her "In a Closeup". [5] According to a Washington Post review, "Trainor seems to genuinely admire 'From a Distance', Julie Gold's anthem of universal brotherhood, for she treats the hymn-like melody with great respect. She changes the lyrics, though, and instead of waxing poetic about the beauty of the world 'from a distance', she points out how flawed it all looks 'in a closeup'." [6]
[edit] External links
- Lyrics.
- "From a Distance" review at All Music Guide
- "From a Distance" at Songfacts
- Video of Julie Gold's Grammy Acceptance
- Bette Midler video at YouTube
[edit] Notes and sources
- ^ official Julie Gold Biography
- ^ VH1 "50 Most Awesomely Bad Songs Ever" countdown
- ^ a b c "Run for Your Life! It's the 50 Worst Songs Ever!" by John Aizlewood, Clark Collis, Steve Kandell, Ben Mitchell, Tony Power, James Slaughter, Rob Tannenbaum, Mim Udovitch, Rene Vienet and Jonah Weiner, Blender (view article)
- ^ a b "From a Dog's Stance" lyrics from official Jay Mankita web site
- ^ In a Closeup, album by Sue Trainor
- ^ "Trainor's Reverent Poke at Folk" by Geoffrey Himes, The Washington Post, April 30, 1993
