Talk:Gift of Men

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

	This article is within the scope of WikiProject Middle-earth, which aims to build an encyclopedic guide to J. R. R. Tolkien and his legendarium. Please visit the project page for suggestions and ideas on how you can improve this and other articles.
Assessment ??? This article has not yet received a rating on the quality scale. ??? This article has not yet received a rating on the importance scale. Article Grading: The article has not been rated for quality and/or importance yet. Please rate the article and then leave comments here to explain the ratings and/or to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article.

[edit] Rowe's edits of the Gift_of_Men Tolkien page

(wikification; headers should be lowercase, per WP:MOS; removed POV statements (article shouldn't express a point of view ("this author")); formatting footnote)

Just so you know, I am the original author of the "spiritual view..." section of this page, and the first paragraph of the next section. I hope you have some appreciation for the quality of the writing.

I don't mind refinements to the work, by fellow Tolkien enthusiasts, but I dislike arbitrary edits by anyone who appears to be a "tourist". Your edits REMOVED a key insight about the nature of how evil entered the Tolkien world through weaving of incompatible themes in the original myth of the world being created through themes of the great music.

Are these comments REALLY that bad? ...

(It is the interpretation of this author that there can be no damaging of the themes as happened in the first Great Music, when competing wills created the first marring of Arda, and sowed the seeds of evil.)

(*) Stories abound in "The Silmarillion" of the stark choices that some have had to make when their intrinsic nature as a member of a particular race came into conflict with the finality of the Gift. See the stories of Beren and Luthien, Elrond and Elros, and Earendil. Also see the story of Aragorn and Arwen in the Lord of the Rings. These stories might confer additional insights for the interested reader.

After all, the whole idea of discussing Tolkien's "Gift of Men" (ie. WHY was the race of men 'doomed to die') is itself an act of interpretation, ie. a Point of View.

If you must edit, do NOT remove information for dogmatic reasons; remove information only if its incorrect or does not add anything to the article. Remove only as a last resort!

To satisfy your peeve about POV, I will re-add this information in a more 3rd person way, when I have time.

--SanjaySingh 20:04, 5 April 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Was Smeagol a hobbit?

Just wonder where the information that Smeagol is a hobbit comes from. I have always read that Smeagol and his people could be related to hobbits, but I do not remember and exact statement that they are hobbits. ColinMarble 05:41, 23 August 2006 (UTC)

Smeagol was a hobbit... as Tolkien clearly states in Letter #214 and other places. --CBD 23:51, 30 August 2006 (UTC)