Violet Club

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Violet Club was a nuclear weapon deployed by the United Kingdom during the cold war.

Violet Cub was the first "high yield" weapon deployed by the British, and was intended to provide an emergency capability until a thermonuclear weapon could be developed from the Christmas Island thermonuclear tests known as Operation Grapple. In 1953, shortly after the Americans tested a thermonuclear weapon in 1952, followed by the Soviets with Joe 4, and before the UK government took a decision in July 1954 to develop a thermonuclear weapon, AWRE Aldermaston were asked about the possibilities for a very large pure fission bomb yielding one megaton. This study^[1] referred to the Zodiak Mk.3 bomb, but progressed no further than a rudimentary study. At this time studies were also started^[2] that ultimately led to a decision in 1954 to develop a thermonuclear weapon, and the design studies were split into two tracks because the British at that time had not yet discovered the Teller-Ulam technique necessary to initiate fusion. One track led to an intermediate design, the so-called Type A thermonuclear design, similar to the Alarm Clock and layer cake hybrid designs of other nuclear powers; although these designs are now regarded as large boosted-fission weapons, and no longer regarded as thermonuclear weapons that derive a very large part of their energy from a fusion reaction, designated by the British as Type B, but as hybrids. The British hybrid weapon was known as Green Bamboo, weighed approx 4,500 lb (2,045 kg) and its spherical shape measured approx 45 inches diameter with a 72-point implosion system^[3]. This Green Bamboo weapon was intended as the warhead for all projected British strategic delivery systems of the period; the Yellow Sun Stage 1 air-dropped bomb, and the Blue Steel air-launched stand-off missile. The large girth of these weapons was designed to accommodate the diameter of Green Bamboo's implosion sphere.^[4]

The Orange Herald spherical warhead installed in the centre section frame of a Blue Danube casing prior to the Operation Grapple tests at Christmas Island. Although smaller at approx 36 inches diameter than the Green Grass warhead of Violet Club at 45 inches, the Green Grass warhead would appear to be very similar. A notable difference would be the 72-lenses of the Green Grass implosion system, derived from the Green Bamboo design, unlike this photograph showing 32 lenses and detonators. The Blue Danube derived firing switch (the large circular item attached to the frame at top left) is clearly seen, with the firing cables leading to each detonator also clearly visible. Because the timing of the firing signal was so important, each cable was of exactly identical length, with duplicated cables to the nearest detonators having to be coiled. The nose and tail units of the casing fix to the large circular frame of the modified Blue Danube casing.

A variant with a smaller implosion sphere, fewer explosive lenses, and some other changes was intended for the Blue Streak ballistic missile that was unable to carry Green Bamboo. However, the reduced size was achieved by reducing the size of the surrounding HE layers, and this resulted in less compression at the fissile core when detonated, and a reduced nuclear efficiency, and yield; meaning that less of the fissile material was consumed before the bomb blew itself apart. To compensate for the reduced compression more fissile material was required to maintain yield at the desired level, and this in turn made excessive demands on scarce and expensive fissile material. Estimates computed from reliable sources of actual core cost^[5] and cost per kilogram^[6] of HEU put the core sizes of Green Bamboo and Orange Herald as 98 kg and 125 kg respectively, although some other published (and unverified) sources claim lower figures of 87 kg and 117 kg respectively.^[7] This design later became known as Orange Herald, and was tested at Christmas Island, yielding 720 kt.^[8] These two weapons, Green Bamboo and Orange Herald were intended as the two hybrid weapon predecessors of the first British thermonuclear weapons, based on the Granite design series that began with Short Granite, Purple Granite, Grapple X, Grapple Y, and Flagpole and Halliard at Grapple Z.

Delays and failures in the Granite programme and the abandonment of Green Bamboo without a test, left a gap in the programme and an emergency capability weapon to fill that gap was devised from elements of both Green Bamboo and Orange Herald; being known as Knobkerry,^[9] or Green Grass, and the Interim Megaton Weapon.^[10] There were also other factors involved in the decision to build an Interim Megaton Weapon. One being that the UK HEU production programme was by 1957 producing quantities of HEU for which there was no immediate need; and the Chiefs of Staff were reluctant to see it continue to languish in stores, unused for weapons, when it was being produced at great cost.^[11] The Green Grass warhead containing perhaps 70–86 kg of HEU (although there are no reliable declassified sources for this figure) was therefore hurriedly produced and installed in a modified Blue Danube casing, to be known as Violet Club, until a better solution based on the Yellow Sun casing could be produced, known then with Green Grass installed, as Yellow Sun Mk.1.^[12] Only five Violet Club weapons were produced, known by the RAF description of Bomb, Aircraft, HE 9,000 lb HC, and they were stripped of their Green Grass warheads for transfer to the better casings when these became available.

Schematic of the steel ball bearing arrangement common to Green Grass, Green Bamboo and Orange Herald warheads. The internal and external diameters can be computed from the 450 kg weight of the steel balls. First published in Synergy Magazine, published Southampton, UK, No3, 2003

Violet Club (and to a lesser degree Yellow Sun Mk.1) was not considered a satisfactory design and suffered from numerous design defects. An implosion design, the fissile core of the weapon was a hollow sphere of HEU which was supported by a HE supercharge cast around a magnesium honeycomb matrix to aid structural strength.^[13] The HEU core was greater than one uncompressed critical mass and to maintain it in a sub-critical condition AWRE fashioned it into a hollow thin-walled sphere. The HEU sphere was collapsed inwards by the HE supercharge and its surrounding shell of HE supercharge and 72 lenses. However, a fire in the bomb store or a traffic collision on the airfield could easily lead to a partial crushing or collapse of the non-removable shell of HEU, and in turn a spontaneous nuclear chain reaction. AWRE responded by inserting (though a hole in the shell) a rubber bag, rather akin to an outsize female condom, and filled this with 133,000 steel ball bearings,^[14] weighing 450 kg, before sealing the hole with a plastic bung. The steel balls were intended to prevented a nuclear detonation even if the explosives fired accidentally, or in any conceivable accident. The ball bearings had to be removed through the hole in the bomb casing during flight preparation, and after the bomb was winched into the aircraft. The ball bearings then had to be re-inserted into the lowered and upturned bomb before transport back to the bomb store. Quite obviously, without the ball bearings installed, these weapons were armed and live, and too dangerous to allow to be flown on exercises. Bomber Command exercises demonstrated that flight preparation followed by a scramble take-off could not be reduced below thirty minutes,^[15] and on exercises in bad weather and at night a ninety minute scramble was the norm.^[16] At least one accident dated 1960 was reported in the press when the plastic bung was removed and 133,000 steel ball bearings exited onto the aircraft hangar floor, leaving the bomb armed and vulnerable.^[17] The Royal Air Force were so nervous of the outcome of a fire in storage, that permission was sought to store the bombs inverted, so that a loss of the plastic bung could not end with the steel balls on the floor, leaving the HEU unprotected against a subsequent explosion.^[18] Even without the partial nuclear detonation feared by the RAF, there was "a risk of catastrophe" ^[19]

AWRE's trickery with the steel balls had other unintended outcomes. Even an event as inconsequential as early morning frost was an issue, Violet Club could be loaded into a bomber for up to thirty days on standby, while parked overnight on a remote base where the bomb could get very cold. If the steel balls froze together inside the bomb cavity and couldn't be removed, the bomb was useless, and the aircraft couldn't scramble with almost half a ton of excess weight. AWRE's solution was to fit the bomb with an electric blanket. Because the bombs were armed before flight, the take-off was hazardous; the bombs couldn't be jettisoned, and landing with an armed bomb on return to base was too hazardous to contemplate; so Violet Club couldn't be used on an airborne alert.^[20] or even flown to a remote dispersal base.

Other design flaws centred on a requirement for a strip-down and inspection at six-monthly intervals and taking three weeks per weapon using AWRE civilian staff. The unstable nature of the bomb required that the work be done in-situ at RAF facilities, causing considerable disruption to operational duties. There were three main reasons for the strip-down and these were deterioration of the rubber bag, corrosion of the steel balls, and deterioration of the HE, which was prone to cracking. Replacement of the HE would cost the RAF in excess of £90,000 adjusted to 2006 prices.^[21]

Green Grass/Violet Club was the first UK deployed weapon to dispense with the crude polonium and beryllium impact or crush type initiators used in Red Beard, Blue Danube, Fat Man and other early US weapons. Instead it used an Electronic Neutron Initiator or ENI, known as Blue Stone which had the great advantage of being adjustable, allowing the neutron burst to be triggered at precisely the right moment. The burst heights of Green Grass were optimized for either maximum overpressure without allowing fireball contact with the ground, or to maximise the ground area subjected to a 6 psi overpressure; respectively 3,500 ft and 6,200 ft above ground level,^[22] using a barometric fuze backed-up with an adjustable clockwork timer fuze^[23] and fail-safe impact fuzes. Most of these mechanisms originated from Blue Danube although the radar altimeter fuze was omitted.^[24] The electrical power for these fuzing mechanisms and the firing mechanisms of the 72-lens 45 inch diameter implosion device came from lead-acid accumulators located in the tail of the Blue Danube casing. These were commercially-sourced six volt motorcycle batteries.

Green Grass struggled to meet the Chiefs of Staff requirement for an Interim Megaton [yield] Weapon. It was never tested, and AWRE estimated its yield at 500 kt based on the Orange Herald test of 720kt. A Mr Challens of AWRE who later became the Director of AWRE then claimed to the Air Staff that

A weapon of one half megaton was considered to be in the megaton range.[25][26]

A play-on-words that later returned to haunt AWRE when later estimates revised the yield to 400kt. Challens also stated on behalf of AWRE that

AWRE were almost completely sure that a nuclear explosion would not occur if the balls are in, - but in the absence of trial proof, he could not guarantee it.

The Royal Air Force were not amused, with Bomber Command Staff officers minuting their seniors with remarks like this one.^[27]

This [minute] means that Violet Club and Yellow Sun Mk.1 are not "in the megaton range" at all, notwithstanding the extraordinary measures taken, and costs involved for what we had thought to be a megaton capability. This ..... lead me to the belief that production of Green Grass be curtailed. I cannot imagine any commercial organisation continuing to buy a device that so patently fails to meet the requirement, or to be misled without protest as the Air Ministry has so consistently been [misled] by AWRE.

Summing up, senior levels of the RAF believed they had been sold a 'lemon', and these further extracts from the archives does much to illustrate the uncertain safety of the weapon in the hands of the inexperienced RAF.

Aircraft engines must not be run with Violet Club loaded on the aircraft with the safety device [of steel balls] in place. The engines must not be started until the weapon is prepared for an actual operational sortie [to prevent the steel balls vibrating like a bag of jellybeans].[28]

.... uncertainty exists about the effects of movement with the balls inserted. [29]

The fifth and last Violet Club weapon was due for delivery to the RAF by the end of May 1959^[30] and all were withdrawn by 1960, but in their Yellow Sun Mk.1 form they survived until 1963, when all had been replaced with Yellow Sun Mk.2 with Red Snow warheads installed.

These very large and dirty fission bombs were the largest pure-fission bombs deployed by any state, and unlike their predecessors Blue Danube and Red Beard they used HEU as a fissile material rather than plutonium. The reason being primarily economic. The cost of HEU to the Royal Air Force was (at 1958-9 prices) £19,200 per kg, with plutonium priced at £143,000 per kg.^[31] Although a HEU weapon needed more fissile material for a given yield than a plutonium weapon,^[32] a saving per weapon was of the order of £22.7M at 2006 prices. Thirty seven Green Grass warheads were built (five as Violet Club) saving the Treasury £840M. The influence of the Treasury on weapons procurement should not be underestimated: it reaches even into weapons design. Clearly, there were economic benefits in building large and dirty U-235 fission bombs, rather than cleaner, but more expensive plutonium weapons; and there was a shortage of plutonium anyway. By 1958 Britain's accumulated production of plutonium was only 472.2 kg^[33] and a proportion of that was bartered to the United States in exchange for HEU and other items. Up to 1958, British output of HEU was only 860 kg,^[34] while the United States supplied the UK with approximately seven tons of HEU from their less costly production process. So HEU used for Green Grass was purchased cheaply from the U.S. while selling to the U.S. the unwanted and high-priced weapons-grade plutonium.

Knobkerry, alias Green Grass, alias Interim Megaton Weapon, alias Violet Club and Yellow Sun Mk.1 had one other distinction. It was the last entirely British nuclear weapon deployed with the UK Armed Services. The British Operation Grapple thermonuclear weapon tests at Christmas Island in 1957-58 were the end of evolution. There were no more wholly home-grown designs. The British evolutionary line became extinct. Britain never deployed a true thermonuclear weapon of wholly home-grown design. All the weapons tested at Operation Grapple were abandoned, because AWRE no longer needed them; although some of their features were undoubtedly incorporated into later weapons. These Granite-type devices were all experimental devices needing to be developed further into reliable Service-engineered warheads at considerable cost in time and money. The U.S. designs offered after 1958 were fully tested and engineered, and cheap to produce.^[35] They were manufactured in Britain from British materials and U.S. blueprints. They were British property and there were no American political constraints on their use; and for the Treasury, it was truly a deal made in heaven; and Violet Club and Yellow Sun Mk.1 bridged the gap until the American designs could be manufactured.

[edit] Footnotes

1. ^ Public Record Office, London. AIR 2/13759 E8A. (PRO)
2. ^ PRO AIR 2/13759 E18B
3. ^ PRO. AVIA 65/1193 E10A. Tech Note GW375 p2 para 2.
4. ^ Humphrey Wynn, RAF Strategic Nuclear Forces: their origins, roles and deployment 1946-69. Published HMSO London 1994. ISBN 0-11-772833-0 p193. (Wynn)
5. ^ PRO. AB 16/1888 E111.
6. ^ PRO. AB 16/3878 Appendix 4.
7. ^ http://www.milnet.com/nukeweap/Nfaq7-2.html#uk
8. ^ Lorna Arnold, Britain and the H-Bomb, the official history, p147, p236. Published Palgrave, 2001. ISBN 0-312-23518-6 in North America, ISBN 0-333-94742-8 elsewhere.
9. ^ PRO. AVIA 65/1116 E18
10. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13680 E11A.
11. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13680 E11A and E46B.
12. ^ Wynn. pps 248-251.
13. ^ PRO. AVIA 65/1218 E183 (a)
14. ^ David J.Hawkins, Keeping the Peace, The Aldermaston Story, p52. Published Pen and Sword in association with AWE, 2000. ISBN 0-85052-775-9
15. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13705 E36A (c).
16. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13705 E62A page 1.
17. ^ Sunday Telegraph, London, 28 June 1998, p13.
18. ^ PRO. AVIA 65/1218 E181, E193.
19. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13705 E62A page 2, E47A page 3, and PRO. AIR 2/13718 E249 page 2.
20. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13705 E36A.
21. ^ PRO. AVIA 65/1155 E194 para 11.
22. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13705 E58A.
23. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13718 E7A (4)
24. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13718 E21B (3)
25. ^ At a conference recorded in PRO. AVIA 65/1218
26. ^ [1]
27. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13705 E59A
28. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13718 E15A (3)(d)
29. ^ PRO. AIR 2/13718 E21B (14)
30. ^ PRO AVIA 65/1116 E20.
31. ^ PRO. AB 16/3878 Appendix 4.
32. ^ Charles S.Grace, Nuclear Weapons: Principles, Effects and Survivability. Published: Royal College of Military Science, Shrivenham, Wilts, and Brasseys, 1994. ISBN 0-08-040992-X
33. ^ PRO AB 16/3878 various enclosures.
34. ^ PRO. AB 16/3878 various enclosures.
35. ^ PRO. AVIA 65/1771 E24 page 1 para 3, and PRO. AVIA 65/1792.

[edit] External links

• http://www.avrovulcan.org.uk/nukes/violetclub.htm
• http://www.keconnect.co.uk/~defcon/history.htm (many inaccuracies on this site.)
• http://www.mcis.soton.ac.uk/Site_Files/pdf/nuclear_history/glossary.pdf
• Norris, Burrows and Fieldhouse, Nuclear Weapons Databook Vol.5, British, French and Chinese Nuclear Weapons. Published Westview Press, Oxford, 1994. ISBN 0-8133-1612-X
• Prof J.E.Harris, MBE, FREng, FRS, FIM. Interdisciplinary Science Reviews. The threat of nuclear terrorism. Published ISR 1999 Vol.4, No.2. ISSN 0308-0188.
• Prof J.E.Harris, MBE, FREng, FRS, FIM. Interdisciplinary Science Reviews. Plutonium: from star dust to Star Wars. Published ISR 2001, Vol.26, No.1. ISSN 0308-0188.