Talk:William Murdoch
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography. For more information, visit the project page. | ||
| ??? | This article has not yet received a rating on the Project's quality scale. Please rate the article and then leave a short summary here to explain the ratings and/or to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article. [FAQ] | ||
 |
William Murdoch has had a peer review by Wikipedia editors which is now archived. It may contain ideas you can use to improve this article. |
 |
This article is part of the History of Science WikiProject, an attempt to improve and organize the history of science content on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the project page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion. You can also help with the History of Science Collaboration of the Month. |
I am the great great great grand nephew of William Murdoch (my name is William Matthew Murdoch). His name was spelled with an "H" on the end "Murdoch". Please make any necessary changes to your web site.
Thanks for the information on him.
-William
This page was originally created as [[William Murdock]] by User:Pigsonthewing, then moved here. My first thught was to move it back. But I tried several phrase matches usng both alternate spellings. Google shows the 'Murdoch' version is favored, if only by 1 to 10 percent. Lou I 21:08, 13 Jun 2004 (UTC)
- That's not the case. When I created William Murdock, William Murdoch already existed, and I pointed the former at the latter, as the pages' histories show. Andy Mabbett 21:45, 13 Jun 2004 (UTC)
I'm going to be making a major updating of this page & adding a fair bit more detail, please bear with me as I don't have much time each day to do this. AllanHainey 14:05, 4 August 2005 (UTC)
[edit] The Caledonia Paddle Steamer
Because early steam ships are rather a mania for me, I sent out to check the claim that the P.S. Caledonia was the first steamer to cross the Channel, and it does not appear to be substantiated.
H.P Spratt's The Birth of the Steamboat (Chas. Griffin, London, 1958), mentions Caledonia (p. 84), saying only: "Two other steamboats, the 'Quebec' and the 'Caledonia' of 45 nominal h.p., followed soon after in 1817. The machinery for the Quebec of 500 tons, was obtained from Messrs. Maudslay, Sons and Field, of London; it was rated at 56 nominal h.p. and developed 100 indicated h.p." (Note 264, referring to this section, cites The Maudslay Society, Henry Maudslay, 1771-1831; and Maudslay, Sons and Field (Bedford, 1949), p. 44).
This isn't inherently helpful one way or the other, but on pp. 92-94 Spratt writes of the P.S. Margery, later Élise, laid down in 1813 and launched in June 1814 (p. 92).
On p94 Spratt says: "She was chartered or sold, in about March 1816, to Messrs. Andriel, Pajol et Cie., of Paris (note 303), renamed by them the 'Élise', and refitted for service on the river Seine (note 304). Under the command of Captain Pierre Andriel, who later introduced the first steamboat service on the the Mediterranean with the 'Ferdinando Primo' (see p. 105), and with Captain Anthony Cortis and Mr. W. Jackson (a former collaborator of Robert Fulton also on board (note 305), the 'Élise' steamed from the Thames in stormy weather to Newhaven. She left there on the 17th March 1816, and battled her way (note 306) across the Channel (the first steamer that ever did so) in the face of southerly head-winds, and reached Havre the next day, after seventeen hours at sea (note 307)."
Notes read as follows. 303: Circulaire publicitaire: L'Entreprise brevetée de navigation accélérée Pierre Andriel, Pajol et Cie., par l'emploi de pompes à vapeur Paris, 18 Janvier 1816. 304: Parliamentary Papers, London, 1822, No. 417, Fifth Report of the Select Committee on Holyhead Roads: Steam boats, etc. Appendix I by Joshua Field, p. 198. Note 305: La Quotidienne, Paris, 22 Mars 1816, p. 3. Note 306: Journal des Débats, Paris, 28 Mars 1816. Spratt H. Philip et Bigot, Germaine L., "Le premier navire à vapeur à travers la Manche." Revue Maritime, Service Historique de la Marine, Paris, Février 1957, pp. 170-175. Note 307: Histoire de la Marine. Editée par Illustration, Paris, 1934, p. 330.
Just to clear up the question, as the above does not settle the more specific matter of whether the Caledonia was the first British (as in British-flag) vessel to cross the Channel, she appears not to have been. Jean-Jacques Antier's Les Premiers Paquebots à vapeur (L'Ancre de Marine, St-Malo, 1984) lists the Defiance, of Greenock, as having crossed the Channel in 1816, en route to the river Main, before the Caledonia (p. 87). Antier's book is not footnoted.
Hurrah ! A first ! Antier says that the Caledonia was the first steamer to cross the North Sea from Britain to Scandinavia (presumably, but not definitely, Norway) in 1818 (p. 89). Angus McLellan 23:38, 27 January 2006 (UTC)
- The source for the claim that the Caledonia was the 1st to cross the Channel was The Third man by John Griffiths (referenced in the article) it states (on p 328) "William thus missed being on the first Channel Steamboat crossing, which Watt junior courageously accomplished." and gives the reference date 06/10/1817 for a letter sent 2 days after the Caledonia set off from Surrey Docks (to Margate Harbour then across the Channel), though no date of the actual journey & there isn't a great deal about it in the book as it is a biography of Murdoch & he didn't make the trip. It doesn't mention Scandinavia but says the cross-channel trip was from Margate Harbour to Rotterdam then up the Scheldt and Rhine to Koblenz. As Griffiths isn't a naval historian and the steamboats you cite seem fairly obscure I suppose it's easy to assume he was mistaken in his attribution of the Caledonia as the 1st to cross the channel. I'll remove the claim from the article. AllanHainey 12:33, 30 January 2006 (UTC)
-
- Its an excellent article by the way. When I saw you mention John Griffiths above, I did a double-take. There was a successful American C19th shipbuilder and engineer by that name, he had something to do with perfecting the propellor. WP doesn't have an article on him. Angus McLellan 19:33, 30 January 2006 (UTC)
