Doctor Bashir, I Presume?

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode
"Doctor Bashir, I Presume?"
Dr. Bashir with his parents
Episode no.	114
Prod. code	514
Airdate	February 24, 1997
Writer(s)	Ronald D. Moore Jimmy Diggs
Director	David Livingston
Guest star(s)	Brian George as Richard Bashir Max Grodenchik as Rom Chase Masterson as Leeta Fadwa El Guindi as Amsha Bashir J. Patrick McCormack as Bennett Robert Picardo as Zimmerman
Year	2373
Episode chronology
Previous	"By Inferno's Light"
Next	"A Simple Investigation"

"Doctor Bashir, I Presume?" is an episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, the sixteenth episode of the fifth season. It features a familiar face from Star Trek: Voyager, Robert Picardo, playing the creator of the Doctor, his main Star Trek: Voyager character. Of greater significance to Deep Space 9's lore, however, is a major twist in Julian Bashir's back-story.

1 Plot Summary
2 Notes
3 See also
4 External links

[edit] Plot Summary

Spoiler warning: Plot and/or ending details follow.

Dr. Lewis Zimmerman comes to Deep Space Nine with the intent of using Dr. Bashir's physical and personality likeness as a template for a long-term medical hologram (as opposed to the short-term Emergency Medical Hologram installed on such ships as USS Voyager and the Enterprise-E). In order to make the hologram as robust as possible, Zimmerman needs a complete personality profile on Bashir. In addition to questioning Bashir himself, Zimmerman interviews Bashir's colleagues and makes arrangements – against Bashir's wishes – to invite his estranged parents, Amsha and Richard Bashir, to the station.

Julian is embarrassed by his father's tendency toward hyperbole, for example referring to the time he "ran shuttles" when, in fact, Richard was merely a steward who was fired shortly into the career. Bashir implores his parents at dinner not to reveal to Zimmerman anything about a secret from his childhood. Later, his parents go to the infirmary to try to assuage their son's fears, stating emphatically that they will not tell Zimmerman that they had Julian genetically modified when he was a child. They point out that they have kept the secret since he was a child, and that because such modification is illegal in the United Federation of Planets, they, too, are criminally culpable.

However, Bashir's parents are unaware that rather than speaking to their son, they are speaking to Zimmerman's new hologram; Zimmerman and Chief O'Brien, who is assisting Zimmerman, are right around the corner. O'Brien informs Julian about what he heard and Julian confirms that he had been genetically modified. As a child, he reveals, he was a poor student who seemed destined to failure. His parents took him to Adigeon Prime for DNA resequencing, greatly improving his intelligence and dexterity. With the secret out, Bashir sees no alternative but to resign from Starfleet.

However, before Bashir can file his resignation, his parents take things into their own hands. Richard strikes a deal with the Starfleet Judge Advocate General's Rear Admiral Bennett: Richard will spend two years in prison for his and his wife's crime, and Bashir is allowed to retain his commission.

In the midst of all this, Zimmerman pursues Leeta's affections, to the point of asking her to accompany him back to Jupiter Station to open her own bar. Shy Rom is too scared to say anything to convince her to stay, despite it being clear that Leeta would welcome any reason to stay with him. She is on the verge of getting onto a transport with Zimmerman when Rom careens around the corner and asks Leeta to stay – to which she agrees.

Spoilers end here.

[edit] Notes

This marks Bashir's parents' first appearance. Their strained relationship with Julian in this episode retroactively explains Bashir's awkward decline of Odo's offer to pass on his regards to friends or family on Earth in "Homefront".
This is the second and last time a holographic communications device appears, just a few episodes after its first appearance in "For the Uniform". For the same reason its first appearance allows for a more dramatic interaction between Sisko and Michael Eddington, its second appearance allows Admiral Bennett's speech about the hazards of genetic engineering to come across more forcefully than it would coming from a desktop view screen.
Although Bennett is referred to as a rear admiral, he wears a four-pip rank insignia; while he titularly ranks below a vice admiral, his insignia sports more pips than vice admirals' three-pip devices. Additionally, other rear admirals (e.g. Erik Pressman) have worn two-pip devices. All considered, Bennett's rank insignia is in all likelihood a costuming error.
Some fans have noted a serious inconsistency between this episode and the second season Star Trek: The Next Generation episode Unnatural Selection - under the interpretation of Federation law given in Doctor Bashir, I Presume? the actions of the Gagarin IV scientists could not have been legal. It would seem highly unlikely that Captain Picard and his crew could have been ignorant of the law, and that Picard should not have arrested the scientists since they were Federation citizens.

[edit] See also

Khan Noonien Singh – Genetically-altered superman whose actions contributed to the ban on genetic engineering
"Space Seed" – Khan's first appearance
"Statistical Probabilities" – Introduces characters whose genetic engineering did not go as well as Bashir's.