Wikipedia:Categories for deletion/Places
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
- Category:Places and various subcats were listed for deletion on March 20, 2005. Consensus was to Delete everything.
Assuming Category:Places by country and Category:Populated places are deleted, this overly general category should go as well. -- Rick Block 19:04, 20 Mar 2005 (UTC)
Summary after 2 weeks — no votes => move to unresolved
- Umm, since there were no objections, the nomination is carried but since there were dependencies, it would only move to unresolved if those dependencies were not deleted. RedWolf 07:40, Apr 3, 2005 (UTC)
Contents |
[edit] Category:Places by country (cat & subcats)
[edit] Category:Places in Belarus
[edit] Category:Places in Russia
[edit] Category:Places in Ukraine
Countries are places, so IMO these categories are redundant with the corresponding country categories. -- Rick Block 18:58, 20 Mar 2005 (UTC)
Summary after 2 weeks — 3:1 for Delete => move to section 5.2 below
- 3 Delete: Radiant; Kbdank71; Gene Nygaard
- 1 Keep: Wincoote
- Keep Countries are hardly the only type of place. The intention of these categories is perfectly clear to me. A number of common subcategories of national menus belong in them, but most do not. I designed more of the architecture of the category:United Kingdom menu than anyone else, and chose not to have a places category, putting the relevant categories in the main menu or one tier down instead, but I don't object to this form of category as an intermediate link if some people think it is useful. Wincoote 20:27, 20 Mar 2005 (UTC)
- I disagree, it's too broad a category, and it is a superfluous step between Category:Russia and Category:Cities in Russia. Delete. Radiant_* 08:46, Mar 21, 2005 (UTC)
- Delete. -Kbdank71 14:25, 21 Mar 2005 (UTC)
- Delete, even though the proposer's reasoning is wacky; it's an unhelpful intermediate step. Gene Nygaard 18:40, 26 Mar 2005 (UTC)
