Talk:Brodnici
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Origin
The Brodnici was a Slavo-Romanian, Slavic or Turanian vassal state of Galicia.
Where did you read that they were Turanian? --Anittas 03:15, 15 January 2006 (UTC)
in the second reference (victor spinei) and in a high school romanian history book of the early 90s -- Anonimu 10:43, 15 January 2006 (UTC)
The Brodnici was a Slavo-Romanian, Slavic or Turanian vassal state of Galicia.
I want prove that: 1. it was a state 2. it was slavo-romanian or slavic or turanian 3. it was vassal of Galicia
The territory of Brodnici comprised of the southern part of what was to become the Romanian principality of Moldavia.
4. it was where you located it
Until then, I modified it.
- 1. i agree. i couldn't find any info that they formed a state
- 2. the second reference and romanian history books say it. until you come with some references that deny this, it should be here
- 3. since they fought at the battle of kalka along with a galician prince, maybe they were a kind of vassals
- 4. hungarian sources say that teutons extended their territory till the brodniks border, and most romanian historians think this reffers to southern moldova. the author of the second reference says that they lived in southern moldavia and southwestern part of ukraine ( black sea coast between dniester and dniepr) maybe we should say this. but if you find another reference that puts them elsewere, i'll agree to mention it in the article
Anonimu 14:54, 7 February 2006 (UTC)
- 2. romanian history books says that with what proves? reference to deny this? well, modern "romanian history books" say that they were romanian. and whatever the truth, how come the possibility that they were romanian is missing?
- 4. again, in a "romania history book" map, the brodnici appear is north-eastern Muntenia. But I also think that they lived somewhere in Buceac, southern Ukraine, along the mouth of the Danube and Dniester.
