User talk:Okino

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Category:Příbram

I'd removed Category:Příbram from several articles about people. The categories are not intended to serve as all-encompassing database tool but to show few most defining characteristics of a person and birthplace is rather far from it. I'd created Category:Czech local politicians for these. Pavel Vozenilek 13:19, 25 November 2006 (UTC)

I am opposed to Your decision as the categories of People of the City are quite common in many other cities (compare for example Category:People from New York City, Category:People from Berlin, Category:Natives of Lyon and many others). Příbram is not a big city, so I don't think it is necessary to make independent category for the people with connection to Příbram. Anyway if this is a problem, I can make the category, which is - as You can see - usual.

I am open to discuss whether any individual article is needed to be categorized under Příbram, but I suppose that especially all the mayors of city (now Vacek, Fuksa and Řihák) and writer Jan Drda (born in Příbram, many of his books are directly connected to Příbram features like people or places) should be included in the category. I can understand, that for Dvořák or Týrlová their connection to Příbram was not so important, but on the contrary, it was important for Příbram itself.

Waiting for Your kind answer for a while before reverting.Okino 18:56, 25 November 2006 (UTC)