Talk:Minor characters in Suikoden

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Disagreed. Its far better to have separate pages for each SoD as it is, rather than trying to jam 540 character descriptions, statistics and trivia into one massive article. And even if such a merger for "minor" characters would occur, Most of the characters on this proposed merger are hardly minor figures in the series, such as Lepant and Viktor. Rorshacma 23:43, 4 August 2006 (UTC)

Agree! Many other things called Kreutz besides fantasy characthers.

Disagreed. Rorshacma is right. --Poki#3 17:51, 11 August 2006 (UTC)

Disagree. See above. And in regards to what the guy who didn't sign said: That's what disambiguation pages are for. I'm going to start adding (Suikoden) to some characters who have common names around, like changing "Viktor" to "Viktor (Suikoden)" Ephyon 17:18, 21 August 2006 (UTC)

I would have to disagree, Viktor is far from a "minor" character !! NeoMagus26 15:21, 2 September 2006 (UTC)

Disagree. Viktor is one of the Major characters and a bunch of Suikoden Characters have their own pages. Yayauc90 06:01, 6 September 2006 (UTC)

Disagree. viktor was anything but minor. Some of the lesser used SoD, maybe. Not Viktor.

Disagree. Merging them will only compromise the information on each character, as well as make the pages look more messed up and congested. Also as mentioned, since many more major characters are not suitable for being merged due to the extensive information available, it will make the decision of merging the so called 'minor' characters unrealistic and troublesome.

Oh wow, woops. I didn't even bother to check this discussion page before merging (I never would have thought to check an talk page for an article that didn't even exist!). That said, what notability do these characters have outside their respective games? Most game articles don't have seperate articles for most characters (novels almost NEVER do, and movies almost never do either. Many TV shows do, but only because in a given show they may appear across 150+ episodes). At the very least the minor ones should be here, with articles for only the most notable few from each game. I'll let you all decide on that. Cheers, and sorry again. Radagast83 05:07, 25 November 2006 (UTC)