User:Dsmdgold/Sandbox
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] WP:NOT gallery proposal analysis
- Current per 5:31 Fri 13 Jan 2006
[edit] Preliminary discussion on Proposal to modify WP:NOT an image gallery
- Dsmdgold (propose)(votes below)
- David Remahl (support)
- Carnildo (?)(votes below)
- SimonP (oppose)
- Pfctdayelise (?)
[edit] Proposal
[edit] Support
[edit] Charles Stewart's wording
- Charles Stewart
- Haukur Þorgeirsson
- Ancheta Wis
- DavidP
- Linas
- Grenavitar
- Astrokey44
- Denni
- CristianChirita
- Masssiveego
- ShaunMacPherson
- Fg2
- Dsmdgold
- Smerdis of Tlön
- Cyde Weys
- ugen64
- Jmabel
- Dschwen
- Fir0002
- MDD4696
- Sandpiper
- Tupsharru
[edit] DESiegel's wording
- DESiegel
- A Y Arktos
- Rune Welsh
[edit] Crypticfirefly's wording
- Crypticfirefly
- Cactus.man
[edit] Support with condition
- Jitse Niesen (wants a few sentences annotation / image)
- Srleffler (wants wording to be carefully chosen)
- Lar (agrees with Srleffler)
- Stifle (wants to address fair use)
[edit] Impractical support
- Carnildo (voted support but wants at least a paragraph annotation / image - effective oppose)
[edit] Oppose
- Zoe
- Calton
- Titoxd
- Splash
- Dalbury
- MisterHand
- BirgitteSB
- Aaron Brenneman
- cohesion (oposition based mainly on wording, word encyclopedic)
- Durova
[edit] Apparently opposed, no vote
- Cryptic
[edit] Vote deprecated
- <203.109.241.48> (support)
[edit] Comment
- Aaron Brenneman (reverted premature change to WP:NOT)(Voted above)
- Gurubrahma (generally negative)
- Oldak (concern over wording, "unencylopedic")
- ike9898 (concern over galleries of fair use images )
