Talk:Groups claiming an affiliation with the ancient Israelites

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] POV check

The Template:POV check has been placed on this page because it appears that the entire purpose behind the creation of this thinly-veiled article is only to validate the unproven claims of certain users with a Mormon POV who are obsessed with validating their own beliefs and views by "adopting" topics (actually entire existing Wikipedia articles) relating to Judaism and the Jewish people. Pathetic! That is why a Template:verify was inserted in the Mormon sub-section of this article. The attempt to somehow equate Mormonism with (elements) of Judaism is further shown in the new template Template:Mormon jew which was manufactured by plagiarising the original Template:Jew. Again, pathetic! Why is this article needed? It merely restates (basically verbatim) all the points that are to be found in all these individual articles, and there already exists a comperehensive Mormonism and Judaism article, so why create this one as well, unless you are grabbing at straws? IZAK 17:15, 1 November 2005 (UTC)

[edit] What is the point of this article?

This appears to be an article listing a bunch of unusual groups which either claim to be or are Jewish, with one other completely unrelated group (Mormons) mixed in. The text itself is mostly copy-pasted from the articles on those groups itself. Is there any point to this article? Jayjg ^(talk) 18:45, 2 November 2005 (UTC)