Talk:PeanutButterWiki

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You have new messages (last change).
Wikipedian The operator of the subject of this article, PeanutButterWiki, has edited Wikipedia as Dweekly (talk • contribs).

[edit] Tricky questions

It's a bit ironical that, when I first came across this article, the version in the answers.com Wikipedia mirror was a much better article than the version we had ourselves!

The problems I see are:

  • Defining original research, and deciding when citations are needed, are related and non-trivial questions. We don't ask for a citation to say the sky is blue or that Lincoln was a US president, that's common knowledge, but it's sometimes helpful to repeat such facts. Similarly, surely we don't need a citation to say that PBwiki is a wiki farm?
  • Deciding where to draw the line between description and promotion. The complete features list probably belongs on the PBwiki site, not here, an external link will do and save us the trouble of keeping it current. On the other hand, the more relevant features should be documented here.

So this is going to be a tricky article to expand. Much of what I have added has been previously added by other editors, and then removed! Such are the joys of a wiki. Andrewa 20:35, 26 September 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Rem sources tag

I've removed the {{sources}} tag. I've added some external links which should surely now be adequate, but IMO the existing links were adequate anyway, and there was no comment here as to what more was needed. Feel free to comment as to whether the article is now adequately sourced. Andrewa 19:57, 28 September 2006 (UTC)

Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../p/e/a/Talk%7EPeanutButterWiki_7169.html"