Private militias in Iraq

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article may require cleanup to meet Wikipedia's quality standards.
Please discuss this issue on the talk page or replace this tag with a more specific message. This article has been tagged since December 2006.
Iraq War
Phases
Invasion – Post-invasion (Insurgency – Civil War)

Engagements
Nasiriyah – Baghdad – Debecka Pass – Peninsula Strike –Red Dawn – Spring 2004 Uprising – 1st Fallujah – 1st Ramadi – Husaybah – Najaf – 2nd Fallujah – Mosul – Matador – Haditha – Steel Curtain – Al-Askari Mosque – 2nd Ramadi – Together Forward – Amarah – Turki

Full list of Coalition operations
This box: view • talk • edit

Private militias in Iraq is a phenomenon that has not been common after complete revolutions that terminate a nation's constitution. For instance, none of the European countries after World War II or Japan had private militias that were not directly affiliated with any governmental institutions. After the fall of Saddam Hussein in 2003, well-funded and heavily armed private militias have sprung up that provide the impetus of the Iraqi insurgency.

Contents

[edit] Official statements

U.S. Ambassador to Iraq, Zalmay Khalilzad asseverates that "the existence of private militias" has loomed as "a persistent problem."[1]

Brett McGurk, Director for Iraq, from the National Security Council has stated,"The Iraqi constitution makes clear that militias are illegal[citation needed] and the new government platform pledges to demobilize militias as one of its principal goals....[The] private militias...purport to enforce religious law through illegal courts. "[2]

U.S. Senator Ted Kennedy has said, "Sectarian violence between Shiites and Sunnis is being fueled by the private militias, is now the biggest threat to stability."[3] Moreover, U.S. Senator John Warner has urged the White House to prod Nouri al-Maliki to empower the Iraqi army to subdue the militias and stated, "It is their job, not the U.S. coalition forces' to subdue and get rid of these private militias"[4].

[edit] No martial law

Militias in Iraq bear firearms with impunity.
Militias in Iraq bear firearms with impunity.

One dilemma has been the imposition of martial law and suspension of civil liberties to bring order and then restore democratic rule. The idea was pondered yet never implemented[5][6] notwithstanding the fact that many of today's democracies have used martial law to bring about an end to anarchy or those who wish to derail the government.

On 29 September 2006, Iraqi official imposed a curfew for two days in Baghdad.[7] As soon as the curfew ended "Sunday morning, new violence killed at least 22 people in Baghdad and elsewhere."[8]. Thereafter, martila law was temporarily extended again.[9]. Later, the curfew was ended.

[edit] Sustenance

According to a professor of Middle East politics,"They get some salary, they get a rifle, they get a uniform, they get the idea of belonging, protection from a group." However, he also notes that "People in [Mahdi Army] only get sporadic incomes. It's also very dangerous. You might be fighting another militia, such as the Badr organization, or worse the American army or the Iraqi army."[10] It is stated that Iran is backing the militias.[11]

[edit] Iraqi government

Nouri al-Maliki asked political parties to dismantle their militias on 5 October 2006.[12] He also stressed that militias are "part of the government", that there is a "political solution", and finally that they should "dissolve themselves" because "force would not work."[13] He blamed the sectarian violence on "al Qaeda in Iraq".[13] He has also condemned "Saddam Hussein loyalists"[14]. This has led to growing concerns about al-Maliki's unwillingness to eliminate Shia militias.[15] The Mahdi Army, a group linked to Nouri al-Maliki, is held responsible for "execution-style killings" of 11 Iraqi troops in August 2006.[16] U.S. officials posit that the militias are a more serious threat to Iraq's stability that the Sunni insurgency.[17]

SCIRI refused to acknowledge own militia, the Badr Organization.[12]

[edit] References and notes

  1. ^ Khalilzad: Crackdown under review CNN 11 July 2006
  2. ^ Ask the White House 10 April 2006
  3. ^ Senator Kennedy on "Mission Accomplished" and Supplemental Funding TedKennedy.com
  4. ^ Lawmakers to Bush: Push Iraq on Militias Associated Press 22 October 2006
  5. ^ Iraq Ponders Martial Law FoxNews 29 June 2004
  6. ^ Iraq's PM poised for martial law The Christian Science Monitor 7 July 2004
  7. ^ Iraqi authorities imposed a curfew in Baghdad Voice of America 30 September 2006
  8. ^ Iraq government facing sectarian rift AP via Yahoo! News 1 October 2006
  9. ^ 2nd mass kidnapping in Iraq; martial law extended CNN October 2, 2006
  10. ^ Luring away from militias
  11. ^ Kuwaiti MP Dr. Walid Al-Tabtabai: I Don't Think It Is True that the Iranian Nuclear Project Is for Energy Purposes
  12. ^ a b Iraq political groups warned on militias AP via Yahoo! News 5 October 2006
  13. ^ a b Rice Urges Greater Effort to Stem Violence in Surprise Baghdad Visit Voice of America 5 October 2006
  14. ^ http://www.voanews.com/english/2006-12-12-voa9.cfm
  15. ^ Iraq plan 'fails to impress': US concerns BBC News 3 October 2006
  16. ^ U.S. Coalition Kills 30 Shiite Fighters AP 8 October 2006
  17. ^ Revenge attacks grip town north of Baghdad Reuters 15 October 2006

[edit] See also

[edit] Further reading

  • IRAQ - PRIVATE MILITIAS MAY KEEP A ROLE (MAY 25/NYT).

Publication Date: 25-MAY-04 Publication Title: Periscope Daily Defense News Capsules Format: Online at http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/summary_0199-386547_ITM Description: NEW YORK TIMES -- Despite pledges by the U.S. military to disband private militias in Iraq, American officials now seem to be resigned to working with them, the New York Times reports.

The U.S. is engaged in negotiations with several of the main Iraqi militias to merge them with...

[edit] External links

Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../p/r/i/Private_militias_in_Iraq_c477.html"