Talk:The Freddie Mercury Tribute Concert

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You have new messages (last change).
This article is part of the Queen WikiProject, a WikiProject that aims to improve the coverage of Queen on Wikipedia.
Start This article has been rated as Start-Class on the assessment scale.
High This article has been rated as High importance on the importance scale.
The article has been rated for quality and/or importance but has no comments yet. If appropriate, please review the article and then leave comments here to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article and what work it will need.
Queen WikiProject To-Do
edit - history - watch - purge
  • Make Queen (band) a featured article.
  • Get the Queen WikiProject page done.
  • Change all stubs to articles.
The Queen WikiProject needs your help! We are currently in the process of defining article and notability guidelines for albums and songs.

[edit] Criticisms and Controversies

A current discussion is taking place about the extent to which Brian May may have used The Freddie Mercury Tribute Concert in part in order to promote both his own songwriting as well as his upcoming solo album.

NOTE: This article has been repeatedly vandalised!! My suggestion is that, rather than simply erasing large sections of material, discussions be addressed at this site.

[edit] Paragraph of Nonsense

Please stop adding this paragraph of nonsense back. All of this is POV, conjecture and speculation from a certain point of view. Let's keep it to facts. Very little controversy came from the concert, nothing was mentioned by other sources. Clearly, this is someone with an agenda and an ax to grind, portraying Brian May as an egomaniac attempting to cash in on Mercury's death-almost NONE of the media coverage that resulted implied such a thing. The paragraph also states that Mercury was the "main songwriter," whereas Queen had no "main songwriter" with many times Brian May writing just as much as Freddie did (and just as many hits). Also, this poster is obviously not of great intelligence--note misspellings like "sceptics" and "prominantly" as well as punctuation lacking, missing spaces and no capitals at the beginning of sentences. The paragraph in question is here:

    • "Similar to other stadium-sized events such as Live Aid, the Freddie Mercury Tribute Concert has been considered by some to be a self-promotion gimmick by the remaining band members (especially guitarist Brian May). It has been suggested that it wasn't a genuine tribute to Freddie, since more of May's songs were performed. This is peculiar considering that Mercury was the main songwriter in the band. Also, it has been noted that only a handful of the artists (e.g. Elton John, Robert Plant, George Michael, David Bowie, Liza Minelli, Ian Hunter, Annie Lennox) were friends or influences to Freddie. Some sceptics believe that others (Iommi, Rose, Hetfield, Seal, Daltrey, Elliot) were brought in simply because of Brian May's musical preferences or in order to increase the audience. The great popularity and prominence of Guns N' Roses and Metallica at the time can be seen to support this argument. on the other hand, both bands (before and after the event)have publicly sighted Queen as an influence. Moreover, Metallica had recently recorded a Grammy Award winning cover of 'Stone Cold Crazy', while members of Guns N' Roses, especially Rose, have spoken prominantly with huge admiration for Mercury and the band". CinnamonCinder December 5 2005
To CinnamonCinder, Because so many people are involved in writing the articles on Wikipedia, the appearance of various spelling errors and/or omissions of words is inevitable. Furthermore, since the writing can always be improved, this alone does not represent a valid excuse for erasing an entire paragraph. However, I re-wrote the section in order to make it read better and I do admit that it previously pretty hard to follow.
On the other hand, a recent discussion on www.queenzone.com revealed that many fans agree with the overall suggestion that The Freddie Mercury Tribute Concert was not a genuine tribute to Freddie Mercury, for various reasons. You have to admit that it is strange that Brian May's songs dominated the concert when the purpose of the event itself was supposedly to honor Freddie Mercury! He further used the event in order to perform a song called "Too Much Love Will Kill You", which was a single on his upcoming solo album! For all of these reasons, I do believe that some of the overall points points should remain. On the other hand, I agree that some of the points that were being added were so dramatic that it was becoming funny! Perhapds a compromise of some sort should be made. User:67.161.159.218 December 5 2005
By the way, here are various clips of what different Queen fans had to say:
  • " I also found it appalling that Brian May would use the event in order to promote the single for his upcoming album. More amusingly, he actually goes so far as to declare that this particular self-promoting act represented the best thing that he could do to honor Freddie!"
  • "The reason why there weren't so many Freddie tracks at the FM tribute concert and on the Q+PR tour is quite simply because it's incredibly difficult to sing many songs like Freddie did! Songs were picked so that others could lend their own style to them."
  • "I must admit, I share a lot of the same feelings as the topic starter. The tribute concert, completely."
  • "The only problem with Brian is that he takes himself a way too serious. Maybe his sense of humour is low when it comes to him."
  • User:67.161.159.218 December 5 2005

[edit] The Paragraph

The paragraph reads much better now, so thank you, and I left that. However, I deleted the second, smaller paragraph--it is possible to connect every artist with Freddie in one way or another--all of them either influenced Freddie, were friends with Freddie, or drew considerable influence from Freddie and the overall work of Queen. Also, expect further editing of the paragraph--though the concert may have had more May songs than others, one need only take a look at the Magic Tour setlist to see that the band often had many May songs in their setlist, because many of his songs worked very well live. CinnamonCinder 05:17, 5 December 2005 (UTC)

To Cinnamon cinder, yes, the paragraph does read a lot better than it did. Good points were also added, so I have no real problem with it. To me, it seems like a pretty good compromise, since it mentions both points of view. User:67.161.159.218. December 5 2005
Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../t/h/e/Talk%7EThe_Freddie_Mercury_Tribute_Concert_f6d9.html"