Talk:Pirc Defence

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Do we have any Pirc players listening?

I "corrected" the redir from Robatsch Defense from Modern Defence to Pirc Defence, but I realize now that may have been a mistake. It seems that Robatsch and Ufimtsev may actually belong with Modern instead of Pirc. I had just created a bunch of redirects to Pirc Defence from Robatsch Defence, Ufimtsev Defence, and Ufimtsev Defense when I realized this may be an error. If so, those redirects should be changed and the Modern Defence page probably needs to mention Robatsch and Ufimtsev. Also, what about the Pirc-Robatsch? Quale 06:26, 11 Apr 2005 (UTC)

Isn't the Robatsch Defense was a seperate defense from the Pirc. Since it is reached after e4 g6 versus the Pirc which is reached e4 d6 d4 nf6? I realize that they often end up similar but I don't think it should redirect here. Falphin 18:06, 8 May 2005 (UTC)