Talk:Claude Frollo
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
Claude Frollo is within the scope of WikiProject France, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to France and Monaco on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please join the project and help with our open tasks. | |
 |
||
| ??? | This article has not yet received a rating on the quality scale. Please rate the article and then leave a short summary here to explain the ratings and/or to identify the strengths and weaknesses. | |
Contents |
[edit] Suitability
Should an article on this fictional character contain a summary of nearly the whole work that he appears in? Does each character in a fictional work warrant his/her own article?
Even if the answer to both these questions is yes, this article needs serious work, as the summary seems to be based on the disney version of the story. This is another reason why such a summary seems to me to be a bad idea. Should we have summaries of every variation? I think not. But if we are to have any summary at all, it should be on the original work, not some poor, disneyfied substitute. Dmw 06:25, 18 November 2006 (UTC)
- The reason for this article being based on the Disney version of the story is because the article was originally for the Disney villian Frollo, not the charater from the original story. Some one decided to mess it up and combine the two. I don't know who it was. Jeez, if they did that, at least they could've changed the summary. I was the one who re-wrote the summary (a while ago) into the version on the article now. Since the two have been combined now, I don't see an issue with you re-writing it. I think You and me are pretty much the only people who pay attention to and "Watch" this article anyway. Majinvegeta
[edit] LUST
in the song part it says he has love for esmerelda but its lust the whole point is it is just mad lust and therefore really 'sinful' to him. so i changed it
[edit] Frollo Inverted Hearts Picture
If Gaston has a Kh:Ih picture, then why doesn't Frollo have one? Please post one if you find it.
- There is no Frollo Inverted Hearts photo, but he is on the game. But you shouldn't take Inverted Hearts that seriously. It's a fan product.
-
- Yes it is basically fan fiction in game form. Besides Tony Jay is dead sadly, and it would be hard to get him anyway. Its too bad, he had a great voice.
-
-
- Still, if Frollo is on a KH Game (Frollo, Gaston and The Horned King are many candidates to appear on one), maybe they'll get Jim Cummings or Corey Burton to de a replacement. But, of course, it won't be the same without Tony Jay.
-
-
-
-
- Well i'm guessing if they were to put Frollo in Kingdom Hearts, they could just sample older dialogue for the movie plot, and have him without a voice actor for the rest of the game. I know it sounds crazy but i'm guessing it could work.71.228.22.48
-
-
[edit] NOOOOOOOOO
Why god why ? Why did Tony Jay have to die ?
- He had cancer and died. It's the natural process of life.
-
- I knew that. I just want to know how he got the cancer.
-
-
- His diet? His sexual life? It could have been anything. I feel just as disappointed as you, but I have accepted the fact that Tony Jay lived his life and succumbed to death. It happens to everyone. Jienum 22:06, 3 September 2006 (UTC)
-
[edit] Wikiquote
The edit history says the quotes were moved to wikiquote, but I created a wikiquote link for this page and it says nothing's there. Mr_Beale
[edit] Just a thought
The last part of this article seemed exteremly choppy. Short sentences with sudden pauses, I didn't like It. So I fixed. Majinvegeta
[edit] Original character
This article needs to have more information on the original character the movie was based on. --DrBat 13:37, 29 October 2006 (UTC)
- Agree, there actually isn't an article on Wikipedia of the Disney character Quasimodo, only on the one from the original book. Majinvegeta
[edit] fictional narcissists
fictional narcissists? i don't think so, remove that, please. narcissism in his own words would be "evil"
- He did a lot of things that were evil, and most of them worse than narcissism. --DrBat 03:31, 30 October 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Separate page for Disney character
I have created a separate page for the Disney character (Claude Frollo (Disney adaptation)) and added some words on the Frollo of the novel. It was kind of weird that the article on a major character of a classic work of European literature would consist entirely of the discussion of a character in a very free film adaptation of the original novel... ~~Lumendelumine Jan 13 2007, 16.42 UTC~~
Thank you; it was for the best, really. Hades has his own article after all, so this is the best movie to make. I've already begun work on the Disney character's article, including rewriting the History section and adding a template, so it should be alright. Nqnpipnr 03:21, 15 January 2007 (UTC)
