Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/Technology in the Stargate universe

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Technology in the Stargate universe

This article is pretty much complete. It lists practicaly every technology worth mentioning in Stargate. It is completely accurate. (I verified it) I just think this would make a good featured article, or perhaps even an article of the day. Tobyk777 06:51, 26 November 2005 (UTC)

Comment. As-is, this article would be a much better candidate for Wikipedia:Featured list than Featured Article. -Silence 07:21, 26 November 2005 (UTC)

• Object. As per Silence, this nomination might be better served on WP:FLC. Issues with it becoming a FA include: 1) The article has no references. 2) It is organized as a long list with most entries containing only a one sentence description. The article needs to be converted into a more flowing text to be a realistic FA candidate. 3) Image:Zeropointmodule.jpg and Image:SGBC303ship.jpg both claim to be fair use images but contain no justification for why they qualify for fair use. --Allen3 ^talk 11:49, 26 November 2005 (UTC)
  • We ask for references on WP:FLC too, you know, and the copyright issues are the same. This article has more text here than the usual list, but that would not be a problem on WP:FLC; however, it is not up to the standard I would expect of a featured article. -- ALoan (Talk) 21:54, 27 November 2005 (UTC)

• I agree. I recommended it to FLC not because I think it's quite good enough to be one yet, but because the people there will be much better than we are at offering the suggestions which this page will need in order to grow closer to becoming a Featured List. -Silence 21:59, 27 November 2005 (UTC)

• Object. As per everyone. Maybe an FLC, but this is NOT a FAC. (Hell, I created the Tech in Stargate TEMPLATE) Staxringold 00:24, 28 November 2005 (UTC)