Talk:Bexley Hall (disambiguation)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] prod discussion
This disambig page was where Bexley Hall ended up. I'm questioning changing that to a redirect to the stub about the seminary, when Bexley Hall (MIT) is actually a longer article/section. I'm also questioning if one is significantly more notable, an MIT dormatory or a Episcopal seminary. The person who made the move obviously thinks the seminary is more notable. I would argue that neither is significantly more notable. Having lived in the dorm for 4 years I'll admit a bias, but I suspect the dorm is known by more graduates than the seminary.--J Clear 23:43, 7 September 2006 (UTC)
- Three unrelated questions:
- Can I clarify that you are not questioning the deletion of the disambig page, (which you can do simply by deleting the prod template)? Since there are only 2 articles/sections, they can have top disambiguation, which I already included at the top of the Bexley Hall (Seminary) stub.
- Are you questioning what should go at Bexley Hall? I am sympathetic. Please have your say at Talk:Bexley Hall (Seminary)#Requested move
- I am afraid we may accidentally delete some authorship history that is needed for GFDL. I assume there must be an original article about the MIT hall before it was merged into List of MIT dormitories (now List of MIT undergraduate dormitories). However, I have not yet found it in the histories here. Was there an original article about the Bexley Hall (MIT), before this one in November 2004 here (with history here)?
- --Hroðulf (or Hrothulf) (Talk) 13:12, 8 September 2006 (UTC)
