Pictish language

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Pictish
Spoken in: Scotland
Language extinction: 9th century or later
Language family: Indo-European
 Celtic
  Pictish
Language codes
ISO 639-1: none
ISO 639-2: to be added
ISO/FDIS 639-3:

The Pictish language is the extinct language of the Picts, in what is now Scotland. Evidence of the language is limited to place names and to the names of people found on monuments and the contemporary records. At its height, it may have been spoken from Shetland down to Fife.

The classification of the Pictish language is controversial.

In 1582, the humanist scholar (and native Gaelic-speaker) George Buchanan, expressed the view that Pictish was similar to languages like Welsh, Gaulish and Gaelic. The rest of research into Pictish has been described as postscript to Buchanan's work. [1]

According to W. B. Lockwood (1975) the view that Pictish was a Celtic language is tentative. Referring to an inscription in Shetland he writes: "When the personal names are extracted, the residue is entirely incomprehensible. Thus the Lunnasting stone in Shetland reads ettocuhetts ahehhttann hccvvevv nehhtons. The last word is clearly the commonly occurring name Nechton ..., but the rest, even allowing for the perhaps arbitrary doubling of consonants in Ogam, appears so exotic that philologists conclude that Pictish was a non-Indo-European language of unknown affinities".

However, the evidence of place names and personal names argue strongly that the Picts spoke Insular Celtic languages related to the more southerly Brythonic languages[2] though it has also been proposed that the language was closer to Gaulish than the Brittonic languages.[3] Columba, a Gael, needed an interpreter in Pictland, and Bede claimed that the Picts spoke a different language from the Britons, statements which say nothing about the nature of the Pictish language. It has been argued that one or more non-Indo-European languages survived in Pictland, an argument that is considered to be primarily based on limited negative evidence and the long discarded view that languages and material cultures can spread only through invasion and migration.[4] Pre-Indo-European elements can be found fairly frequently in northern Scottish place names, and it is theorised that some Pictish ogam inscriptions may also represent examples of this language.

Place names often allow us to deduce the existence of historic Pictish settlements in Scotland. Those prefixed with "Aber-" (river mouth), "Lhan-" (churchyard), "Pit-" (portion, share, farm), or "Fin-" (hill [?]) indicate regions inhabited by Picts in the past (for example: Aberdeen, Lhanbryde, Pitmedden, Pittodrie, Findochty, etc). However, it is "Pit-" which is the most distinctive element, while "Aber-" can also be found in places which were formerly Brythonic-speaking. Some of the Pictish elements, such as "Pit-", were formed after Pictish times, and may refer to previous "shires" or "thanages".[5] Other suggested place-name elements include "pert" (hedge, Welsh perth - Perth, Larbert), "carden" (thicket, Welsh cardden - Pluscarden, Kincardine), "pevr" (shining, Welsh pefr - Strathpeffer, Peffery).[6]

The evidence of place names may also reveal the advance of Gaelic into Pictland. As noted, Atholl, meaning New Ireland, is attested in the early 8th century. This may be an indication of the advance of Gaelic. Fortriu also contains place names suggesting Gaelic settlement, or Gaelic influences.[7] There are a number of Pictish loanwords in modern Scottish Gaelic, such as beinn, but few have survived into Doric.

Apart from personal names, Bede provides a single Pictish place name (HE, I, 12), when discussing the Antonine Wall:

It begins at about two miles' distance from the monastery of Abercurnig, on the west, at a place called in the Pictish language, Peanfahel, but in the English tongue, Penneltun, and running to the westward, ends near the city Alcluith.

Peanfahel - modern Kinneil, by Bo'ness - appears to contain elements cognate with Brythonic penn 'at the end' and Goidelic fal 'wall'. Alcluith, 'rock of the Clyde', is modern Dumbarton Rock, site of a major early medieval fortress and later castle.

[8]

[edit] Notes

  1. ^ This view may be something of an oversimplification: Forsyth, in Language in Pictland, offers a short account of the debate. Cowan, "Invention of Celtic Scotland" may be helpful for a broader view.
  2. ^ Forsyth, Language in Pictland, Price "Pictish", Taylor, "Place names", Watson, Celtic Place Names. For Kenneth H. Jackson's views, see "The Language of the Picts" in Wainright (ed.) The Problem of the Picts.
  3. ^ Ferguson, The Identity of the Scottish Nation.
  4. ^ Forsyth, Language in Pictland; the relationship between Basque and Pictish theorised by Federico Krutwig, lacks support in English-language publications. The website of Gorka J. Palazio presents some of Krutwig's ideas in English.
  5. ^ For place names in general, see Watson, Celtic Place Names, for shires/thanages see Barrow, "Pre-Feudal Scotland."
  6. ^ Glanville Price, "Pictish", p.128.
  7. ^ Watson, Celtic Place Names, page numbers wanting.
  8. ^ Nicolasen, Scottish Place-Names, pp. 204-205.

[edit] References

  • Ball, Martin J. and James Fife (eds.) The Celtic Languages. London: Routledge (2001) ISBN 0-415-28080-X
  • Cox, R. A. V. "Abstract: Modern Scottish Gaelic Reflexes of Two Pictish Words: *pett and *lannerc." in Ronald Black, William Gillies, and Roibeard Ó Maolalaigh (eds.) Celtic Connections: Proceedings of the Tenth International Congress of Celtic Studies, Vol. 1. East Linton: Tuckwell Press (1999), p. 504
  • Ferguson, William. ; The Identity of the Scottish Nation Edinburgh University Press, 1999. ISBN 0-7486-1071-5
  • Forsyth, K. Language in Pictland : the case against 'non-Indo-European Pictish' in Studia Hameliana #2. Utrecht: de Keltische Draak (1997). Etext Rev. Damian McManus. Cambrian Medieval Celtic Studies #38 (Winter 1999), pp. 109-110
  • Forsyth, K.; "Abstract: The Three Writing Systems of the Picts." in Black et al. (1999), p. 508
  • Griffen, T.D.; "The Grammar of the Pictish Symbol Stones" in LACUS Forum #27 (2001), pp. 217-26
  • Henderson, Isabel, The Picts (1967)
  • Lockwood, W.B., Languages of The British Isles, Past And Present, 1975, André Deutsch, ISBN 0-233-96666-8
  • Nicolaisen, W.F.H., Scottish Place-Names. John Donald, Edinburgh, 2001. ISBN 0-85976-556-3
  • Okasha, E.; "The Non-Ogam Inscriptions of Pictland" in Cambridge Medieval Celtic Studies #9 (1985), pp. 43-69
  • Price, Glanville, "Pictish" in Glanville Price (ed.), Languages in Britain & Ireland. Blackwell, Oxford, 2000. ISBN 0-631-21581-6
  • Wainwright, F.T. (editor), The Problem of the Picts (1955). ISBN 0-906664-07-1
Celtic languages
Continental Celtic Gaulish †| Lepontic † | Galatian † | Celtiberian † | Noric †
Goidelic Irish | Galwegian † | Manx | Scottish Gaelic (ScotlandCanada)
Brythonic Breton | Cornish | British † | Cumbric † | Ivernic † | Pictish † | Welsh
Mixed languages Shelta | Bungee †
Extinct