Talk:Buy to let

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Thanks for beefing up my article guys.  :) - TomRobinson 09:56, 7 December 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Completed Merge

Completed merege of buy-to-let by copying page to section Experienced investors and amateurs.

As you can see the whole of the merged article was on this sub-topic and clearly the buy to let article is more comprehensive.

I chose the unhypenated title as I feel more people are likely to try to search this was. Also its probably the preferred way in the style guide?

I hope everyone approves. simonthebold 20:28, 14 December 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Amateur investor

I felt the section on amateur investors did not represent the reality of the UK sector. Also, the word amateur should not be used simply in the derisory. A great number of amateurs are very successful in the sector. Budup 11:21, 19 December 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Landlord Mortgages

After repeated spamming and removal of a link to the Landlord Mortgages website the perpetrator added this comment to their link and an entry to the standard anti-spam comment:

Landlord Mortgages - The organisation is much respected by the UK National press and comments regularly on Buy To Let. The company carries out regular statistical reports ie. rental trends. 11:17, 19 July 2006 86.131.94.97

Wikipedia is not a collection of external links, nor is it a place to advertise your business. "If this is correct then why have links in the first place. Are you saying you favour some links over others? Landlord Mortgages is very influential in the market place and has as much press coverage on the subject as ARLA or CML...carry out your own search. I have duly amended your article to reflect current trends, your information was incorrectly stated, as such we are influential and warrant a listing." 11:17, 19 July 2006 86.131.94.97

I have removed the link and comment; let me explain why. The link takes you to a commercial website for a mortgage broker who specialises in this market. The website offers no encyclopedic information, only an option to purchase an investment guide . The purpose of external links is to give access to further information and links to relevant independent organisations. The exception to this are large well-know commercial companies which have their own pages.

The comnment makes reference to my (your) article. The article is not owned by any one person but is a collective effort. Any worthwhile contributions are welcolmed. However you should realise any non-neutral point of view changes will be reversed by other editors.

Please try and join in with the spririt of the project instead of pursuing self-interest.simonthebold 15:29, 19 July 2006 (UTC)

Please sign your comments with four tildes (~).

Talk about spamming : simon you are a financial adviser with your own links on this page. If you set standards apply them yourself...jealousy gets you know where 06:58, 20 July 2006 81.153.74.6

So you say its better for someone when looking at mortgages relating to buy to let that they are linked through to ARLA who do not offer such mortgags. We are the most respected buy to let mortgage provider. If you are saying that our service does not add value to your readers then that contradicts UK National Press. If you are to set standards set them accross the whole site..ARLA is a commercial organistation. This page is incorrectly written but you obviously dont value my companies input. 09:32, 20 July 2006 86.131.94.97

Yes Lee, I am a financial adviser. There are no (note spelling) links to my business on my user-page. Anyone who is interested in BTL can type in a search in Google or a hundred other search engines to find people, like you, trying to flog their services. THIS IS AN ENCYCLOPEDIA. That means it's not a place to sell your products. If you feel something on this page is incorrect then please edit it. But be aware your edits will be copy edited by other people with a WP:NPOV who will remove any bias or commercial links.

ARLA offers advice to landlords and tennants on their website. What does your website offer apart from the opportunity for you to make money? simonthebold 19:52, 20 July 2006 (UTC)

I do not have a problem not having my website on the page. The only reason I put it on the site was the fact arla is commercial. If you truly wanted to put a non commercial link then put it to a news website. 11:37, 24 July 2006 86.131.99.78

ARLA is contextually relevant and offers non-commercial content, your website is purely a way for you to make more money. simonthebold 11:26, 24 July 2006 (UTC)

And please sign your comments with four tildes (~).