Wikipedia:Featured list candidates/Liverpool F.C. seasons
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Liverpool F.C. seasons
Another self-nom, but this is a comprehensive, accurate and clear list with references, notes and very few redlinks. ArtVandelay13 13:12, 18 October 2006 (UTC)
- Comments - I am not going to really support or object at this stage, but I will offer some suggestions that I think would help improve it.
- The use of "n/a"s and "DNQ"s clutters the table without adding any information - maybe just leave them blank?
- Maybe separate out the goalscorers and the numbers of goals they scored
- There was an FA Cup (but no League) in 1945-46 - this should be included.
- Inter-Cities Fairs Cup should really be abbreviated ICFC
- Use ordinal numbers for positions, perhaps?
- Lancashire Cup in 1892-93 should really not be in the League Cup column; keep the footnote but attach it to the season instead?
- Ditto for the 1986-87 Super Cup.
- In Arsenal F.C. seasons, I abbreviated the entries in the "Division" column to "Div 1", "Prem" etc. to save space and make it look less repetitive; I think the same here would work. Qwghlm 23:02, 18 October 2006 (UTC)
- In reply:
- I think I'd prefer to keep these - without them the table looks a little empty.
- I think separating the goal tallies may put them out of context, even if they are next to the scorer.
- Added
- Changed
- Changed
- Changed
- Changed
- I'm not sure about this - the top entry is "Lancashire League", and I don't think this should be abbreviated (as it's not obvious to everyone like the other divisions are), and as it's longer than all the other league names, the benefits of abbreviating them would be lost. ArtVandelay13 14:19, 19 October 2006 (UTC)
