Talk:Killology

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I'm a former Army Ranger and have been in combat in Panama (Op Just Cause), Somalia and in Afghanistan. I'm only about 60 pages into "On Combat", but it's pretty much right on with my experiences. It's also helped me to understand some of my perceptions during firefights, and before and after them. This book probably wouldn't have any meaning for me if I did not have and understand the "Warrior Mindset", but I do, and it has helped me better than any DoD counselor so far. Guess I'll post a more comprehensive review when I've finished the book.

[edit] Pushing the POV line

Giving this article a look, I'm concerned that it might not be completely NPOV, on both sides of the issue. I think it could do with a balanced look at some of the controversies around these theories, rather than a link to an external site in which a guy tries to debunk Grossman in what I consider to be a very unprofessional-looking manner. What are the issues and what are the responses on both sides? 23skidoo 21:23, 12 June 2006 (UTC)