Pournelle chart
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Pournelle chart, developed by Jerry Pournelle (in his 1963 political science Ph.D. dissertation), is a 2-dimensional coordinate system used to distinguish political ideologies. It is similar to the Political compass and the Nolan Chart in that it is a two-dimensional chart, but the axes chosen in the Pournelle chart are different from those in other systems.
The two axes are as follows:
- The x-axis (labeled Statism) refers to a political philosophy's feelings toward state and centralised government. The farthest right is state worship, and the farthest left views a state as the "ultimate evil". This is equivalent to the diagonal of the Nolan chart.
- The y-axis (labeled Rationalism) referring to a political philosophy's belief that all problems in society have solutions that can be found through the use of reason. The top indicates complete confidence in planned social progress, and the bottom represents skepticism of such approaches. This axis is not used in other systems, because the "up" direction includes all philosophies that claim society's problems can be solved through rationality, regardless of whether this process is government-led or individual-led.
"Leftist" ideologies, such as American liberalism, socialism and communism, are placed by Pournelle in the upper right-hand quadrant of high state control and high rationalism. Conservatism, fascism and Nazism are placed in the lower right hand quadrant of high state control and low rationalism. Classical anarchists are in the lower left hand corner of low state control and low rationalism. Libertarians and Objectivists are placed in the upper lefthand corner of low state control and high rationalism.
[edit] Criticisms of the model
This model lacks some nuances as to what is referred to as "control". For example, one may wish to divide the question into issues of personal freedom, and other issues. For instance, up into the 20th century, the United States gave a significant leeway to its citizens with respect to security (right to bear arms) while at the same time heavily regulating sexual activities, even between adults in private, see Comstock Law and sodomy law.
Some have criticized the model for the pejorative use of the word "irrational". However, this word does not indicate that the political philosophies near the "bottom" are irrational, nor that those who hold them are irrational. Rather, the "bottom" of the scale represents the belief that human rationality cannot perfect society. For example, the conservatism of Edmund Burke would be near the middle on the left-right scale, but near the bottom on the "rationality" scale (3/1', in Pournelle-style notation), because Burke believed that human society was not perfectable and was skeptical about initiatives aimed at vast improvements to society. Since Pournelle himself has views not far from those of Burke, it is clear that the term "irrational" is not intended as a pejorative.
