Talk:Bosniaks of Serbia

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This should be split into two articles. serbia and Montenegro are two separate countries now and there should be separate article about Bosniak population in both of them. PANONIAN (talk) 01:36, 17 December 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Join

I suggest joining Bosniaks of Montenegro to this articel. It seems logic, as that people belongs to one not only nation, but of the same sub-ethnic origin. --Edin Sijercic 21:23, 16 February 2007 (UTC)

I do not agree, both states are now independent, I see no reason why we should join articles of two separate states. Why then not join articles Bosniaks in Serbia and Bosniaks in Macedonia. There is no logic in this. PANONIAN (talk) 23:52, 16 February 2007 (UTC)

Are you aware that we'll need thousands of articles if yu plan for every people in every state? So what if the states separate. Why do we have Bosniaks? Why not split to Bosniaks in Bosnia and Herzegovina and other. Bosniaks live in Sandzak, other Bosniaks that live elsewhere in Montenegro and Serbia are not relevant. Its not notable enuph to have separate articles.

Bosniaks in Serbia and Bosniaks in Macedonia are not of same ethnic origin, do not live in a compact geo-historical (to us even political) entity. How can you say there is no logic? Did yu think at all? The SANDZAK Bosniacs/Muslims are different from OTHER Bosniacs/Muslims; the stupid border between Montenegro and Serbia does NOT split us (we still have cultural institutions for whole Sanjak, Bosniak Matica for Sanjak; all parties run in both parts of Sandzak, how do yu not understand?). --Edin Sijercic 23:53, 20 March 2007 (UTC)

No, I do not plan articles "for every people in every state", only for certain peoples with significant demographic or historical presence in certain country. Both countries, Serbia and Montenegro, have significant Bosniak populations and therefore articles about Bosniaks in both countries should exist. Opposite to this, there is no need that we writte articles about Bosniaks in Romania or Bosniaks in Latvia because there is no significant Bosniak population in those countries. Also, Bosniaks do not live only in Sandžak - there are also sizable native Bosniak populations in Mačva district of Serbia or in Ulcinj municipality of Montenegro, etc, etc... Also, this was not meant to be article about Sandžak - you already have separate article about Sandžak, which also speak about Bosniaks. This article was meant to be about something else. PANONIAN (talk) 01:37, 21 March 2007 (UTC)