Metrication in the United States

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This label, on a bottle of Head & Shoulders shampoo, illustrates the conflicted state of U.S. metrication in the early 21st century.
Enlarge
This label, on a bottle of Head & Shoulders shampoo, illustrates the conflicted state of U.S. metrication in the early 21st century.

The road towards metrication in the United States has been rocky and unsteady. In some fields, the metric system has been used in the United States since the early 1800s. The use of metric units has been gradually increasing for many years, but much of the public momentum has been lost since the 1980s, except in schools, science, and manufacturing.

Contents

[edit] 19th century

In the early 1800s, the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey (the government's surveying and map-making agency) used meter and kilogram standards brought from France. In 1866, Congress authorized the use of the metric system and supplied each state with a set of standard metric weights and measures.

In 1875, the United States solidified their commitment to the development of the internationally recognized metric system by becoming one of the original seventeen signatory nations to the Convention du Mètre. The signing of this international agreement concluded five years of meetings in which the metric system was reformulated, refining the accuracy of its standards. The Treaty of the Meter, also known as the "Meter Convention", established the Bureau international des poids et mesures (BIPM, International Bureau of Weights and Measures) in Sèvres, France, to provide standards of measurement for worldwide use.

In 1893, under the Mendenhall Order, metric standards, developed through international cooperation under the auspices of BIPM, were adopted as the fundamental standards for length and mass in the United States. The customary measurements – the foot, pound, quart, etc. – have been defined in relation to the meter and the kilogram ever since.

The 1895 Utah Constitution mandates in Article 10, Section 11, that "The Metric System shall be taught in the public schools of the State".

[edit] 20th century

The Conférence Générale des Poids et Mesures (General Conference on Weights and Measures), the governing body that has overall responsibility for the metric system, and which is made up of the signatory nations to the Treaty of the Meter, approved an updated version of the metric system in 1960. This modern system is called Le Système International d'Unités or the International System of Units, abbreviated SI.

On February 10, 1964, the National Bureau of Standards (now known as the National Institute of Standards and Technology) issued the following statement:

Henceforth it shall be the policy of the National Bureau of Standards to use the units of the International System (SI), as adopted by the 11th General Conference of Weights and Measures (October 1960), except when the use of these units would obviously impair communication or reduce the usefulness of a report.

The United Kingdom began a transition to the metric system in 1965 to more fully mesh its business and trade practices with those of the European Economic Community. The conversion of the United Kingdom and the Commonwealth nations to SI created a new sense of urgency regarding the use of metric units in the United States.

In 1968, Congress authorized a three-year study of systems of measurement in the U.S., with particular emphasis on the feasibility of adopting SI. The detailed U.S. Metric Study was conducted by the Department of Commerce. A 45-member advisory panel consulted with and took testimony from hundreds of consumers, business organizations, labor groups, manufacturers, and state and local officials.

ANMC logo
Enlarge
ANMC logo

The final report of the study, "A Metric America: A Decision Whose Time Has Come," concluded that the U.S. would eventually join the rest of the world in the use of the metric system of measurement. The study found that measurement in the United States was already based on metric units in many areas and that it was becoming more so every day. The majority of study participants believed that conversion to the metric system was in the best interests of the nation, particularly in view of the importance of foreign trade and the increasing influence of technology in American life.

US metrication logo
Enlarge
US metrication logo

The study recommended that the United States implement a carefully planned transition to predominant use of the metric system over a ten-year period. Congress passed the Metric Conversion Act of 1975 "to coordinate and plan the increasing use of the metric system in the United States." The Act, however, did not require a ten-year conversion period. A process of voluntary conversion was initiated, and the U.S. Metric Board was established. The Board was charged with "devising and carrying out a broad program of planning, coordination, and public education, consistent with other national policy and interests, with the aim of implementing the policy set forth in this Act." The efforts of the Metric Board were largely ignored by the American public, and in 1981, the Board reported to Congress that it lacked the clear Congressional mandate necessary to bring about national conversion. Due to this apparent ineffectiveness, and in a Reagan effort to reduce federal spending, the Metric Board was disestablished in the fall of 1982.

This measuring cup, manufactured and sold in the U. S. c. 1980 at the height of the metrication effort, features graduations in both metric and U. S. Customary systems—with the metric graduations in front (the front when the cup is held by a right-handed person).
Enlarge
This measuring cup, manufactured and sold in the U. S. c. 1980 at the height of the metrication effort, features graduations in both metric and U. S. Customary systems—with the metric graduations in front (the front when the cup is held by a right-handed person).

The Board's demise increased doubts about the United States' commitment to metrication. Public and private sector metric transition slowed at the same time that the very reasons for it became more pressing: the increasing competitiveness of other nations and the demands of global marketplaces.

Congress included new encouragement for U.S. industrial metrication in the Omnibus Trade and Competitiveness Act of 1988. This legislation amended the Metric Conversion Act of 1975 and designates the metric system as "the Preferred system of weights and measures for United States trade and commerce". The legislation states that the Federal Government has a responsibility to assist industry, especially small business, as it voluntarily converts to the metric system of measurement.

Federal agencies were required by this legislation, with certain exceptions, to use the metric system in their procurement, grants and other business-related activities by the end of 1992. While not mandating metric use in the private sector, the Federal Government has sought to serve as a catalyst in the metric conversion of the country's trade, industry, and commerce. Exceptions were allowed for the highway and construction industries. The Department of Transportation was planning to require metric units by 2000, but this plan was canceled by the 1998 highway bill TEA21. [3] Use in the U.S. military is generally high, due, in part, to the need to work with other nations' militaries.

Some members of Congress attempted to ban use of the metric system on federal highways in 1992 and 1993. [4] [5] However, these anti-metric bills were not met with much enthusiasm by the House and failed without a vote at the time. However, the National Highway System Designation Act passed in 1995 and prohibited the use of Federal-aid highway funds to convert existing signs or purchase new signs with metric units. [6]

[edit] 21st century

[edit] Metrication efforts

"Toward a Metric America" (button)

The current effort toward national metrication is based on the claim that industrial and commercial productivity, mathematics and science education, and the competitiveness of American products and services in world markets would be enhanced by completing the change to the international standard measurement system based on metric units. Many or most Americans, however, remain unconvinced of this position, or disagree over whether and how to pay and enforce complete conversion, which, if undertaken, could possibly incur considerable expense in the near term for millions of businesses and government agencies.

A potential problem for current metrication efforts is that many or most Americans, thirty years after the 1970s metric push, have little interest in metric usage. Daily life no longer features even dual usage of units such as Celsius for temperature, so most Americans have little contact with metric units on a daily basis. Those who need to use the metric system for work learn it, those who travel overseas learn enough to get by, but most others do not feel generally compelled to use it.

[edit] Mars Orbiter

The use of two different systems was the contributing factor in the loss of the Mars Climate Orbiter in 1998. NASA specified metric units in the contract. NASA and other organizations worked in metric units but one subcontractor, Lockheed Martin, provided thruster performance data to the team in pound force seconds instead of newton seconds. The spacecraft was intended to orbit Mars at about 150 km altitude, but the incorrect data meant that it probably descended instead to about 57 km, burning up in the Martian atmosphere.

[edit] Current usage

[edit] Daily life

While most Americans have heard of the metric system, metric usage remains low at the individual level. Weather reports on television are given in customary units (with the exception of hurricanes, where pressure is typically given in millibars at the national level). Few Americans understand the Celsius temperature scale, and would not know what to wear if outside temperature were reported to be 12° Celsius, for example. The BTU remains the common measure of heating and cooling. Clothing is measured in inches or sizes. The more common SI prefixes are widely known, and sometimes used with non-metric units. For example, computer hard drive capacity is measured in gigabytes and a lottery is named Megabucks. Nuclear explosions are measuered in kilotons and megatons of TNT. The letter K is widely accepted as meaning "thousand" (e.g., "She earned over 100K last year"). This usage has largely replaced the abbreviation m that was commonly used for "thousand" before the 1960s.

[edit] Consumer and retail

Numerous consumer products come in rounded metric-system sizes in the United States. The trend seems to be toward more product sizes based on metric units, due to the international nature of manufacturing, distribution, and sales. A few of these products display the metric quantity first or more prominently. Some items are produced and sold in rounded metric quantities (e.g., dental floss is often sold in 50 meter packages). Perhaps the most common metric item sold is the 2-liter bottle of soft drinks. Some supermarket chains also make their store brand soft drinks available in 3-liter party sizes as well. Half-liter (500 ml) and one-liter containers of soft drinks are increasingly sold alongside more traditional 12 oz, 16 oz, 20 oz, and 24 oz sizes, which are generally glass instead of plastic as the liter bottles are. Recently, The Coca Cola Company introduced 1.5 liter-bottles for its products as well.

However, attempts to sell 3- or 4-liter bottles of milk, instead of gallons, have been largely unsuccessful. Wine is sold in standard bottles of 750 ml, following the practice of the rest of the world, and a fifth of liquor, once one fifth of a gallon or 757 ml, is now commonly 750 ml. Bottled water is commonly found in half-liter and one-liter sizes, but 20 and 24 oz sizes remain common.

Household products such as shampoo, mouthwash, and dental floss have begun to be sold in metric sizes, and PowerBars and similar products have always been sold (but not marketed) by the gram. Consumer-size photographic film is commonly sold in a 35 mm standard, although print sizes and large format films are defined in inches. The standard method for sizing tires combines millimeters for tread width but uses inches for rim diameter.

Nutritional food labels typically report serving sizes in both systems but only list metric values (g or mg) for the breakdown of individual nutrients. The use of Calories (large calorie) instead of kilojoules is a case where a deprecated unit[1] is used instead of the appropriate SI unit.

Since 1992, the federal Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA) has required consumer goods to be labeled in both customary and metric units. There is a strong effort underway by industry to amend this law to allow manufacturers to use metric-only labeling. [7] Most states in the U.S. have already adopted laws allowing metric-only labeling. [8] According to the European Community (now the EU) Directive 80/181/EEC issued on 20 December 1979, the European Union will no longer allow dual-unit labels to appear on products effective as of 1 January 2010. [9] This directive was originally to have been implemented on 1 January 1990, but two 10-year extensions, largely due to US concerns, have since been granted, extending the deadline to 2010. It is unlikely that a third extension would be granted. [citation needed]

Pending the EU deadline, an amendment to the FPLA to allow metric-only labeling would allow manufacturers, both importers and exporters, to avoid the significant costs associated with having to produce two distinct types of package labels. A significant advance in American metrication could result from some products displaying metric weights and measures only. A bill to permit metric-only labeling at the federal level was to have been introduced in 2005. Significant opposition from the Food Marketing Institute, representing US grocers, has delayed the introduction of the bill, which would likely pass if put to a vote. The expressed fear of the FMI is that legislation to permit metric-only labels might also somehow mandate resizing of packaging to round metric sizes (a process already well underway), which could require expensive remodeling or replacement of existing display cases. A compromise has been suggested whereby manufacturers in both the US and the EU could opt for either metric-only or dual labeling, but this idea has been viewed dimly by the EU negotiators.

[edit] Construction

The construction industry has been the slowest to adopt metric units. Dimensional lumber still comes in standard inch widths and depths (e.g., "2 by 4's"), although the finished, cured lumber will not actually have the indicated dimensions. Lengths are commonly 8 and 16 feet. Building codes are established at the local level and the U.S. has extensive building standards that are based on English units. Because of Canada's proximity to the U.S., issues of common units still arise. (Even in other otherwise metricated countries, units customary for that country often continue to be used; for example, traditional construction in Japan still uses Japanese units predating metrication.)

[edit] Education

Most students are taught the metric system in elementary school. Instruction primarily centers on the concepts of powers of 10, the associated prefixes, and the conversion from one prefix form to another. Units of length, volume, and mass are also typically introduced through comparison with ordinary objects. The lack of popular metric usage, however, provides little reinforcement. As a result, while students might understand some of the concepts underlying the metric system, they do not necessarily have an intuitive sense of what the units mean. Furthermore, the fundamental concept that all metric units are derived from a few base units is rarely taught outside of physics and some chemistry classes. Within higher education, the metric system is standard for classes in the sciences (see below).

[edit] Electricity and energy

There are no customary U.S. units for electric current, potential difference, charge, etc., since these concepts were developed well after the international adoption of metric in science. The metric ones (ampere, volt, coulomb, etc.) have always been used. Energy is often measured in watt-hours or BTUs rather than the SI joule. The rated power of engines, electric motors, and power plant steam turbines is frequently quoted in horsepower.

Heating, cooling, and combustion power are often measured in BTUs per hour. Fuel prices are mostly given in customary units, e.g., dollars per gallon, per barrel, per thousand cubic feet, per long ton, etc. The SI term hertz has completely replaced the older term cycles per second as a unit of frequency.

[edit] Financial services

The United States was one of the first nations to introduce decimalized currency. However, until 2001, U.S. stocks were traded in fractions based on the old Spanish pieces of eight. Some commodity market prices are quoted in customary units (e.g., barrels of oil, troy ounces of gold, 40,000 lbs of frozen pork bellies, etc.). The federal government reports international production figures in metric units, for instance, wheat in metric tons, but in bushels for domestic production figures.

[edit] Firearms

The U.S. continues to use fractions of an inch for caliber on many civilian and law enforcement firearms.[2] Except for the 9mm, most widely recognizable calibres are in inches, such as the .45, .357 or .22.

[edit] Manufacturing

Globalization of manufacturing has led to wide adoption of metric standards, although this is not yet universal. After a confusing period where automobiles were assembled with both customary and metric fasteners in each vehicle, cars are now universally built with metric parts. Automobile engines, formerly having been named after their displacement in cubic inches (e.g. the 426 Hemi), are currently named after their rounded measurement in liters (e.g. the 6.1 L Hemi). Engine displacements are occasionally given both in cubic inches and cubic centimetres by American automakers. For example, the specifications for the Dodge SRT-8 6.1 L Hemi state the displacement as 370 cubic inches (6,059 cc)[10]. This type of specification listing tends to be used only when catering to certain demographics (such as muscle car enthusiasts), however, and is not common.

The electronics and computer industries largely converted to metric standards as new technologies were introduced toward the end of the 20th century. Thus 5-1/4 inch floppy disks were truly in 5-1/4 inch-wide packages. They were replaced by "3-1/2 inch" disks that were actually 90 mm wide. CD/DVD disks are 120 mm in diameter, but their size is rarely mentioned.

[edit] Military

The U.S. military uses metric measurements extensively to ensure interoperability with allied forces, particularly NATO STANAGs, "standardization agreements". Ground forces measure distances in "klicks," slang for kilometers. Most military firearms are measured in metric units, beginning with the M-14 which was introduced in 1957,[3] though a few legacy exceptions exist, e.g. .50-caliber guns. Heavy weapon caliber is measured in milimeters. Military vehicles are generally built to metric standards. An exception is the U.S. Navy whose guns are measured in inches and whose undersea fleet measures distances in terms of "kiloyards," depth as "feet", and velocity, in some cases, as "feet per second." The Navy and Air Force continue to measure distance in nautical miles and speed in knots, however, these units are now accepted for use with SI. [11]

[edit] Illegal drugs and controlled substances

Illegal drugs and controlled substances are often measured in metric quantities[12]. The federal law prohibiting them defines the penalties in metric masses.[13]

[edit] Science and medicine

In science, metric usage is essentially universal, consistent with worldwide usage, although additional specialized units are often utilized for specific purposes in various disciplines (such as the light-year in astronomy). Medicine is generally metric, but where interaction with patients is required, usage is often mixed. Doctors often measure a patient's weight in pounds to compute a dosage of medicine administered in grams or milliliters. Even in many cases for which metric units are otherwise used, U.S. practice often varies from the rest of the world. For example, U.S. diabetes patients measure their blood sugar levels in milligrams per deciliter, whereas most other countries use millimoles per liter.

In hospital settings, patient data is typically recorded using metric quantities, but all interaction with patients is done with reference to customary units (i.e., patient weights might be recorded in kilograms but discussed with patients in pounds).

Usage among veterinarians varies, but due to the heavy emphasis on public interaction, animal weights (e.g., for cats or dogs) are nearly always recorded and reported in pounds and ounces.

[edit] Sports

Americans are frequently exposed to metric units through coverage of international sporting events, particularly the Olympic Games. Races in the U.S. are run in metric distances (e.g., the 100 meter sprint and 5 km ("5K") races). Measured distances as used in events such as shot put, high jump, and discus throw are, however, often in feet and inches, except at the international level. Even most casual runners prefer to think of a "10K" race as a "6.2 mile" race. The field and court sizes for most popular team sports (even soccer) were originally set in English units. Some sporting equipment, such as skis and poles, is sold in metric units. Bicycles, especially at the high end, are increasingly being sold and sized in metric (for example, a frame described as "21 inch" size in the past is now often labeled as a "53 cm" frame instead).

[edit] Transportation

Highway speed limits are posted in miles per hour and distances are largely announced in miles, yards, or feet, although a few dual mile/km signs can be found, mostly left over from demonstration projects that are no longer supported. [14] One exception is Interstate 19 in Arizona, due to its direct link to Mexico, which is almost completely signed in metric, except for speed limit signs. Signage on this road is, however, being converted back to traditional units as they are replaced. Another exception is the turnpike section of Delaware Highway 1, which uses a kilometer-based system, in anticipation of the mid-1990s conversion in the U.S. to the metric system (which did not happen). Distances were originally signed in kilometers, but have since been replaced with standard milemarkers. The exit numbers have remained metric.

Since 2000, the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices has been published in both metric and American Customary Units. Metric signs, including speed signs in kilometers per hour, are now displayed in the manual even though they are not normally used on the roads and there is no definite plan to go metric yet. For visual distinction, regulatory and advisory metric speed signs have black circles around the numbers followed by "km/h" and other regulatory metric signs have yellow plates reading "METRIC" in black on top of the main signs. The UK Metric Association considers this part of the metrication ahead of the United Kingdom where metric road signs are usually illegal. [4]

Due to their proximity to Canada, the states of New Hampshire and Maine include distances in both miles and kilometers on many highway signs, although some older signs still have miles only. However, exits in Maine are numbered according to the number of miles from the southern or western terminus of the route. At least one route (US 31) in Alabama has both mileposts and kilometer-posts.

Gasoline and diesel fuel are both sold by the US gallon, and fuel economy is rated in miles per gallon. However, some border town neighboring Canada display the equivalent cost in Canadian dollars per liter due to the high rate of Canadian customers crossing the border specifically to purchase gasoline at a lower tax rate.[citation needed] Domestic airline flights are assigned altitudes in feet and measure speed in knots. Nautical charts show depth in fathoms and use the nautical mile for distance (one minute of arc at the radius of the earth at sea level is one nautical mile). Railroads use the standard gauge of 4 feet 8-1/2 inches, as does most of Europe (where it is expressed instead as 1435 mm). US Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 101, which governs vehicle controls and displays, permit speedometers to display miles per hour, kilometers per hour, or both. Odometers are permitted to record miles or kilometers, but must be clearly labelled as to which unit they record. In practice, virtually all US-market vehicles have mile odometers and dual labeled speedometers with mile-per-hour as the primary calibration. Some vehicles with electronic speed and distance readouts can be switched between US and Metric units.

[edit] Hybrid Units

Some measurements are done in units derived from both customary and metric units. For example:

  • Power per unit length from a nuclear reactor fuel rod: kilowatts per foot
  • Heat rate from a power plant: BTUs per hour per kilowatt
  • Distance to target for a U.S. submarine: kiloyards.
  • Federal automobile exhaust emission standards: grams per mile

Any measurement that combines customary units with electrical units is necessarily hybrid, since there are no traditional electrical units. An example can be found in Table 8, chapter 9 of the National Electrical Code Handbook (8th ed.) where resistance of conductors per unit length is given in ohms per thousand feet.

[edit] Popular culture

[edit] The Simpsons

  • In A Star is Burns Grampa Simpson angrily denounces Marge Simpson's plan to switch to the metric system, yelling "The metric system is the tool of the devil! My car gets forty rods to the hogshead, and that's the way I likes it!" (That translates into 432 (beer) or 504 (wine) gallons per mile, or about 1.2 liters per meter.)
  • In another, entitled Homer the Great, Homer joins a secret society called the Stonecutters. The members sing a drinking song, proudly boasting: "Who controls the British Crown? Who keeps the metric system down? We do! We do!"
  • In the episode Homer and Apu Homer shows he understands the metric system better than the customary one. After he announces his plans to go to India, Lisa informs him it is "over 10,000 miles away". He responds appearing to understand her. She then states that that is "over 16,000 kilometers" to which he replies "D'oh".
  • In another episode, Judge Constance Harm orders Bart to remain at least 200 feet away from Lisa as part of a restraining order. Judge Harm then says it is 61 meters, prompting French, German, and Swiss spectators to be shocked.
  • In the episode They Saved Lisa's Brain, Lisa joins Mensa, which, as a "council of learned citizens", takes over rule in Springfield after the mayor skips town. The Council proceeds to reform daily life in Springfield, to include timetables for trains. In the words of Principal Skinner, "Not only are the trains running on time, they are running on metric time. Remember this time people, 80 past 2 on April 47th, it's the dawn of an enlightened Springfield." The date is certainly non-existent in the metric system. The time given, while possible decimal time is also likely incorrect as it would be approximately 06:00.
  • In the episode The Seven-Beer Snitch, it is revealed that Springfield was the first city in America to abandon the metric system.
  • In the episode Bart's Friend Falls in Love, actor Troy McClure introduces himself on the Sex-Education video Fuzzy Bunny's Guide To You-Know-What with "Hello, I'm actor Troy McClure. You kids might remember me from such educational films as Lead Paint, Delicious But Deadly and Here Comes the Metric System!"
  • In The Regina Monologues, Homer vows that if "English God" helps him escape the Tower of London, he will "endorse the metric system with every cubic millilitre of blood in my... oh, I can't do it! It's so STUPID!" The expression "cubic millilitre", it must be noted, is incorrect.

[edit] Star Trek

[edit] Futurama

  • Futurama is a satirical cartoon set in the future. As in the original Star Trek, both metric and standard units appear.
  • In the episode The Series Has Landed, a lunar farmer informs Fry, the main character, of the temperature drop during a lunar night:
Farmer: "Drops down to minus 173."
Fry: "Fahrenheit or celsius?"
Farmer: "First one, then the other."

[edit] Saturday Night Live

  • The Decabet, a new "metric alphabet", is introduced by a U.S. government official (played by Dan Aykroyd). Instead of 26 letters, the Decabet has only ten, thus saving confusion. In the Decabet, the first four letters, A, B, C, and D remain the same. The letters E and F are combined into one character, Г. For example, the word "eagle" would be spelled "ГaglГ" and would be pronounced, "Ee-fag-lef." The letters G, H, and I would become one letter, "GHI" and the letters L, M, N, and O would become "LMNO", pronounced "Elemenoh", as in, "Please lmnopen the door." Lastly, the so-called "junk letters" (P throught Z) would be combined into a single letter, so an ordinary "stop" sign would look like an incomprehensible mess of letters all squashed together. For example, the word 'alphabet' would be spelled A-LMNO-PQRSTUVWXYZ-GHI-A-B-EF-PQRSTUVWXYZ, proceeding with a comic explanation of how the Decabet will affect spelling and pronunciation.

[edit] Knight Rider

  • The Knight Industry 2000 (KITT) displays the speed in digital miles per hour (MPH). Certain Knight Rider Season 1 episodes have KITT speaking physical quantity in metric, but later episodes usually use the American Customary Units. In Region 1 Knight Rider DVDs, the English subtitles display the original units unconverted, but the French subtitles (unavailable in Seasons 3 and 4 DVDs) always display metric including values converted from the American Customary Units.

[edit] References

  1. ^ Standard for Use of the International System of Units (SI) (IEEE/ASTM SI 10-1997) (1997). New York and West Conshohochen, PA: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers and American Society for Testing and Materials. p. 11
  2. ^ Nazarian's Gun Recognition Guide. Viewed September 22, 2006 at [1]
  3. ^ Nazarian's Gun Recognition Guide. Viewed September 22, 2006 at [2]
  4. ^ UK Metric Association: Fiction: The USA has not gone metric; Fact: It's going metric

[edit] See also

[edit] External links


Metrication by country
Australia | Canada | India | Ireland | Jamaica | New Zealand | Singapore | South Africa | United Kingdom | United States | Zambia