The Cuban Missile Crisis: Second Holocaust

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The Cuban Missile Crisis: Second Holocaust by Robert L. O'Connell is an alternative history essay in which the 1962 Cuban missile crisis developed into war. The essay was published in What Ifs? of American History, edited by Robert Cowley.

War breaks out after a senior Soviet naval captain uses a "nuclear torpedo" against United States naval forces off the Cuban coast. (Soviet authorities had earlier decided that senior captains could fire such torpedoes in certain circumstances without first obtaining authorisation from higher up.) Matters soon escalate to the point that a Soviet missile is launched from Cuba, destroying Washington, D.C. and killing President John F. Kennedy, Vice-President Lyndon B. Johnson, and most other civilian decision-makers.

This act seals the Soviet Union's doom: had Kennedy survived, he might have ordered a measured response; since he didn't, surviving American generals order a total attack, which continues long past the destruction of any Soviet military capacity. In the course of The Two Days' War, Cuba is completely destroyed, with 95% of its population being killed; heavy radiation spreads throughout the Caribbean and also damages southern Florida, which had been attacked by the Soviets. The Soviet Union is also destroyed, not just militarily crushed, with some 80% of its population perishing in the nuclear attacks themselves and the ensuing large-scale famines and radiation sickness. The East European countries are also severely damaged and lose a large part of their populations.

As a result, the US is completely isolated and ostracised in the post-war world and accused of having perpetrated genocide, the "Second Holocaust" of the title. The situation is exacerbated by Nixon being elected president in 1964, refusing to make any apology and also refusing to give up nuclear arms as required by a treaty signed in Geneva by all other surviving nations on Earth. NATO collapses with all other members leaving, and the United States leaves the UN, where resolutions were adopted accusing it of war crimes; the United States orders the UN to leave New York City. Eugene McCarthy, elected president in 1968, offers partial concessions which fail to satisfy the rest of the world.

The story is presented as a summary of the report prepared by a high-level US commission of inquiry which thoroughly investigated the course of the war and how it came to have such a horrific result, and reached the conclusion that the US must give up its nuclear arms in order to be re-accepted in the International Community.

After years of being classified it is presented to the public by Newt Gingrich, who in this history is the Chief Archivist of the US and who had never gone into politics.