Talk:Type 348 Radar

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Citations and comments

Normally, I'm not big on citations in pages other than important science and lit topics - I prefer people adding information, with citations being added later. But when the only Reference provided contradicts the article, one has to say something. At the very least find a webpage that supports what you said. Kazuaki Shimazaki 10:34, 3 November 2006 (UTC)

UPDATE: I've seen 128.170.136.277's contributions. Interesting info but still only vague references to Chinese official information or Chinese sources. Surely, "Chinese official information" would have made their way into some Chinese military journal by now? The only site provided still contradicts the reference directly.

For citation requests, to avoid shooting through the article with ugly "citation required" tags, I chose to only emphasize the sentences asserting that the Chinese choice of the E/F band as correct. Certainly, some other countries, not only the Ukraine, but also the French/Italian/Germans (G-band for EMPAR) and the Dutch (X-band for APAR) had different conclusions. Some justification and attribution of this position is required not only as a citation, but also to avoid an NPOV problem.

But really, put up as many citations as possible. Please. Kazuaki Shimazaki 17:23, 14 December 2006 (UTC)