Ecotax
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Ecotax, short for Ecological taxation, can refer to:
- A fiscal policy that introduces taxes intended to promote ecologically sustainable activities via economic incentives. Such a policy can complement or avert the need for regulatory approaches. Often, such a policy intends to maintain overall tax revenue by proportionately reducing other taxes, e.g. on human labor and renewable resources, in which case it is known as the green tax shift towards ecological taxation.
- The Pigovian taxes that are introduced by such a policy - see below.
Contents |
[edit] Taxes affected
Examples of taxes which could be lowered by a green tax shift:
- Payroll, income, and (to a lesser extent) sales taxes.
- Corporate taxes (taxes on investment and entrepreneurship).
- Property taxes on buildings and other infrastructure.
Examples of ecotaxes which could be implemented or increased:
- Carbon taxes on the use of fossil fuels.
- Severance taxes on the extraction of mineral, energy, and forestry products.
- Licence fees for fishing and hunting.
- Specific taxes on technologies and products which are associated with substantial negative externalities.
- Garbage disposal taxes and refundable fees.
- Taxes on effluents, pollution and other hazardous wastes.
- Site value taxes on the unimproved value of land.
[edit] General remarks
Ecotaxes are often proposed by Green political parties and conservationist interest groups.
Tax shifting usually includes balancing taxation levels to be revenue-neutral for government and to maintain overall progressivity.
Taxes on consumption may take the feebate approach advocated by Amory Lovins in which additional fees on less sustainable products — such as sport utility vehicles — are pooled to fund subsidies on more sustainable alternatives — such as hybrid electric vehicles.
The object of a green tax shift is often to implement a "full cost accounting", using fiscal policy to internalize market distorting externalities, which leads to higher efficiency and sustainable wealth creation.
Although ecotaxes or green taxes are often opposed by conservative groups (or proposed by environmentalist movements), they are not easily characterized in this way. Basic economic theory recognizes the existence of externalities and their potential negative effects. To the extent that green taxes correct for externalities such as pollution, they correspond with mainstream economic theory. In practice, however, setting the correct taxation level or the tax collection system needed to do so is difficult, and may lead to further distortions or unintended consequences.
[edit] Progressive or Regressive?
Some green tax shift proposals have been criticized as being fiscally regressive (a tax with a marginal rate that decreases as the taxpayer's income increases). Taxing negative externalities usually entails exerting a burden on consumption, and since the poor consume more and save or invest less as a share of their income, any shift towards consumption taxes is considered regressive. However, conventional regulatory approaches will affect prices in much the same way, while lacking the revenue-recycling potential of ecotaxes. Moreover, correctly assessing distributive impact of any tax shift requires specifics, eg. is the increase in the (moderately regressive) carbon tax more than offset by the decrease in the (highly regressive) payroll tax? Some proponents claim a second benefit of increased employment or lower health care costs as the market and society adjust to the new fiscal policy. These claims, as with the claim "tax cuts create jobs" are often difficult to prove or disprove even after the fact.
[edit] Ecotax policies enacted
An ecotax has been enacted in Germany by means of three laws in 1998, 1999 and 2002. The first introduced a tax on electricity and petroleum, at variable rates based on environmental considerations; renewable sources of electricity are not taxed. The second adjusted the taxes to favor efficient conventional power plants. The third increased the tax on petroleum. At the same time, income taxes were reduced proportionally so that the total tax burden remained constant.
[edit] Registration taxes
The Netherlands and Portugal have introduced differentiations into their car registration taxes to encourage car buyers to opt for the cleanest car models.
In the Netherlands, the new registration taxes, payable when a car is sold to its first buyer, can earn the owner of a hybrid a discount up to €6000.
Austria has had a registration tax based on fuel consumption for several years.
See also : Vehicle registration plate
[edit] See also
- Sin Tax
- Energy Tax Act
- Green politics
- Nuclear power phase-out
- Free-market environmentalism
- Pigovian tax
[edit] External links
- Redefining Progress
- Sightline Institute's research and resources on green taxes
- Creative Taxing Can Save the Environment
- Fiscallygreen.ca
- Earthrights.net
- A Distributional Analysis of Green Tax Reforms - Gilbert E. Metcalf
- WorldMoralMovement.org - Green tax as part of a moral tax code
- noe21 - capacity and action centre promoting solutions to global climate change
- GreenTaxSwitch.com - campaign by the Liberal Democrats in the UK for a switch to green taxes
- STERN REVIEW: The Economics of Climate Change - An executive summary of a report by economist Nicholas Stern (27pg pdf file)
- BBC article on Stern's Report