Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2006-03-27/In the news
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
In the news
Britannica responds to Nature
Encyclopædia Britannica Inc have responded to the Nature study published in December (see archived story) with a 20-page open letter, titled "Fatally Flawed". The document was released on their website on March 22, and strongly denounced Nature's study as flawed and unscientific, demanding a retraction of the article. Nature declined (see related story).
On March 23, the Associated Press agency ran a story about the dispute which was widely reprinted, with media outlets including Yahoo!, USA Today, Forbes, ABC News, CBS News, Newsday, The Washington Post, and many more.
In addition, original reporting on the story included:
- "In a War of Words, Famed Encyclopedia Defends Its Turf", The Wall Street Journal
- "Heavyweight bout: Encyclopedia Britannica vs. Nature", The Scientist
- "Britannica hits back in Wikipedia row", The Times
- "Nature mag cooked Wikipedia study", The Register
- "Britannica objects to allegations of inaccuracy by science journal", The Boston Globe
- "Revered reference beyond compare", The Australian
- "Britannica lashes out at Wikipedia comparison study", vnunet
- "Britannica begs to differ on Wikipedia's accuracy", Ars Technica
- "Britannica Comes Out Swinging at Nature", and "Nature Responds to Britannica", Designtechnica
- "Encyclopedia Britannica fires back over Wikipedia row", PC Pro
Anti-poverty group editing Wikipedia
In "Group adds to Nussle's entry in Wikipedia", an article in the Des Moines Register, members of the ONE Campaign took credit for POV edits made by User:67.155.175.170 to the article of United States Congressman Jim Nussle. The edits support the agenda of the ONE Campaign's parent organization Make Poverty History, which, however laudable, are out of place in the encyclopedic articles of individual politicians.
Mistaken identity
Journalist, broadcaster and author Mark Lawson mentioned some errors in his Wikipedia article in The Guardian column "My life as a Catholic Jew"; they were promptly corrected by User:Piotrus.
Also this week: Britannica v. Nature — Community Portal — News and notes — Press coverage — Features and admins — B.R.I.O.N. — T.R.O.L.L.
