Restoration Movement
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
- For information related to dispensational Christian views regarding the end times, see restorationism.
The Stone-Campbell Restoration Movement (or simply, Restoration Movement) is a religious reform movement born in the early 1800s in the United States during the Second Great Awakening. The nickname is taken from the names of Barton W. Stone and Alexander Campbell, who are regarded by some historians as the leading figures of four independent movements with like principles who merged together into two religious movements of significant size. Many of the more conservative members of the Churches of Christ object to the phrase "Stone-Campbell Movement" as being derogatory. Restorationism sought to renew the whole Christian church, on the pattern set forth in the New Testament, without regard to the creeds developed over time in Catholicism or Protestantism, which allegedly kept Christianity divided. Churches are now found throughout the globe, claiming to "concentrate on the essential aspects of the Christian faith, allowing for a diversity of understanding with non-essentials."
Key practices are the weekly celebration of the Lord's Supper on the first day of each week, and a commitment to believer's baptism, initially submersion was in a river, stream, or lake most probably.
Contents |
[edit] Modern branches
Four modern North American religious groups trace their heritage back to roots in the Stone-Campbell Restoration movement:
- The Christian Churches (Disciples of Christ)
- The Independent Christian Churches/Churches of Christ
- The Churches of Christ (non-instrumental)
- The churches of Christ (non-institutional)
The other large groups of the movement are:
- The Churches of Christ in Australia
- International Churches of Christ
- The United Reformed Church in the United Kingdom (also affiliated with the Reformed Church movement)
- The Fellowship of Churches of Christ in the United Kingdom
- The Associated Churches of Christ in New Zealand
Although they disassociate themselves from the Stone-Campbell Movement and have the least in common with the other branches, the Christadelphians share a heritage from the movement.
The Christian — Churches of Christ — Disciples of Christ family of Churches are linked through the World Convention of Churches of Christ. They will meet for the XVIIth World Convention of Churches of Christ in Nashville, Tennessee in July-August 2008. Also see Jesse Moran Bader
[edit] Pioneers of the movement
Although Barton W. Stone, Thomas and Alexander Campbell, and Walter Scott were to become the best-known and most influential early leaders of the movement, others preceded them and laid the foundation for their work.
- Barton W. Stone (1772-1844) - Texts
- Thomas Campbell (1763-1854) - Texts
- Alexander Campbell (1788-1866) - Texts
- Walter Scott (1796-1861) - Texts
- James O'Kelly (1735?-1826), Durham, North Carolina - Texts
- Rice Haggard (1769-1819) - Texts
- Elias Smith (1764-1846) - Texts
- Abner Jones (1772-1841) - Texts
Scholars such as C. Leonard Allen at Abilene Christian University say that, besides the New Testament, the Restoration Movement was also influenced by the philosophy of John Locke and Scottish common sense philosophy.
[edit] Key principles
- Christianity should not be divided, Christ intended the creation of one church.
- Creeds divide, but Christians should be able to find agreement by standing on the Bible itself (from which they believe all creeds are but human expansions or constrictions) instead of on the opinions of people about the Bible.
- Ecclesiastical traditions divide, but Christians should be able to find common ground by following the practice (as best as it can be determined) of the early church.
- Names of human origin divide, but Christians should be able to find common ground by using biblical names for the church (i.e., "Christian Church," "Church of God" or "Church of Christ" as opposed to "Methodist" or "Lutheran", etc.). It is in this vein that conservative members of the Churches of Christ object to the phrase "Stone-Campbell Movement".
[edit] The Christian Connection
Inextricably related to and intertwined with the Restoration Movement is the Christian Connection (sometimes spelled as Connexion). This religious movement began in several places and were secessions from three different denominations during the late 18th and early 19th centuries. In 1792, James O’Kelley (O'Kelly), dissatisfied with the role of bishops in the Methodist Episcopal Church, separated from this body. O’Kelley’s movement, centering in Virginia and North Carolina, was originally called Republican Methodists.
The denominational name was dropped in 1794 favor of the name “Christian” and a commitment to use the bible as the only “rule of faith and practice.” During the first several years of the 19th century, two Baptist ministers in New England espoused similar views to O’Kelley and began exclusively using the name “Christian.” Working independently at first, Elias Smith of Vermont and Abner Jones of New Hampshire joined together in their efforts.
In 1801, the Cane Ridge Revival in Kentucky would plant the seed for a movement in Kentucky and the Ohio River valley to disassociate from denominationalism. Barton W. Stone and four others separated from the Springfield Presbytery in 1804 preferring to be known only as “Christians.” Interestingly enough, Rice Haggard who suggested that the Republican Methodists use only the name Christian was the impetus behind Stone's western group doing the same.
By 1808, O’Kelley’s followers and the Smith/Jones movement were united; Stone’s Christians in Kentucky would soon follow suit. This loose fellowship of churches was called by the names “Christian Connection/Connexion” or “Christian Church.”
When Stone and Alexander Campbell’s Reformers (also known as Disciples and Christian Baptists) united in 1832, only a minority of Christian Churches participated. The participating churches largely were from Kentucky, Indiana, and southern Ohio. Those who did not unite with Campbell continued to use the name Christian Church as did the Disciples — thus beginning the confusion over names among the various factions of the Restoration Movement which continues today.
The Christian Church merged with the Congregational Church in 1931 to form the Congregational Christian Church. The Evangelical and Reformed Church formed in 1934 as a merger of the Reformed Church in the United States and the Evangelical Synod of North America. In 1957, the Congregational Christian Church and the Evangelical and Reformed Church after twenty years of discussion forged the United Church of Christ.
In 1989, the UCC and Disciples of Christ agreed to participate in full communion with each other while remaining separate denominations.
Sources
Murch, James DeForest. Christians Only. Cincinnati: Standard Publishing, 1962.
Jennings, Walter Wilson. Origin and Early History of the Disciples of Christ Cincinnati: Standard Publishing, 1919.
Morrill, Milo True. History of the Christian Denomination in America. Dayton: The Christian Publishing Association, 1912.
A Short Course in UCC History: The Christian Churches
UCC-Disciples Ecumenical Partnership
A Short Course in UCC History: The Congregational Christian Churches
A Short Course in UCC History: The Evangelical and Reformed Church
[edit] Churches of Christ/Disciples of Christ split
In 1906 the Churches of Christ and the larger Disciples of Christ split over many issues that ran back to the Campbell-Stone Union in 1824. Actually, it is more correct to say that a split which had been brewing for decades was formalized in 1906, the U.S. Census Bureau listed the groups separately for the first time in its religious census. One of the issues that lead to the split was exclusivism. Since 1836 Campell and Stone noticed a growing "furious zeal for orthodoxy". The exclusivism faction never comprised a majority within the whole of the Restoration Movement, but it did eventually dominate the majority of the Southern churches. In the American South, churches of the Restoration tradition tend to identify themselves with the name Church of Christ and argue that it was their faction that remained true to the original principles of the Restoration Movement, not vice versa.
On October 23, 1849, a group of individuals met in Cincinnati, Ohio with the intention of creating a "general church organization for the furtherance of the work by the church collectively." This action caused immediate disagreements among the churches, because such organizations had previously been abolished. Barton W. Stone himself had in fact taken part in the abolition of the Springfield Presbytery, and authored at that time a very influential document, The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery, which contained within it the idea that the existence of all such bodies was necessarily divisive and hence sinful.
About nine or ten years after that, L. L. Pinkerton, who was a member of the Midway, Kentucky church brought a melodeon into the church building. One of the elders of that assembly removed the melodeon that evening but it was soon replaced by another. Until that time all singing in the churches had been a capella - without instrumental accompaniment. Generally speaking, the bulk of the urban congregations, particularly in the Northern states, were not totally averse to this development, which was also gaining momentum in the other religious groups around them, while rural congregations, particularly in the Southern United States, tended to oppose this trend.
About 40 years later, the U.S. Census Bureau, in consultation with the leaders of the two factions, decided to list the members of these two movements separately. Although exclusivism was one of the factors involved in the split, it was not the only factor. Other issues revolving around baptism, plus the missionary society and instrumental music issues noted above, also contributed to the split. In most Churches of Christ, it is maintained that the prime issue was that of instrumental music in services of worship.
After the split the Churches of Christ generally became more exclusive, while the Disciples of Christ became more inclusive. The Churches of Christ became more rigid in their interpretation of the Bible, while the Disciples became less so, becoming more "mainline", where for the most part they remain today.
By 1926 a split began to form within the Disciples over the future direction of the church. Conservatives within the group began to have problems with the perceived liberalism of the leadership, upon the same grounds described earlier excepting instrumental music. In 1927 they held the first North American Christian Convention, and the Independent Christian Churches/Churches of Christ began to emerge as a distinct group from the Disciples, although the break was not totally formalized until the late 1960s. By this time the decennial religious census was a thing of the past and it is impossible to use it as a deliniation as it was in 1906.
The Disciples of Christ today are still not totally devoid of the conservative-liberal tension. A related movement known as the Disciple Heritage Fellowship<http://www.disciple-heritage.org> (originally "Disciples Renewal"), has been particularly critical of perceived liberalism in the denomination and purports to call the church back to its Restorationist roots. It is closely related to the Confessing Movement found in several other mainline denominations.
[edit] Church of Christ schisms
After the split between the Church of Christ and the Disciples of Christ movements, many Churches of Christ found that other issues still divided them.
Since the members of the Churches of Christ agreed that there was no scriptural basis for an association of churches or a synod, the churches were all independent and autonomous. All disagreements in doctrine were handled locally, although open discussion was encouraged on a national or international basis. Most issues were discussed by the publishers of religious periodicals, who used their periodicals to present their own views and to debate the views of others. Between 1920 and 1960 over 20 splits [citation needed] among the Churches of Christ had formed. Critics charged that the Churches of Christ had in some ways become a series of denominations within a denomination, exactly what Stone and Campbell had worked so hard to avoid. [citation needed]
[edit] Largest subgroups
The most notable subgroups were:
- The "one-cuppers", who believe that the use of only one cup during the Lord's Supper is acceptable. Many of these churches are also divided over the practice of someone breaking the bread before each individual partakes.
- The non-Sunday school group, who believe that Sunday School is wrong, since it is mentioned nowhere in the Bible and unheard of prior to the 18th century. Some of these congregations have further divided over issues such as divorce and remarriage. However, in recent years many of these splits have begun to be resolved.
-
- There is a considerable overlap between the first two groups listed. Almost all of the "one-cup" belief churches reject Sunday School, while around half of the non-class churches take the "one-cup" position. Almost all of congregations of one of these persuasions also reject institutions, though they have little association with churches classified in the third group (see below). These groups largely divided from the mainstream churches in the early twentieth century. Non-class churches in the United States number around 1100 (8% of Churches of Christ, or around 2% of membership), while about half these are also one-cup groups.
-
- Some of the churches in those groups (and others to a much lesser extent) have been at odds over whether to hire a full-time "minister" for a congregation. They asked whether this was in fact an acceptance and endorsement of the extra-Biblical concept of clergy. Many of them believe that preaching is properly done by male members of the church, perhaps occasionally reinforced by a travelling evangelist engaged only for a specific event or series of events. There has also been discussion in some churches about whether anyone now living truly meets what are seen as the New Testament requirements for the office of elder.
- The "non-institutional" brethren (sometimes perjoratively referred to as "anti" churches within the more mainstream church of Christ body), who objected to centralized oversight between congregations and the resulting institutions such as children's homes. They did not object to operating in parallel to accomplish certain goals, but held that each assembly engaged in such an effort must oversee its own participation without external oversight or the pooling of funds into an intercongregational fund or a fund overseen by one church but funded by many. The non-institutional brethren also hold that the universal fellowship of believers (usually called the "universal church") is not organizable nor institutional (i.e., composed of individuals with no collective work, not congregations or "local churches"). Division with the mainstream began after World War II and was completed by the 1960s. These churches number over 2000 (around 15% of churches and 10% of membership of the Churches of Christ).
- Premillennialist Faction --While Premillennialism is mainstream doctrine in many Protestant denominations, it has never been so in Churches of Christ, but has had enough adherents that they were a visible subgroup. Division over this issue occurred in the 1920s, and churches espousing this position number around 80.
[edit] Other issues
At one time, pacifism was an issue of serious concern. Prominent Church of Christ leaders before World War II such as David Lipscomb, J.W. McGarvey, Moses E. Lard, Robert Milligan, and Tolbert Fanning held pacifist positions. Post-World War II, the pacifist faction has largely died out as a recognizable subgroup.
Another schism which ultimately split the Churches of Christ again, was the Crossroads Movement which started in the 1960s and 1970s (also called the "Boston Movement" or "Discipling Movement"). The Crossroads Movement initially started as a somewhat radical, although largely accepted, movement within some institutional churches led by Chuck Lucas. The Crossroads Movement spread across Churches of Christ as a means to revitalize smaller churches and evangelize college campuses. The Crossroads church of Christ utilized informal Bible Studies, called "Soul Talks" to evangelize entire campuses. They also believed in the use of "Prayer Partners" which paired believers together to work on spiritual issues. The Soul Talk Leaders held weekly meetings to discuss the spiritual development of the brothers and sisters in their small groups. The Crossroads Movement started at the 14th Street Church of Christ in Gainesville, Florida, which became known as "Crossroads Church of Christ", an incubator for the future International Churches of Christ.During the 1980s, Kip McKean and the Boston Church of Christ became prominently associated with the trend. Much of the outside literature during this period refers to it as the "Boston Movement" or occasionally the "Discipling Movement," after the later practice of assigning each new church member a mentor who was to "disciple" the newer member through prayer and advice about a wide range of day-to-day decisions. This movement appears to be directly related to the Shepherding Movement that was gaining influence in the wider Evangelical world at the time.
Partially in reaction to the Crossroads Movement and Postmodernism, many congregations have questioned the traditions of the mainstream Churches of Christ, sometimes hiring preachers from outside the Churches of Christ and generally taking a more ecumenical stance toward other churches. Essentially, these congregations now constitute yet another subgroup. Some of these congregations no longer use the name "Church of Christ," allow instrumental music, and even de-emphasize the necessity of baptism, but insist they remain loyal to the Restoration traditions of non-denominationalism and Biblical authority. Many within the mainstream Churches of Christ see this as a move toward Evangelicalism.
[edit] The Restoration Movement internationally
Restoration Movement churches are found around the world and the World Convention of Churches of Christ provides a link for them.
Their genealogies are representative of developments in North America. Their theological orientation ranges from fundamentalist to liberal to ecumenical. In some places they have joined with churches of other traditions to form united churches at local, regional or national level.
These trends can be seen with the Churches of Christ in Australia.
[edit] See also
[edit] External links
- Churches of Christ in Australia
- Restoration Movement Pages, Memorial University of Newfoundland
- The Christian - Churches of Christ - Disciples of Christ family of Churches XVIIth World Convention of Churches of Christ in Nashville, Tennessee, July-August 2008.
- The Christian Restoration Association
- The Christian Standard (periodical).
- Independent Christian Churches/Churches of Christ Locator
- The LookOut (periodical).
- North American Christian Convention
- Restoration Movement Colleges, Universities, and Seminaries
- Ministry Employment Network
- Ozark Christian College
- Restoration Movement Internet Portal.
- RestorationUnity.com Representing greater unity among restoration churches
A different view of the history of this movement (from a "non-institutional" viewpoint) may be discovered by studying the publications of Truth Magazine Publications and Florida College publications. External links for these two publishing sources are:
- Florida College Bookstore
- Truth Magazine Bookstore
- EMOS EMOS, or Evangelical Ministries of Sylvania, has a monthly bulletin that combines biblical and theological research that will help equip and train Christians to follow Christ. This ministry is part of the American Restoration Movement
[edit] History and Sources
[edit] References
- North, James B. (1994). Union in Truth: An Interpretive History of the Restoration Movement. Cincinnati, Ohio: The Standard Publishing Company. ISBN 0-7847-0197-0.
- Flavil R. Yeakley, ed., The Discipling Dilemma: A Study of the Discipling Movement Among Churches of Christ (Nashville: Gospel Advocate Co., 1988).
- C. Leonard Allen and Richard T. Hughes, Discovering Our Roots: The Ancestry of Churches of Christ (Abilene, TX: ACU Press, 1988)
- Martin Edward Wooten, "The Boston Movement as a 'Revitalization Movement'" (D.Min. thesis, Harding Graduate School of Religion, 1990)
- Jerry Jones, What Does the Boston Movement Teach? vols. 1-3 (Bridgeton, MO: Jerry Jones, 12880 Bittick, 1991-93)
- United States Department of Commerce and Labor, Bureau of the Census, Religious Bodies, 1906 (United States Printing Office, 1910), 236
- West, Earl Irvin (2002). The Search for the Ancient Order Vol. 1. Gospel Light Publishing Company. ISBN 0-89225-154-9
- Foster, Douglas A.(Editor), Blowers, Paul M.(Editor), Dunnavant, Anthony L.(Editor), Williams, D. Newell(Editor). The Encyclopedia of the Stone-Campbell Movement. Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, Grand Rapids, Michigan. ISBN 0-8028-3898-7
- Foster, Douglas A., Reese, Jack, Childers, Jeff W. The Crux of the Matter: Crisis, Tradition, and the Future of Churches of Christ. ACU Press. ISBN 0-89112-035-1
