Talk:Dandruff
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] Vandalism
I just deleted the whole Seborrhic Dematitis, because it was just a bunch of random letters. Dappled Sage 03:57, 25 February 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Is dandruff contagious ?
discussion copied from wikipedia:reference desk (Jun 12 2004)
As the article states, various things can cause dandruff. seborrheic dermatitis and psoriasis is not contagious. However, I did some reading a little while ago about staph and strep (both mentioned in the dandruff article) in relation to dermatitis and I got the impression that most people are carriers of the bacterium but those with conditions which cause the skin to flake (like those I've just mentioned) are responsible for spreading the bacterium widely in a community. However, I seem to remember that spreading the bacterium does not spread dermatitis (and, by extension, a flaky scalp). I believe those suffering from dermatitis do tend to have higher incidence of staph and/or strep infection, though. But it would be nice if someone with more expert knowledge could confirm that.
Looking at the question another way: lets imagine that dandruff is contagious. I would then expect to see campaigns in our schools about scalp hygiene in the same vein as we have in the UK about lice and I would expect people with dandruff to be far more outcast and shunned than they are. --bodnotbod 18:49, Jun 9, 2004 (UTC)
It seems that large chunks of text in this article come directly from the external link given ([1]). Copyvio? 129.2.211.72 23:54, 6 Jan 2005 (UTC)
- I did a large portion of the rewriting and reorganization of this article, and I can tell you that everything from external sources, except direct quotes, was paraphrased and reorganized. So, without comaring the external link to the article in depth, I can tell you that either 1) the external link copied it from here, or 2) there is a common source and similarity in wording is coincidence, because it was definitely not copied from the external source. CyborgTosser (Only half the battle) 09:18, 9 Jan 2005 (UTC)
Article quotes from Joseph P. Bark, M.D. Do we have permission?
- I'm pretty sure this is fair use, but if possible, we should have a reference to the original interview. Unfortunately I didn't add it when I did the reorganizing and now I am having trouble finding the original source. CyborgTosser (Only half the battle) 07:14, 14 Mar 2005 (UTC)
Simple dandruff does not cause hair loss. Philiphughesmd 04:33, 10 December 2005 (UTC)
[edit] Effective Shampoos?
The article refers to salicylic acid shampoos as the 'gold standard' of dandruff treatment, and to other brand as 'less effective', but it lists no evidence of this or explain why this is - whether it's true or not, it comes off as someone trying to take down Head and Shoulders, or something. Any references to support this? Aerothorn 18:48, 12 February 2006 (UTC)
- The gold standard of treatment is Selsun Blue with selenium sulfide. Other shampoos are inferior. <- clearly not NPOV unless backed up! (this is ZoFreX, too tired to log in)
- PLEASE SIGN YOUR POSTS WITH FOUR TILDES (~ x4). Stovetopcookies 23:33, 10 January 2007 (UTC)
there are different kind of shampoo for the different kind to dandruff.... saying that a shampoo is the best is a non-sens!
I find the idea that not applying shampoo to your hair on a regular basis preserves your oily base on your scalp instead of overusing shampoo and conditioner that will dry out your scalp. This is of course opinion and I'd love to see if research has been conducted since it would be radical enough to cause detriment to the preconceived notion of always 'rinsing and reusing' during each shower.
Also, does dandruff affect longhaired men or is this only a shorthair problem?
--Jmnage 18:19, 23 March 2006 (UTC)
- I find that mine gets worse when my hair is longer. Jack Cain 21:58, 23 March 2006 (UTC)
I used to have terrible dandruff; not even the "anti-dandruff" shampoos would get rid of it to a satisfactory standard. To my surprise, one use of common baby shampoo eliminated it almost instantly, and on a second usage it was completely stripped (at least 99.99%) of the white flakes! I discovered it through Lifehacker80.47.196.152 22:32, 30 July 2006 (UTC)
- Something similar. I've had dandruff for ages, and have tried many different varieties, but then somebody gave me Selsun Blue AND told me to use it only once a week, while using Baby Shampoo rest of the week. Works like a charm, and I have been free from dandruff for some time now :) So, I think that combination of anti-dandruff (try several untill you find what works best for you) and baby shampoo is best. Shinhan 18:08, 8 September 2006 (UTC)
[edit] a dandruff sufferer
i have suffered dandruff for nearly 20 years, i have now been reguarly using coal tar shampoo for several years and it has only made perhaps a slight bit of difference as my jacket at work reguarly shows white specks.In my teens you could visibly see the dandruff on the back of my head even after a wash -which caused me enormous disconsertion and withdrawal, it isnt that bad now but nevertheless my barber makes a mention of my dandruff problem every time he cuts my hair and has suggested rubbing mustard oil on a towel after washing my hair -not to keen to try this as it will make my hair prematurely oily.Furthermore there is no flakeiness elsewhere on me and there are no itching problems with the dandruff. problem with coal tar shampoos is that they apparently become less effective after a certain while, also it is very true that oily hair causes dandruff as i have this as well. the psychological effects are the most damaging as i have suffered considerable years of unemployment due to low self esteem and shame of having a "dirty unhygienic" condition.
- Have you tried a Tea Tree shampoo? My father uses t-gel to keep his under control, but it never worked for me, so I started trying Tea Tree. I use paul mitchell brand about twice a week, and it works wonders. Jack Cain 12:44, 21 March 2006 (UTC)
- Try oling (I think I spelled that wrong) your hair. It worked for me.ch 16:20, 24 March 2006 (UTC)
-
- Goodness, no, there is no "best" shampoo because no shampoo is best! Use apple cider vinegar as a rinse and it will solve your problem -- at least, it did for my terrible case of dandruff. The first time you use it your scalp will really hurt, but with continued use you will notice no pain, because your scalp will be healing. I use a spray bottle of vinegar. Sometimes I do vinegar before shampoo (I use mild baby shampoo); sometimes I do vinegar after; sometimes both -- and sometimes only vinegar, no shampoo. The vinegar is not only an antifungal agent which will retard the fungus which causes dandruff, but more importantly it helps to loosen and wash away the build-up of skin cells which eventually clump together and appear as dandruff on your shoulders. Not only is vinegar far more effective than any shampoo, it is way cheaper, and best of all natural -- no need to worry that your dandruff treatment is giving you skin cancer. Please try it. Really. It works. I use vinegar four or five times a week, but I think a person could use it less often with a different treatment. I have heard that some people will apply lots of vinegar in the evening and let it sit overnite, then shampoo in the morning to wash away the pre-dandruff scalp buildup. I have tried that too, and it also works.216.67.0.242 20:40, 15 February 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Images?
I'm surprised there are no images to illustrate this condition. Could one of the dandruff sufferers who have posted here perhaps take a photo or two for the benefit of the encyclopedia? BigBlueFish 20:44, 1 April 2006 (UTC)
[edit] POV?
"The gold standard of shampoo brands is..."? 151.199.59.227 21:28, 7 May 2006 (UTC)
OK I'm sick of seeing this uncited and in all probability advertising paragraph:
There are shampoo brands available specifically for those who have dandruff. The gold standard of shampoo brands is Selsun Blue with selenium sulfide. A shampoo that contains salicylic acid, such as Denorex Extra Strength [2] or Neutrogena T/Sal [3] were found to be marginally acceptable in clinical tests submitted to the FDA for the final monograph. Other less effective products are Head & Shoulders, which contains zinc pyrithione, Neutrogena T/Gel, which contains coal tar; and various generic products with the same active ingredients. For more persistent or severe dandruff, as well as dandruff due to seborrheic dermatitis, shampoo containing 1% or 2% ketoconazole, such as Nizoral, can be used. These anti-dandruff ingredients are either fungicides, which kill the Malassezia furfur fungus, or acids which break down the oils on the scalp that lead to visible clumping of dead skin flakes.
So I've removed it from the main article for now. I don't think discussion of brands even if "studies show that..." has any place here. If anyone has studies showing the effectiveness of say coal tar vs ketoconazole or something, that would be a good replacement.ZoFreX 18:35, 9 May 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Any truth in this
Is there any truth in the claim I have heard, that if you use an anti-dandruff shampoo and then revert to a regular type, the dandruff will return worse than before. I've heard that from a number of people, but no solid evidence. 128.232.250.254 21:57, 19 May 2006 (UTC)
- Not in my experience. Seems illogical.
- Please sign your posts and no, it's just a matter of perception. Stovetopcookies 23:32, 10 January 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Kill off the fungus
Just writing to support the 'try different ingredient shampoos and rotate idea; here's why:
I've been living with it for years. For a long time Head&Shoulders or the generic version every week or two worked (regular shampoo the rest of the week) but lately it hasn't worked well; I have to use it every time. I may try using ketoconazole-based shampoo.
It seems that if you use a strong effective product (or a weak fungus), you can knock it out (until you get re-infected) while the less effective products just keep it from multiplying enough to make the symptoms bad.
PLEASE SIGN YOUR POSTS WITH FOUR TILDES (~ x4). Stovetopcookies 23:32, 10 January 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Terbinafine spray
This antifungal (for athlete's foot or jock itch) worked great when I tried it on my dandruff; I'll try to find it in a shampoo. For months, I had a sore I thought was (and my doctor confirmed) was hemorroids, but I tried the terbinafine spray I had for athlete's foot on it, as a shot in the dark, bam! It's been gone ever since (2 months). I'd tried talc, vaseline, tea tree oil, Selenium sulfide shampoo, all with little, short-term success. It was after this that I tried putting Terbinafine spray on my scalp.
PLEASE SIGN YOUR POSTS WITH FOUR TILDES (~ x4). Stovetopcookies 23:32, 10 January 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Infection
The article suggests that scratching-to-the-point-of-bleeding is dangerous because of infections (it specifically lists staph and strep, which I know suck a lot, odd that they can survive with all the fungus around though)... Would a person such as myself be in danger if, oh, say, there was a rather bad case of scalp acne in conjunction with the dandruff, resulting in a scalp perpetually covered in open sores? Cuz.. I've had that for the better part of a decade now without any problems that I know of.. I just know I'd look really gross bald.. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 64.122.208.51 (talk • contribs) 18:33, 4 December 2006 (UTC).
