Talk:Nemetschek
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Nemetscheck (not Nemetschek --- Article listed on Wikipedia:Votes for deletion Apr 30 to May 7 2004, consensus was to redirect to Nemetschek. Discussion:
Orphaned, poorly written one-sentence advertisement article on a CAD company, with extlink. Lupo 11:03, 30 Apr 2004 (UTC)
- Oh, and I see now that it is actually a duplicate: we have a (albeit only marginally better) stub at Nemetschek. Lupo 11:08, 30 Apr 2004 (UTC)
- [Summary: Keep] Is now a redirect to the correct spelling (Nemetschek). Note that this article was created out of List of CAD companies, and was misspelled about 3 or 4 times, but those redirects have now been deleted (they were pretty extreme misspellings, unlikely to be of use). Whether it should exist under any name is a different question - the redirect should stay if the article does (likely misspelling), but maybe the article (correctly spelled) should be listed here instead. - IMSoP 11:43, 30 Apr 2004 (UTC)
This is Wikispam anda duplicate of the Nemetscheck article cited above for deletion. Alcarillo 16:01, 30 Apr 2004 (UTC)- No, there is no duplication. The article originally listed was a misspelling of Nemetschek and is now, as is proper, a redirect there. If people feel that Nemetscheck (the misspelling) should not be kept even as a redirect, this should go to Redirects for deletion; comments on Nemetschek (the correct spelling) should be directed at the listing for that page, below. (to where I have copied the
struckoutpotion of your comment) - IMSoP 12:59, 1 May 2004 (UTC)
- No, there is no duplication. The article originally listed was a misspelling of Nemetschek and is now, as is proper, a redirect there. If people feel that Nemetscheck (the misspelling) should not be kept even as a redirect, this should go to Redirects for deletion; comments on Nemetschek (the correct spelling) should be directed at the listing for that page, below. (to where I have copied the
- OK, I've just realised what was going on - two listings using the same MediaWiki page is just asking for trouble, so I've split them up and tried to put comments on the one they were actually referring to. This listing should probably be removed, since it is a valid redirect unless the other article is deleted. - IMSoP 13:31, 1 May 2004 (UTC)
- Keep as a redirect - that solution is fine with me. And note that I did not say I considered Nemetschek a VfD-candidate, I just pointed out that there was a duplicate. I did not use one MediaWiki page for two articles. Lupo 09:28, 3 May 2004 (UTC)
End discussion
Note: see also Template:VfD-Nemetschek
