Template talk:CT-1

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This template is used in the Character/Symbol Chart/Box/Table, where multiple cells needs to be shown as One block for each specific character/symbol. It is helpful for cell and data grouping. ~ Tarikash 22:43, 14 June 2006 (UTC).

Currently using it in this page Miscellaneous Technical (Unicode). ~ Tarikash 22:43, 14 June 2006 (UTC).

[edit] This is ridiculous!

Making dozens of templates for the purpose of styling tables? If you find that the cell styles of wikitables aren't diverse enough for your purposes, you are better off making a case for new class styles to be added to Mediawiki:Common.css, not creating a batch of discordant templates.

The naming system of these templates don't follow any logical order or reason... How is one to know what a template named "CT-5" does within a table, or how it differs from "CT-9", without using this lengthy reference guide? Asking editors to remember what each of these indistinguishable templates do is a tall order, unless you intend to subst: each and every one of them (which I can't imagine to be much of a time-saver). In addition, these templates contain mostly arbitrary style changes, and they don't look like they meet any sort of consensus from WP:MOS or anywhere.

It's completely obtuse system—while it may save some time for the initial editor creating a table, it in turn makes the work of future editors much more difficult. Moreover, it seems their intented use is superfluous; if a table needs more stylistic alteration than HTML already allows, the table is too complication and should be reduced or reformatted, or styled directly into the table code itself if necessary.

Here's an example of why these templates are needless. The following table, using these templates, was found at Optical character recognition#Optical Character Recognition in Unicode:

				Symbol	Name
				Hex
				Symbol's Picture
⑀	OCR Hook	⑁	OCR Chair	⑂	OCR Fork	⑃	OCR Inverted Fork	⑄	OCR Belt Buckle
0x2440		0x2441		0x2442		0x2443		0x2444
⑅	OCR Bow Tie	⑆	OCR Branch Bank Identification	⑇	OCR Amount Of Check	⑈	OCR Customer Account Number	⑉	OCR Dash
0x2445		0x2446		0x2447		0x2448		0x2449
⑊	OCR Double Backslash		Not Defined		Not Defined		Not Defined		Not Defined
0x244A		0x244B		0x244C		0x244D		0x244E
		-		-		-		-

And here's a modified version of the same table, with the same cell information, using standard wikicode with CSS and no template calls:

Unicode Symbol Characters

Block: Optical Character Recognition Hexadecimal Range: 0x2440–0x245F
Hex Number	Dec Number	Symbol Name	Glyph	Picture of Glyph
0x2440	9280	OCR Hook	⑀
0x2441	9281	OCR Chair	⑁
0x2442	9282	OCR Fork	⑂
0x2443	9283	OCR Inverted Fork	⑃
0x2444	9284	OCR Belt Buckle	⑄
0x2445	9285	OCR Bow Tie	⑅
0x2446	9286	OCR Branch Bank Identification	⑆
0x2447	9287	OCR Amount Of Check	⑇
0x2448	9288	OCR Customer Account Number	⑈
0x2449	9289	OCR Dash	⑉
0x244A	9290	OCR Double Backslash	⑊
0x244B … 0x245F	9291 … 9311	Reserved	⑋	–

There was even room leftover for another column of more information!

My message is this: Keep it simple! —Down10 ^TACO 08:29, 16 March 2007 (UTC)