Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Winter Soldier Investigation
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This is not a "gotcha" page. It's not an RFC "on" or "against" anyone. I am literally requesting that my fellow Wikipedians comment on the following matter:
- The Winter Soldier Investigation article has been blanked several times on the grounds that it contains many copyright violations. After repeatedly asking for a specific instance -- and being ignored, harassed; having the subject changed; etc. -- finally one signed in user and one IP user addressed my question. A passage was cited at talk:Winter Soldier Investigation, with book title and page number.
- But one said the quote *IS* on that page, and the other said it *ISN'T*! Now, I'm not going to go to a library or used bookstore and settle this myself. I expect more competence and/or honesty from my co-contributors.
What shall we do about all this?
- The specific quote (which is, or is not, to be found where cited)
- The general issue of the article supposedly having many such instances
I certify that this is a problem - but I'm not going to use the gotcha template - I don't want action taken against a person, but rather a solution for the article. Uncle Ed 13:31, 24 October 2005 (UTC)
- I'm relisting this at Copyright Problems. Radiant_>|< 16:58, 29 October 2005 (UTC)
