Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/LUEshi (5th nomination)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents 1 All participants 1.1 Keep and variants thereof 1.1.1 Keep - Too many AfDs 1.1.2 Keep - notable meme 1.1.3 Keep - random 1.1.4 Merge 1.1.5 Other participation 2 Creating a Guideline for Memes

[edit] All participants

[edit] Keep and variants thereof

[edit] Keep - Too many AfDs

1. User:Alkivar
   
2. User:CorbinSimpson
   
3. User:Rhymeless
   
4. User:Wwwwolf
   plus "whole lotta noise" == meme
5. User:Sonicandfffan
   

[edit] Keep - notable meme

1. User:Yuckfoo
   
2. User:Badlydrawnjeff
   
3. User:Stevemcl
   
4. User:Stoph
   
5. User:Haikupoet
   also "double jeopardy"
6. User:Silensor
   
7. User:Tinyboy21vote)
   
8. User:Statikeffeck?LUEshi)
   
9. User:199.74.79.242
   

[edit] Keep - random

1. User:FlyingPenguins
   "looks notable"
2. User:BaronMasters?LUEshi)
   mentions GameFAQs, YTMND, etc
3. User:58.64.102.150
   "does someone hate this page?"
4. User:71.104.188.69
   "this meme isn't widespread"

[edit] Merge

1. User:Isotope23?LUEshi - Comment)
   
2. User:Wrathchild-K
   
3. User:Adrian
   
4. User:Douglasr007
   Note - "keep or merge"
5. User:Metropolitan90
   
6. User:Rimsy
   
7. User:The Soul Reaver
   Note - "or delete"
8. User:Shingen?LUEshi)
   

[edit] Other participation

1. User:62.30.72.236
   
2. User:68.35.69.119
   
3. User:Patashu?LUEshi)
   
4. User:Spiffy42
   
5. User:Toffile
   
6. User:WarpstarRider
   

[edit] Creating a Guideline for Memes

As a side note to this frustrating AfD, I've been trying to reach a consensus proposal for an internet meme guideline on Wikipedia at User:Badlydrawnjeff/Meme. We're trying to make some sort of guideline that can work independent of WP:WEB, which does a horrible job dealing with internet-only mediums. Any input from people would be quite helpful. --badlydrawnjeff (WP:MEME?) 14:45, 7 March 2006 (UTC)