| Year |
Goalkeeper |
Defenders |
Midfielders |
Forwards |
| 1985 |
Tim Borer, Old Dominion |
Paul Caligiuri, UCLA
Shaun Pendleton, Akron
Michael Reynolds, George Mason |
John Kerr Jr., Duke
Mark Mettrick, Hartwick
Bruce Murray, Clemson |
Michael Brady, American
Eric Eichmann, Clemson
Thomas Kain, Duke
Sam Sumo, George Mason |
| 1986 |
Jeffrey Duback, Yale |
Paul Caligiuri, UCLA
Benjamin Okaroh, Boston U.
Steve Trittschuh, SIU-Edwardsville |
Mark Francis, SMU
Gary Furlong, Maryland
John Harkes, Virginia |
John Catliff, Harvard
Guy Furfaro, Philadelphia
George Gelnovatch, Virginia
John Kerr Jr., Duke |
| 1987 |
Robert Willen, Virginia |
Seamus Purcell, Providence
Paul Rutenis, Clemson
David Smyth, UNC |
John Harkes, Virginia
Mark Mettrick, Hartwick
Tab Ramos, NC State |
Doug Allison, South Carolina
Bruce Murray, Clemson
Ken Snow, Indiana
Peter Vermes, Rutgers |
| 1988 |
Tony Meola, Virginia |
Jeff Agoos, Virginia
Marcelo Balboa, San Diego State
Kevin Grimes, SMU |
Henry Gutierrez, NC State
Pat O'Kelly, Seton Hall
Mark Santel, Saint Louis |
Scott Benedetti, Portland
Brian Benedict, Duke
Ken Snow, Indiana
Joey Valenti, Duke |
| 1989 |
Tony Meola, Virginia |
Kevin Grimes, SMU
Cameron Rast, Santa Clara
Kevin Wylie, Vermont |
David Banks, Philadelphia
Tim Martin, Fresno State
Pat O'Kelly, Seton Hall |
Clark Brisson, South Carolina
Peter Isaacs, Harvard
Robert Paterson, Evansville
Ken Snow, Indiana |
| 1990 |
Kasey Keller, Portland |
Jeff Agoos, Virginia
Scott Cannon, Evansville
Tom Loeber, South Carolina |
Dario Brose, NC State
Chad Deering, Indiana
Mark Santel, Saint Louis |
Steve Rammel, Rutgers
Ken Snow, Indiana
Billy Thompson, UCLA
David Weir, Evansville |
| 1991 |
Brad Friedel, UCLA |
Alexi Lalas, Rutgers
Mike Lappas, UCLA
Cameron Rast, Santa Clara |
Peter DiMaggio, Columbia
Graham Merryweather, Evansville
Claudio Reyna, Virginia |
Gerell Elliott, Fresno State
Henry Gutierrez, NC State
Manny Lagos, Milwaukee
Dante Washington, Radford |
| 1992 |
Brad Friedel, UCLA |
Joe Addo, George Mason
Scott Schweitzer, NC State
Hector Zamora, Seton Hall |
Joe-Max Moore, UCLA
Claudio Reyna, Virginia
Joseph Thieman, Princeton |
Ben Crawley, Virginia
Robert Martella, Bowling Green
Alan Prampin, SMU
Robert Ukrop, Davidson |
| 1993 |
Tim Deck, Wisconsin |
Shane Batelle, Saint Louis
Pedro Lopes, Rutgers
Jorge Salcedo, UCLA |
Brian Kamler, Creighton
Jason Kreis, Duke
Claudio Reyna, Virginia |
Keith Defini, Creighton
Jimmy Glenn, Clemson
Brian McBride, Saint Louis
Staale Soebye, San Francisco |
| 1994 |
David Kramer, Fresno State |
Brandon Pollard, Virginia
Eddie Pope, UNC |
Jason Kreis, Duke
Brian Maisonneuve, Indiana
Matt McKeon, Saint Louis
Todd Yeagley, Indiana |
Brent Bennett, James Madison
Mac Cozier, Charlotte
Darren Eales, Brown
Staale Soebye, San Francisco |
| 1995 |
Chris Snitko, UCLA |
Scott Lamphear, Wisconsin
Ian McIntyre, Hartwick
Brandon Pollard, Virginia |
Ben Hickey, St. John's
Jesse Marsch, Princeton
Clint Mathis, South Carolina |
Mike Fisher, Virginia
Matt McKeon, Saint Louis
Toni Siikala, Campbell
Andy Williams, Rhode Island |
| 1996 |
Jon Busch, Charlotte |
Tahj Jakins, UCLA
Pete Santora, Furman
John Stratton, Air Force |
Mike Fisher, Virginia
Steve Klein, Bowling Green
Mike Mekelburg, USF |
Tony Kuhn, Vanderbilt
Ignace Moleka, FIU
Johnny Torres, Creighton
Andy Williams, Rhode Island |
| 1997 |
Matt Jordan, Clemson |
Leo Cullen, Maryland
Kevin Daly, St. John's
Pete Santora, Furman |
Daniel Hernandez, SMU
Alen Kozic, FIU
Ben Olsen, Virginia |
Wade Barrett, William & Mary
Sigurdur Eyjolfsson, UNC-G'boro
Dema Kovalenko, Indiana
Johnny Torres, Creighton |
| 1998 |
Adin Brown, William & Mary |
Matt Chulis, Virginia
Jamie Clark, Stanford
Kevin Kalish, Saint Louis |
Lazo Alavanja, Indiana
Jay Heaps, Duke
Wojtek Krakowiak, Clemson
Maurizio Rocha, UConn |
Chris Albright, Virginia
Seth George, UCLA
Dema Kovalenko, Indiana
Richard Mulrooney, Creighton |
| 1999 |
Adin Brown, William & Mary |
Nick Garcia, Indiana
Eric Denton, Santa Clara
David Wright, Creighton |
Carl Bussey, SMU
Daniel Alvarez, Furman
Jeff DiMaria, Saint Louis
Sasha Victorine, UCLA |
John Barry Nusum, Furman
Mohammed Fahim, SMU
Ricardo Villar, Penn State
Aleksey Korol, Indiana |
| 2000 |
Chris Hamblin, Boston College |
Chris Gbandi, UConn
Cory Gibbs, Brown
Ryan Suarez, San Jose State |
Carl Bussey, SMU
Mark Lisi, Clemson
Jorge Martinez, San Jose State
Ryan Nelsen, Stanford |
Chris Carrieri, UNC
Ali Curtis, Duke
John Barry Nusum, Furman |
| 2001 |
Byron Foss, SMU |
Chris Gbandi, UConn
Danny Jackson, UNC
Lee Morrison, Stanford |
Luchi Gonzalez, SMU
Kyle Martino, Virginia
Diego Walsh, SMU |
Nicholas McCreath, Rhode Island
Pat Noonan, Indiana
John Barry Nusum, Furman
Dipsy Selolwane, Saint Louis |
| 2002 |
Doug Warren, Clemson |
Todd Dunivant, Stanford
John Swann, Indiana
Chris Wingert, St. John's |
Ricardo Clark, Furman
Sumed Ibrahim, Maryland
Andres Murriagui, Loyola Marymount
Diego Walsh, SMU |
Alecko Eskandarian, Virginia
Pat Noonan, Indiana
Tim Pierce, UCLA
Mike Tranchilla, Creighton |
| 2003 |
Will Hesmer, Wake Forest |
Leonard Griffin, UCLA
Trevor McEachron, Old Dominion
Chris Wingert, St. John's |
Scott Buete, Maryland
Sumed Ibrahim, Maryland
C.J. Klaas, Washington |
Adom Crew, Brown
Ned Grabavoy, Indiana
Vedad Ibisevic, Saint Louis
Joseph Ngwenya, Coastal Carolina |
| 2004 |
Christopher Sawyer, Notre Dame |
Ugo Ihemelu, SMU
Drew Moor, Indiana
Gonzalo Segares, VCU |
Mike Enfield, UCLA
C.J. Klaas, Washington
Sacha Kljestan, Seton Hall
Danny O'Rourke, Indiana |
Justin Moose, Wake Forest
Randi Patterson, UNC-G'boro
Ryan Pore, Tulsa
Jeff Rowland, New Mexico |
| 2005 |
Chris Dunsheath, Bradley |
Gregory Dalby, Notre Dame
Tyson Wahl, California
Marvell Wynne, UCLA |
Mehdi Ballouchy, Santa Clara
Scott Jones, UNC-G'boro
Yohann Mauger, Akron
Brian Plotkin, Indiana |
Jason Garey, Maryland
Ross McKenzie, Akron
Jeff Rowland, New Mexico
Willie Sims, Cal St-N'ridge |
