Talk:Chris Carter (producer/disc jockey)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

< Talk:Chris Carter (producer
You have new messages (last change).

[edit] Autobiography allegation

It appears that this article is an autobiography. It has one editor and reads like a press release.

Please discuss here any reasons why I might be incorrect. Otherwise, please see WP:AUTO.

Thanks, 68.183.117.74 08:44, 14 June 2006 (UTC)

[edit] This is NOT an autobiography

I am the initial editor, and I am NOT Chris Carter. I am a freelance music critic, and have written about the subject elsewhere. If you'd clicked on any of the links, you'd have discovered that I also wrote the Wikipedia entry on Dramarama, Chris's former band. I have also written reviews on the band's material (which would seem to comply with the "published elsewhere" requirement); these may be accessed by clicking the links provided in the Dramarama article. Also, anyone is welcome to chime in. What am I supposed to do...tell all my friends I wrote it and have them all stop by and make an edit or two in order to prove it's not an autobiography?

I am going to delete the Autobiography flag on the article's main page. Thank you.

Hi
The article is very well written. Unfortunately, it seems sort of PRish and autobiographical. That, combined with the fact that your previous edits are restricted to Chris Carter related articles led me to believe that this was indeed autobiography.
I certainly could be wrong, though.
I added the tag in order to attract the Wikipedia community here to discuss the possibilities. Please don't delete the tag again until some sort of final consensus or determination has been reached.
Thanks,
68.183.117.74 06:09, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
Scratch that. After reading those reviews, I can now see that this article is not autobiographical. Sorry for the inconvenience. I only hope that when I hit it big someone will spend weeks slaving away on an article for me.
With apologies, 68.183.117.74 09:18, 16 June 2006 (UTC)

[edit] No problem!

What can I say; I'm a fan. I highly recommend you check out Dramarama's music! - schneile, 16 June 2006

Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../c/h/r/Talk%7EChris_Carter_%28producer_disc_jockey%29_234e.html"