Talk:The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
All this material is original (I wrote it). The quotations were indeed from the book cover and were cited accordingly, please delete if this is against the rules. I do believe, however, that the last sentence of my review should be preserved which follows those cited reviews.
(An observation - it is strange that such a fuss is made over cited reviews given the ownership of all our Wikipedia entries by (effectively) a single individual).
[edit] Suspected copyvio reverted
NHSavage recently merged a plot summary originally contributed by 24.127.101.24 into this article. I have tentatively reverted the merge, since the style (including the presence of review quotes) makes me suspect the text may have been copied from a back cover blurb or an advertisement. However, I have been unable to find a matching original on the web, so I have no actual evidence of this being a copyright violation, just a personal hunch. how do you feel?The original unmerged version by 24.127.101.24 can be found here. If you recognize the source, please let me know. If you are, in fact, the original author of the text, please say so. In that case I have nothing against including it in the article. Any (non-copyvio) improvements to the current version are also welcome. —Ilmari Karonen (talk) 20:54, 13 November 2005 (UTC)