Talk:Nucular

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You have new messages (last change).
WikiProject Spoken Wikipedia The spoken word version of this revision (diff) of this article is part of WikiProject Spoken Wikipedia, an attempt to produce recordings of Wikipedia articles being read aloud. If you would like to participate, visit the project page, where you can join the project and find out how to contribute.

If I remember correctly, Jimmy Carter pronounces it this way, and he's a nucular engineer. -- Zoe

Why is that explanation considered incorrect? It seems all right to me. Is there another proposed explanation? - Montréalais
The pronunciation is considered incorrect. I've reworded it. -- Minesweeper

I propose merging and redirecting with nuclear Martin

The last edit by º¡º is about as NPOV as I've seen this article yet, however I'm still not sure "evolution" is the right choice here. Hephaestos 03:05 Mar 10, 2003 (UTC)

Thank you; I now consider it perfect. *grin* I'll shut up now. Hephaestos 03:11 Mar 10, 2003 (UTC)


educated speakers including scientists, lawyers, professors, congressmen, U.S. cabinet members, and at least one U.S. president and one vice president.

What makes M-W think the one U.S. president is educated? ;) -- Tarquin 19:12, 12 Sep 2003 (UTC)

Well he is educated, but that doesn't necessarily mean he's smart. - TheSeez

Were they referring to Dubya, Carter, or someone else by that "at least once U.S. president"? anthony 警告 13:21, 22 Nov 2004 (UTC)

Is it my imagination, or do some people (in the UK at least) talk about "new killer power stations" etc.? No wonder they've become so unpopular. Andy G 20:12, 23 Sep 2003 (UTC)

Why does it just say one president now? Did this turn out to not be true?

"Notable figures who have sometimes used this pronunciation include several Presidents of the United States, including John F. Kennedy, Dwight Eisenhower, Lyndon Johnson, Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton and George W. Bush."

~ Resister 00:38, 24 Oct 2004 (UTC)

I personally don't know for a fact that anyone except Dubya used it. If you can provide some cites, we should add this. anthony 警告 13:23, 22 Nov 2004 (UTC)

Here's a cite for Dwight D. Eisenhower, Gerald Ford, and Jimmy Carter using it, from the New York Times: http://www.uwm.edu/~iverson/htmlfiles/nucprolif.htm I'd be shocked if Lyndon Johnson and Bill Clinton didn't use it, considering their Southern backgrounds. Bill Clinton was notable for using other disapproved Southern constructions in public, such as double modals. ("might could" and the like.)

Here's a cite for Bill Clinton using it, written by a linguist and performed on NPR's Fresh Air: http://www-csli.stanford.edu/~nunberg/nucular.html

I'd be surprised if JFK used it, though with his non-rhotic Boston accent he did say "Cuber" for "Cuba," exhibiting the intrusive r characteristic of that acccent.

How about a link to linguistic evolution theories? I don't remember which page it was on, but I'm looking. --Harlan

Contents

[edit] Dictionary definition

Wikipedia is not a word usage guide. I suggest we transwiki this to Wiktionary, include a short blurb in nuclear (and I supposed Homer Simpson) if not already there, and then redirect to nuclear. anthony 警告 13:22, 22 Nov 2004 (UTC)


[edit] Huh?

"Nucular" is also the pronunciation preferred by Homer Simpson, and his confident use of it in The Simpsons exemplifies a level of cultural information that is largely overheard at some distance, second-hand, rather than read.

Sorry, from "cultural information" on, I don't get this at all. Does it use terms of art of postmodern textual analysis or some such? Maybe there should be a link explaining them, in that case. --Trovatore 30 June 2005 19:33 (UTC)

[edit] a possible phonotactical motivation

I think the reason why nuclear becomes nucular is phonotactically motivated.

  1. By assimilation, the [li.ər] sequence of the word [n(j)uː.kli.ər] becomes [ljər].
  2. This produces the disfavoured consonant cluster [klj]: English phonotactics has a constraint that stops are followed by one approximant at most.
  3. The disfavoured cluster is reduced. That reduction is achieved through metathesis and is probably influenced by the mentioned words ending in -cular and the word nuke.

An analogous reduction of a this disfavoured cluster of stop + two approximants is found in the pronunciation of the word blue: Originally, the vowel of blue was identical to the vowel of cue, approximately [iw]. In most dialects of English, [iw] shifted to [juː]. Theoretically, this would produce **[bljuː]. However, this disfavoured pronunciation was reduced (by ellision) to [bluː]. Note that there are English dialects that preserve the pronunciations [bliw] for blue and [kiw] for cue. (Other languages don't have that constraint, compare Spanish pliegue [ˈpljeɣe].)

Can any English language linguist confirm this or is this just crazy talk of me? -- j. 'mach' wust ˈtʰɔ̝ːk͡x 9 July 2005 16:05 (UTC)

It sounds reasonable, but then we also have the word likelier, which has the same sequence of phonemes [klj]. thefamouseccles 02:07, 11 Oct 2005 (UTC)
But the cluster in likelier cannot be reduced without destroying the connection to likely-er. Also, likelier has a perfectly serviceable equivalent in more likely, which is rather more likely to be used, certainly in speech. This is not a counterexample. 82.92.119.11 14:37, 20 November 2005 (UTC)
Ah, the word likelier is a good point! I don't think, however, that the lack of a substitute pronunciation *likular can explain why it is really pronounced likelier. I'd rather say it's probably because this word is morphologically transparent: It's a compound like + ly + er. Nuclear isn't, but suppose there'd be an adjective *nuke, then you'd have the adverb *nukely, which would have the comparative *nukelier – I'd bet this word wouldn't be mispronounced as nucular. ― j. 'mach' wust | ⚖ 19:01, 8 June 2006 (UTC)

See also [1] (the note of 9th June, 2006).

[edit] correct pronunciation

So, with the wrong pronunciation given, what actually is the other common pronunciation? --Abdull 15:05, 28 July 2005 (UTC)

Nu-clear. You can hear it pronounced at its Wikitionary page: http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/nuclear . --Fastfission 15:28, 28 July 2005 (UTC)

Given the issue with accents and regional dialects, I'm not sure you can say that it's the "correct" way of saying it, so much as the "mid-western neutral" pronunciation. None the less, the pronunciation "strongly encouraged" in Naval Nuclear Power School is the nu-clear one. I don't see colleges endorsing any other pronunciations. Izuko 15:53, 21 January 2006 (UTC)

In the authoritative (and very informative) Longman pronunciation dictionary, by professor John C. Wells (London), there's no entry nucular, and at nuclear the [-kjələ] pronunciation is given (for both British and American English), but considered incorrect (as, say, ['gri:viəs] for ['gri:vəs], grievous, or [ɑ:ks] for [ɑ:sk], ask). There are also the results of "an opinion poll carried out by the author in 1998 among a panel of 1,932 native speakers of British English from throughout Britain" (p. xii): 94% of the respondents preferred [-kliə], 6% [-kjələ].
This is just a quotation, which I thought might be of some interest.

[edit] Homer Simpson Works In A Nuclear Facility

Maybe this fact should be mentioned in the article.

  • why?--Manwe 13:28, 19 March 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Weekly World News

WWN, popular tabloid, had an article about Nucular power as opposed to Nuclear power... is that all right to add? jeti 14:45, 12 December 2005 (UTC)


[edit] Pedants Я Us

It may not be appropriate, either in place or time, but I feel compelled to point out that both "nucula" and "nucule" are actual words. (See discussion above.)

Here are the definitions:

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Nucula
Nu´cu`la
n. 1. (Zool.) A genus of small marine bivalve shells, having a pearly interior.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Nucule
Nu´cule (nū´kũl)
n. 1. (Bot.) Same as Nutlet.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Nutlet
nut·let Pronunciation (ntlt)
n.
1. A small nut.
2. The stone or pit of certain fruits such as the peach or cherry.

These words are, understandably, somewhat obscure. Thus, while there may be cause for disliking his mispronunciation of "nuclear", if President Bush starts calling something or someone "nuculer" and means it, that's the time to worry... <G>


[edit] Noo'klar

Dr. Strangelove has a good example of the Southern pronunciation. G.W. Bush's is an invented mispronunciation.

[edit] "Revert unpiping to avoid a redirect"

Well, it redirected to Bushism anyway. I actually made the change thinking that "The Decider" might have its own article. There wasn't anything sinister behind the edit. Dubc0724 17:55, 12 September 2006 (UTC)

I never assumed you were doing anything sinister. Heck, I don't even know if you're left-handed! I was just doing my WikiGnome duty, tidying things up.
Atlant 13:48, 13 September 2006 (UTC)
No problemo. Left handed, LOL. The Sinister Minister is my personal fave, if you like jazz banjo playing. Dubc0724 13:54, 13 September 2006 (UTC)
Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../n/u/c/Talk%7ENucular_28af.html"