Talk:Marquis Testaferrata-Olivier
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article was nominated for deletion on 20/7/2006. The result of the discussion was no consensus. |
[edit] Original Research
"
- 1) Said Vassallo, C.M., Unpublished research papers.
- 2) Said Vassallo, C.M.,Charles Said-Vassallo's Research site and Maltese Nobility web site.
This Research was researched by Charles Said-Vassallo
(Text originally based on that of a website by Charles Said Vassallo, by permission.)"
This I'm afraid appears to violate Wikipedia:No_original_research. It may well be that all that is said here is correct but atm it's doesn't meet Wikipedia:Verifiability. It all may be worthy of inclusion but unless some of the key points can be backed up with links to Wikipedia:Reliable_sources then I think this may qualify as Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion
Alci12 15:14, 9 June 2006 (UTC)
Lt Col Charles Barnard Bonham appears in publicly available genealogical records as "Bonham", that is, Barnard is a given name. The author offers no evidence that he is related to the Barnard family.
--193.201.196.10 13:31, 14 November 2006 (UTC)
[edit] "Apocryphal at best"
It appears that this article was recently cited by a defendant acting pro se in a lawsuit involving an unpaid credit-card debt. Apparently, the defendant was trying to prove that a debt-collection attorney who had been pursuing him had retired, although it's not clear why this was important to his defense. Anyway, in Great Seneca Financial Corp. v. Lifeng Lee Hsu, an opinion issued by the Court of Common Pleas for New Castle County, Delaware, the Court noted, among other things, that this article was "apocryphal at best".
At least, I assume the defendant cited to this article, because Googling the phrase "Marquis Testaferrata-Oliver" leads only to this article and the court opinion in question.
Weird.
- Sensor 03:16, 18 July 2006 (UTC)
