CP-violation

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

In particle physics, CP violation is a violation of the postulated CP symmetry of the laws of physics. It plays an important role in theories of cosmology that attempt to explain the dominance of matter over antimatter in the present Universe. The discovery of CP violation in 1964 in the decays of neutral kaons resulted in the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1980 for its discoverers James Cronin and Val Fitch. The study of CP violation remains a vibrant area of theoretical and experimental work today.

1 What is CP?
2 CP Violation
3 Strong CP problem
4 CP violation and the matter-antimatter imbalance
5 References

[edit] What is CP?

CP is the product of two symmetries: C for charge conjugation, which transforms a particle into its antiparticle, and P for parity, which creates the mirror image of a physical system. The strong interaction and electromagnetic interaction seem to be invariant under the combined CP transformation operation, but this symmetry is slightly violated during certain types of weak decay. Historically, CP-symmetry was proposed to restore order after the discovery of parity violation in the 1950s.

The idea behind parity symmetry is that the equations of particle physics are invariant under mirror inversion. This leads to the prediction that the mirror image of a reaction (such as a chemical reaction or radioactive decay) occurs at the same rate as the original reaction. Parity symmetry appears to be valid for all reactions involving electromagnetism and strong interactions. Until 1956, parity conservation was believed to be one of the fundamental geometric conservation laws (along with conservation of energy and conservation of momentum). However, in 1956 a careful critical review of the existing experimental data by theoretical physicists Tsung-Dao Lee and Chen Ning Yang revealed that while parity conservation had been verified in decays by the strong or electromagnetic interactions, it was untested in the weak interaction. They proposed several possible direct experimental tests. The first test based on beta decay of Cobalt-60 nuclei was carried out in 1956 by a group led by Chien-Shiung Wu, and demonstrated conclusively that weak interactions violate the P symmetry or, as the analogy goes, some reactions did not occur as often as their mirror image.

Overall, the symmetry of a quantum mechanical system can be restored if another symmetry S can be found such that the combined symmetry PS remains unbroken. This rather subtle point about the structure of Hilbert space was realized shortly after the discovery of P violation, and it was proposed that charge conjugation was the desired symmetry to restore order.

Simply speaking, charge conjugation is a simple symmetry between particles and antiparticles, and so CP symmetry was proposed in 1957 by Lev Landau as the true symmetry between matter and antimatter. In other words a process in which all particles are exchanged with their antiparticles was assumed to be equivalent to the mirror image of the original process.

[edit] CP Violation

Kaon oscillation box diagram

The two box diagrams above are the Feynman diagrams providing the leading contributions to the amplitude of K-Kbar oscillation

In 1964, James Cronin and Val Fitch provided clear evidence (which was first announced at the 12th ICHEP conference in Dubna) that CP symmetry could be broken, too, winning them the 1980 Nobel Prize. Their discovery showed that weak interactions violate not only the charge-conjugation symmetry C between particles and antiparticles and the P or parity, but also their combination. The discovery shocked particle physics and opened the door to questions still at the core of particle physics and of cosmology today. The lack of an exact CP symmetry, but also the fact that it is so nearly a symmetry created a great puzzle.

It was discovered in 1964 by the group of Christenson, Cronin, Fitch and Turlay in a kaon decay experiment that CP symmetry was violated; only a weaker version of the symmetry could be preserved by physical phenomena, which was CPT-symmetry. Besides C and P, there is a third operation, time reversal (T), which corresponds to reversal of motion. Invariance under time reversal implies that whenever a motion is allowed by the laws of physics, the reversed motion is also an allowed one. The combination of CPT is thought to constitute an exact symmetry of all types of fundamental interactions. Because of the CPT-symmetry, a violation of the CP-symmetry is equivalent to a violation of the T-symmetry. CP violation implied nonconservation of T, provided that the long-held CPT theorem was valid. In this theorem, regarded as one of the basic principles of quantum field theory, charge conjugation, parity, and time reversal are applied together.

Some cosmologists (Myther et al) suggest that, if T-symmetry is violated, then there could be a possibility of the universe experiencing a big crunch without going through a complete replay of the history of universe. Thus, the problems associated with the reversed arrow of time posed by the laws of thermodynamics can be ignored assumung that the universe will then start experiencing a different history while moving towards the big crunch from a distinct point in future when the universe will cease to expand and gravity will take over.

The kind of CP violation discovered in 1964 was linked to the fact that neutral kaons can transform into their antiparticles (in which each quark is replaced with its antiquark) and vice versa, but such transformation does not occur with exactly the same probability in both directions; this is called indirect CP violation. Despite many searches, no other manifestation of CP violation was discovered until the '90s, when the NA31 experiment at CERN suggested evidence for CP violation in the decay process of the very same neutral kaons, so-called direct CP violation. The discovery was somehow controversial, and final proof for it came in 1999 from the KTeV experiment at Fermilab and the NA48 experiment at CERN.

In 2001, a new generation of experiments, including the BaBar Experiment at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) and the Belle Experiment at the High Energy Accelerator Research Organisation (KEK), Japan, have observed CP violation using B mesons [1]. Before these experiments, it was a logical possibility that all CP violation was confined to kaon physics. These experiments dispelled any doubt that the interactions of the Standard Model violated CP. Even more recently, the same experiments showed direct CP violation to be present also in B mesons.

The CP violation is incorporated of the Standard model by including a complex phase in the CKM matrix describing quark mixing. In such scheme a necessary condition for the appearance of the complex phase, and thus for CP-violation, is the presence of at least three generations of quarks.

There is no experimentally known violation of the CP-symmetry in quantum chromodynamics; see below.

[edit] Strong CP problem

In particle physics, the strong CP problem is the puzzling question why quantum chromodynamics (QCD) does not seem to break the CP-symmetry.

QCD does not violate the CP-symmetry as easily as the electroweak theory; unlike the electroweak theory in which the gauge fields couple to chiral currents constructed from the fermionic fields, the gluons couple to vector currents. Experiments do not indicate any CP violation in the QCD sector. For example, a generic CP-violation in the strongly interacting sector would create the electric dipole moment of the neutron which would be comparable to $10^{-18}\ \rm{e\cdot{}m}$ (electron charge multiplied by meters) while the experimental upper bound is roughly a trillion times smaller.

This is a problem because at the end, there are natural terms in the QCD Lagrangian that are able to break the CP-symmetry.

${\mathcal L} = -\frac{1}{4} {\mathrm {tr}\,} F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}-\frac{n_f g^2\theta}{32\pi^2} {\mathrm {tr}\,}F_{\mu\nu}\tilde F^{\mu\nu}+\bar \psi(i\gamma^\mu D_\mu - m e^{i\theta'\gamma_5})\psi$

For a nonzero choice of the QCD $θ$ -angle and the chiral quark mass phase $θ'$ one expects the CP-symmetry to be violated. One usually assumes that the chiral quark mass phase can be converted to a contribution to the total effective $\tilde\theta$ -angle, but it remains to be explained why Nature chooses an unbelievably small value of this angle instead of an angle of order one; the special choice of the $θ$ -angle that must be very close to zero (in this case) is an example of fine-tuning in physics.

The most famous solution that has been proposed to solve the strong CP problem is the Peccei-Quinn theory, involving new scalar particles called axions.

[edit] CP violation and the matter-antimatter imbalance

Main article: Baryogenesis

Unsolved problems in physics: Why does the universe have more matter than antimatter?

One of the unsolved theoretical questions in physics is why the universe is made chiefly of matter, rather than consisting of equal parts of matter and antimatter. It can be demonstrated that to create an imbalance in matter and antimatter from an initial condition of balance, the Sakharov conditions must be satisfied, one of which is the existence of CP violation during the extreme conditions of the first seconds after the Big Bang. Explanations which do not involve CP violation are less plausible, since they rely on the assumption that the matter-antimatter imbalance was present at the beginning, or on other admittedly exotic assumptions.

The Big Bang should have produced equal amounts of matter and anti-matter if CP-symmetry was preserved; as such, there should have been total cancellation of both. In other words, protons should have cancelled with anti-protons, electrons with positrons, neutrons with anti-neutrons, and so on for all elementary particles. This would have resulted in a sea of photons in the universe with no matter. Since this is quite evidently not the case, after the Big Bang, physical laws must have acted differently for matter and antimatter, i.e. violating CP symmetry.

The Standard Model contains only two ways to break CP symmetry. The first of these, discussed above, is in the QCD lagrangian, and has not been found experimentally; but one would expect this to lead to either no CP violation or a CP violation that is many, many orders of magnitude too large. The second of these, involving the weak force, has been experimentally verified, but can account for only a small portion of CP-violation. It is predicted to be sufficient for a net mass of normal matter equivalent to only a single galaxy in the known universe.

Since the Standard Model does not accurately predict this discrepancy, it would seem that the current Standard Model has gaps (other than the obvious one of gravity and related matters) or physics is otherwise in error. Moreover, experiments to probe these CP-related gaps may not require the practically impossible-to-obtain energies that may be necessary to probe the gravity-related gaps (see Planck mass).

C, P and T Symmetries	edit
C-symmetry \| P-symmetry \| T-symmetry
CP-symmetry \| CPT symmetry
pin group

[edit] References

G. C. Branco, L. Lavoura and J. P. Silva (1999). CP violation. Clarendon Press, Oxford. ISBN 0-19-850399-7.
I. Bigi and A. Sanda (1999). CP violation. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-44349-0.
Michael Beyer (Editor) (2002). CP Violation in Particle, Nuclear and Astrophysics. Springer. ISBN 3-540-43705-3. (A collection of essays introducing the subject, with an emphasis on experimental results.)
L. Wolfenstein (1989). CP violation. North-Holland, Amsterdam. 0444-88081X. (A compilation of reprints of numerous important papers on the topic, including papers by T.D. Lee, Cronin, Fitch, Kobayashi and Maskawa, and many others.)
David J. Griffiths (1987). Introduction to Elementary Particles. Wiley, John & Sons, Inc. ISBN 0-471-60386-4.
I. Bigi, CP violation, an essential mystery in Nature's grand design. Invited lecture given at the XXV ITEP Winter school of Physics, February 18-27, 1997, Moscow, Russia, at 'Frontiers in Contemporary Physics', May 11-16, 1997, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, USA, and at the International School of Physics 'Enrico Fermi', CXXXVII Course 'Heavy Flavour Physics: A Probe of Nature's Grand Design', Varenna, Italy, July 8-18, 1997. hep-ph/9803479.
Davide Castelvecchi, What is direct CP-violation?, Stanford Linear Accelerator (SLAC)