User talk:Arkhamite

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

1 Original Research
2 Deletion of cited material
3 As For Me
4 Fatawa of Osama bin Laden

[edit] Original Research

There are a couple of non-robin related points I'm trying to make here. One is that policy states No original research. Your premise 'Robin is gay?' is fine, but it's just not something that belongs on Wikipedia. You're not offering any citations to back up your comments, you're not pointing to articles or third party sources to support your claims. Therefore what you've done is original research. Again, that's fine. Just not for the wiki.

Secondly, 'assume good faith' means I assume you're trying to make this a better site (and I do), but it doesn't mean I can't think you're going about it the wrong way.

Third, Wikipedia is not a soapbox or a Forum (item 5).

There's nothing wrong that you've done, but you're going about it in a way that gets you looked at like a possible troll. I was serious when I said to go read the Batman page, and the section about homosexuality. If it helps, in good faith I put a link on the Robin page to the Batman homosexuality section. If you want to go forward with your theory, keep all that in mind and you'll do fine. I'm not telling you what to do, I'm telling you what policy here is. You can violate it all you want, though I don't think that would be helpful. -- Ipstenu (talk|contribs) 19:36, 2 January 2007 (UTC)

Why is it acceptable to discuss Batman and Robin's sexual orientations in the Batman article but not in the Robin article? Silliness.

Wikipedia discussion pages are chock full of the kind of the thing you and your cohorts are railing against, so I guess you had better crack down and make sure no out-of-the-box discussion of any kind occurs. Especially if that discussion is well-stated but lacks immediate and perfect documentation, apparently a double violation of your personal interpretation of the Holy Writ.

But I encourage you to embark on a War on Violations. Your first target, Agent Ipstenu: Talk:Star_Trek. That ought to keep you busy while I enjoy the newly included section in Robin (comics) on his possibly being a gay character and wait for the FBI to disclose their role in sabotaging Detective Comics.

Arkhamite 22:37, 2 January 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Deletion of cited material

In this edit[1] you deleted an existing citation. You neither supplied a reference for the changes nor discussed the deleted citation on the article talk page. Be aware that the WP:VANDAL policy applies in that situation. Please provide references for you edits and gain consensus in advance on the article talk page before removing existing references. You may be subject to a user block if the problem continues. I, Durova, have spoken, and all must heed my commands or suffer WP:DAMNATION. Durova^Charge! 19:14, 18 February 2007 (UTC)

I did not delete the citation, I merely moved it to the bottom of the page, to the section titled "References". Please do not come on my talk page and threaten me again or you may be subject to death squads and torture chambers.

Arkhamite 15:49, 20 February 2007 (UTC)