Talk:Judicial system of Iran

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

There is no mention of basic aspects of the Iranian judicial process, such as the four types of courts, or many interlaying assemblies that aim to ensure checks and balances. Basic information can be incorporated from Iran but a general expansion is needed. freestylefrappe 02:58, July 23, 2005 (UTC)

Apparently an anonymous contributor doesn't like the following accurate, referenced information and keeps deleting it. I am therefore labeling the article as non-eutral until this is resolved on this talk page. --> [Iran] is one of only six nations that executes children for crimes committed when they were under eighteen years old. (As a State party to the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), Iran has undertaken not to execute anyone for an offence committed when they were under the age of 18, but continues to carry such executions out. [1].)<-- - Outerlimits 06:33, 23 July 2005 (UTC)

Your history in this article speaks for itself. You are here to bash Iran not contribute to Wikipedia. I also suspect that you are a homo who views this execution as an attack on homos. Unlike your CLEAR LIE, Iran dit not say FOR THE FIRST TIME AFTER THE EXECUTION that they had raped a 13-year-old. This was already a published case in Iran and I had personally followed up on it. You on the other hand, are simply picking up anti-Iranian propaganda in the Western media, and are adding a bit of your own to it, participating in the avalanche build-up. Fact is, the vast majority of Iranians approve of such punishements any time, regardless of their ideological viewpoints, hands down.

And how, exactly, does that impact on whether Iran has carried out its committment not to execute people for crimes committed when they were less than 18 years old? P.S. Flame down on the name calling, please. - Outerlimits 06:46, 23 July 2005 (UTC)

Iran has not, and cannot, possibly commit to such an agreement. If Iran had agreed to such an International "agreement" you had better believe it would have been the hottest national topic for the longest time. Iran has no problem executing an 18-year-old who has commited a crime that by Iranian law should get execution as punishment, regardless of whether in some (as you called it) "civilized nations" 18 is by definition a "child". And as an Iranian, I thank God for that. Also, to talk about "teenagers" in terms of Iran, is just laughable beyond belief. Did it not even occur to you that the word "teenager" has to do with the fact that the numbers thirteen through nineteen in THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE end with "teen"?! I can't think of a more stupid way to group human beings together, let alone exporting that concept to other nations whose language is not even English. So if a 19-year-old kills a human being he should get away with it because the word for his age in English ends with "teen" but a 20-year-old should pay for it dearly?! My god, you people are comedians.

Follow the link. Iran has indeed made such a committment, though it has not honoured it. And no, one doesn't "get away" with murder if a punishment less than death is exacted for it. That's a false dichotomy. - Outerlimits 07:00, 23 July 2005 (UTC)

USA also has Capital Punishment, and if I am not mistaken, even in USA a teenager can be executed. But whether USA executes teenagers or not is irrelevant, because it is utterly stupid to categorize human beings on the basis of the ending suffix of their age in the English language!! By the way, did you contribute to any article about what USA does to its "muslim terrorist" captives, including "teenagers" in Guantanamo Bay?

Surely no USA injustice, real or imagined, has any bearing on how Iran's actions are to be judged? Don't be so Americocentric. Iran is a signatory to a United Nations document in which it makes a committment not to execute people for crimes committed while they were under age 18. That has nothing to do with word endings in English. - Outerlimits 07:42, 23 July 2005 (UTC)