Talk:Hanukkah bush
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This is an interesting subject, but I think it would serve better if condensed slighly and merged with Christmas tree.
Peter Isotalo 16:36, 5 September 2005 (UTC)
Contents |
[edit] Moving tangential stuff here for the moment
I guess I've changed my mind... so I'm moving this material here for the moment because I think it's good stuff that belongs somewhere, but it's a little tangential to Hanukkah bushes, and the phenomenon of "mutual goodwill between Jews and Christians during the holiday season" is not really the same thing as "Hanukkah becoming more and more like Christmas."
In the U.S., in the twentieth century, Hanukkah began to be perceived as having similarities to Christmas. A 1926 reference quotes a speaker at a New York temple, speaking on "Hanukkah and Christmas," as saying that "whenever there is the human demonstration of kindliness, freedom, and good cheer" Jews should "participate, but that all theological interpretations should be ignored." In 1940, Christmas fell on the first day of Hanukkah; in 1946, it fell within the eight-day Hanukkah celebration. Both occasions were marked by expressions of Jewish-Christian unity. A 1946 news item mentions a "joint Christmas-Hanukkah program" at a Minneapolis school and quotes the organizer as saying "now these are widespread throughout the country." Increasingly, Hanukkah began to syncretize the less obviously religious elements of Christmas.
- ↑ "Finds Jewish Feast Like Christmas." The New York Times, December 6, 1926, p. 26, reporting a talk by Dr. Nathan Kraus at Temple Emanu-El
- ↑ "Toys to Fit the Child," The New York Times, December 15, 1946, p. SM22, item at end of an article about toy selection
[edit] Article title
This article was recently moved by User:Jordain to Jewish Christmas Tree with the edit comment "Hanukkah bush moved to Jewish Christmas Tree: Name is insufficient, anti-Christian."
The Wikipedia:Naming convention is to "give priority to what the majority of English speakers would most easily recognize."
"Hanukkah bush" gets 1030 Google hits and is a real phrase that is widely used.
"Jewish Christmas tree" gets only 90 Google hits and from context it is clear that this is not a customary way of referring to it.
I do not see what is either "insufficient" or "anti-Christian" about the name "Hanukkah bush," but in any case that is the real name. "Jewish Christmas tree" is a description.
Discuss here and don't move the article, certainly not until it is off AfD, but also not before there is consensus on what the name of the article should be. Dpbsmith (talk) 22:47, 5 September 2005 (UTC)
- Not keeping the article at Hanukkah bush could be seen as anti-Jewish. It's the most widely used phrase. We don't need to try and be religiously "correct" about it. Anti-Christian is not a good reason to move an article on a Jewish subject. - Mgm|(talk) 07:24, September 6, 2005 (UTC)
- Hanukkah bush is the name that should be used. This has nothing to do with "anti=Christian". --ZappaZ 17:43, 8 September 2005 (UTC)
- Yeah, and it's not a Jewish Christmas tree, it's a Hannukah bush! :) jengod 18:23, September 8, 2005 (UTC)
- As a Christian, I don't know what is supposed to be "anti-Christian" about the current name, which doesn't appear to reflect on Jesus or Christianity one way or another. If I had to start at the beginning, I'd call it a "Shrubbery sacrifice for Hanukkah", but sometimes life gets ahead of art. Smerdis of Tlön 18:35, 8 September 2005 (UTC)
I don't have much first-hand experience with the subject of this article, but it does seem that it describes a phenomenon that is distinct enough (though related) to Christmas trees to warrant a distinct article. Also, though I was raised in a Christian family, one of the earliest memories I have from our Christmas tree was a bagel ornament similar to that described as having been at Saks Fifth Avenue. That detail of the article was particularly interesting to me. — ArkansasTraveler 22:37, 29 November 2005 (UTC)
[edit] Offensive to Christians?
Please don't insert material suggesting that the practice is offensive to Christians unless you can supply a verifiable source citation to back this up, such as a quotation from a prominent clergyman. Note that Hanukkah bushes are not public displays. Dpbsmith (talk) 11:03, 16 December 2005 (UTC)
[edit] Bad Page
I find this page insulting. It is not a common practice for Jews to have a Christmas Tree in their homes, and in this page there are no quoted sources to say anything to the contrary to grain of this article.
- I count six or seven sources... e.g. Rabbi Ron Isaacs, "There are certainly Jewish families that feel that they can have a tree in the house without subscribing to the Christian element of the holiday," Peter W. Williams, "Some Jews eager to approximate Gentile customs... and with tongue firmly in cheek—add a 'Hanukkah bush,' or Christmas-tree substitute, and even have visits from "Uncle Max, the Hanukkah man," a clear counterpart to a well-known Christmas figure." And I don't think Saks Fifth Avenue would have advertised decorations for a "Chanukah bush" if it were a rare or obscure practice. Dpbsmith (talk) 20:37, 21 December 2005 (UTC)
-
- I think the anon has a point. There are no real sources given on the prevalence of the practice; some rabbi making an anecdotal remark has no particular authority on this. And very many references to "Hannukah bushes" in popular culture are just more or less jokes, including the 1974 Saks ad (if there was a major market, one would think this would be targeted just a little more regularly). I am seriously skeptical that this article may be implicity exxagerating the prevalence of Hanukkah bushes in the U.S. What we desperately need a real source, like a relevant poll or sociological study of Americans Jews.--Pharos 22:31, 24 December 2005 (UTC)
[edit] Euphemism?
One definition of euphemism is:
- The act or an example of substituting a mild, indirect, or vague term for one considered harsh, blunt, or offensive. "“Euphemisms such as ‘slumber room’ . . . abound in the funeral business” (Jessica Mitford).
Another is:
- the substitution of an agreeable or inoffensive expression for one that may offend or suggest something unpleasant; also : the expression so substituted
Euphemisms usually refer to taboo things like religion, excretion, and sex.
I find it hard to view "hanukkah bush" as a "euphemism," because I think few Jews see anything harsh, blunt, offensive, unpleasant, or taboo. Dpbsmith (talk) 23:43, 30 December 2005 (UTC)